ImageImageImage

Welcome Caleb Martin!

Moderators: HartfordWhalers, BullyKing, sixers hoops, Foshan, Sixerscan

M2J
Assistant Coach
Posts: 3,807
And1: 1,973
Joined: Sep 04, 2012

Re: Welcome Caleb Martin! 

Post#41 » by M2J » Sat Jul 13, 2024 8:44 pm

HotelVitale wrote:
M2J wrote:
Eyeamok wrote:How did he misjudge the market so badly and turn down the Heat offer ? $65 for 5 years vs $32 for 4 years. For a role player that is massive.


They look at what comparable or even worse guys are getting and think they can as well. A few players have fallen in that position this summer... This apron stuff is new and players feel they can opt out and at least receive the ntp MLE from some team and it's just not out there. Not an off season with lots of available money and it seems the middle class value is changing.

I mean some similar guys to Martin or Derrick Jones like DFS are getting 15 million without being super value players that were essentially playoff stars and helped their teams get to the finals in recent years.... And they're in their primes and believe they're close to or nearly as good as Josh Hart who makes 20 million. I was surprised to see DJJ sign quickly for about 10 million and not 13+ at least


Don't think it's the aprons or the current market really, more that like you said Caleb Martin's not a great guy to invest a ton of $ into. He's a 5th starter/solid rotation guy, we're rightfully excited for him given our situation but he's just a 10/4 guy on meh efficiency who's not particularly great at anything. He's going to help a team that already has like 5 good players, but he's not going to change the trajectory of an okay or blah team who needs to add a 3rd or 4th best player and he's not an elite role player either.

I think this type of 'middle class' has always been valued about like this. For the past 5 years there's been like 30-40 guys on maxes, then like 80-90 who make like $13-33m, then like 50 guys who make MLE-ish money ($8-12m). That's about 180-190 guys or 6 per team, and it makes sense as a range for teams to get their top 6 guys together. We can all think of a few examples of stpid overpays for guys as good or worse than Martin, but those are more exceptions to the norm. Martin's probably a little underpaid but he's around where he should be IMO.

(Also when he signed his current deal DFS was viewed as a significantly better defender and shooter than Martin is. DFS was just coming off two seasons of shooting 40% and was a highly valued 3D guy at the time, shine has come off him some in the last couple years).


Well there's big discrepancy with that middle class. Like Hart again is making 20 million... Older KCP just got a raise for similar numbers and he's more efficient.

However, to my point 25-year-old efficient enough 3 and D guy named Gary Trent jr. Who may be the best scoring and shooting guy in this discussion... Is possibly about to get a minimum deal. Not even being welcome back to his team where he fits the timeline for. But, most importantly is being paid 18.5 million this year and possibly going to sign a minimum deal at 25 this summer.


In other words with this middle class revelation, and guys like Brunson choosing to shave 100 million just to stay on the competitive team in the city he wants to be on and Paul George choosing to take the money to be able to he doesn't want to necessarily beyond... Albeit a better situation....,......…........................….,.................The owners won the previous CBA. Because they can always point to not necessarily the money, but instead the team management limitations as to why they didn't spend and why they have to negotiate.

As Lloyd stated teams are not behaving normally and that behavior says that unless they truly believe a move will get them exactly what their goals are... They aren't just throwing money around for Caleb Martin's of the world.
HotelVitale
RealGM
Posts: 16,885
And1: 12,012
Joined: Sep 14, 2007
Location: West Philly, PA

Re: Welcome Caleb Martin! 

Post#42 » by HotelVitale » Sat Jul 13, 2024 10:09 pm

M2J wrote:
HotelVitale wrote:
M2J wrote:
They look at what comparable or even worse guys are getting and think they can as well. A few players have fallen in that position this summer... This apron stuff is new and players feel they can opt out and at least receive the ntp MLE from some team and it's just not out there. Not an off season with lots of available money and it seems the middle class value is changing.

I mean some similar guys to Martin or Derrick Jones like DFS are getting 15 million without being super value players that were essentially playoff stars and helped their teams get to the finals in recent years.... And they're in their primes and believe they're close to or nearly as good as Josh Hart who makes 20 million. I was surprised to see DJJ sign quickly for about 10 million and not 13+ at least


Don't think it's the aprons or the current market really, more that like you said Caleb Martin's not a great guy to invest a ton of $ into. He's a 5th starter/solid rotation guy, we're rightfully excited for him given our situation but he's just a 10/4 guy on meh efficiency who's not particularly great at anything. He's going to help a team that already has like 5 good players, but he's not going to change the trajectory of an okay or blah team who needs to add a 3rd or 4th best player and he's not an elite role player either.

I think this type of 'middle class' has always been valued about like this. For the past 5 years there's been like 30-40 guys on maxes, then like 80-90 who make like $13-33m, then like 50 guys who make MLE-ish money ($8-12m). That's about 180-190 guys or 6 per team, and it makes sense as a range for teams to get their top 6 guys together. We can all think of a few examples of stpid overpays for guys as good or worse than Martin, but those are more exceptions to the norm. Martin's probably a little underpaid but he's around where he should be IMO.

(Also when he signed his current deal DFS was viewed as a significantly better defender and shooter than Martin is. DFS was just coming off two seasons of shooting 40% and was a highly valued 3D guy at the time, shine has come off him some in the last couple years).


Well there's big discrepancy with that middle class. Like Hart again is making 20 million... Older KCP just got a raise for similar numbers and he's more efficient.

However, to my point 25-year-old efficient enough 3 and D guy named Gary Trent jr. Who may be the best scoring and shooting guy in this discussion... Is possibly about to get a minimum deal. Not even being welcome back to his team where he fits the timeline for. But, most importantly is being paid 18.5 million this year and possibly going to sign a minimum deal at 25 this summer..


Nah, that's because teams don't think Gary Trent Jr is very good or reliable at a key role that's worth investing in. Seems like he's fallen out of that range of guys who's going to be one of your top 6 players, so no one wants to give him that $10m+. (He's also not a 3D guy since he's not at all a good defender, and he's also scored at well below average efficiency for his career and his volume dipped a lot last year too.)

Medium SGs are still getting paid, type of guys who'll be your 5th-8th best player. Buddy Hield wasn't a good player at all last year and he got $10m/season, Monk is better but still a limited scorer and he got $20m, I Joe got MLE money ($12m) to be a backup shooter, Royce O'Neale did too to be a meh 3Dish guy, Aaron Wiggins made $11m, Naji Marshall $9m, Gary Harris and Okogie $8m, etc. Melton coming off that scary and nagging back injury got $13m. Klay got like $17m for chrissake.

Teams were confident all those guys could play a key role for them in their rotation and be totally reliable in that, so they got that money. Teams aren't convinced Trent will do that so he's slipping through cracks. Same reasons Oubre did last year (basically, he's got talent but is he actually going to be good at anything for us?).
LeonJordanJr24
Starter
Posts: 2,289
And1: 770
Joined: Jul 18, 2013

Re: Welcome Caleb Martin! 

Post#43 » by LeonJordanJr24 » Sat Jul 13, 2024 10:47 pm

I'll take him lol

Return to Philadelphia 76ers