LongLiveHinkie wrote:Negrodamus wrote:LongLiveHinkie wrote:
It's up to the GM to see that the guy wasn't going to fit and project. Even having said that, I'm not even saying Hinkie made a grave mistake by not dealing him. However, if we have to play the blame game, which everyone seems to love doing, it is more Hinkie's fault than Colangelo's. I'm personally under the belief that it was just an F'd up situation, there was some stuff a bunch of people could have handled better, but it's still hard to greatly fault anyone. But people always love to trash BC for not getting great value for Okafor and Noel. They love it. But they never bring up Hinkie. I can tolerate criticizing BC if they're consistent. You can't rip BC without also being fair and cricitizing Hinkie. For drafting Okafor for starters. Could you imagine if it was Bryan who drafted him? Oh my... I can't even imagine. People are already trashing him for Fultz and we haven't even seen Fultz play yet.
The bottom line is I'm going to defend people who are treated unfairly and people take out their dislike of nepotism on Bryan and blaming him for Hinkie's departure when that was all Jerry and had nothing to do with Bryan. He was offered a job and he took it. Any of us would have done the same. People just have selective memories and pick and choose who they want to blame for what and the dogpiling always falls on Bryan and it just isn't fair and I'm gonna continue to defend him until people get consistent with their criticisms.
Weak answer to my questions, but that's alright.
I don't think anyone on here is going to say Hinkie was infallible. He certainly made mistakes. Creating an argument on the basis that there are posters that think Hinkie is infallible is a bit irritating. Similar to posters saying that there are fans on here wanting to see Fultz suck so they can be right. It's creating an argument that's doesn't exist but was formulated based on an emotional reaction to a point of view that one disagrees with. It derails debates on here and creates an insufferable atmosphere when posters say "I told you so" for a goal common fans hope the team achieve.
lol I'm not "creating an argument." People have been going hard after BC for how he's "ruined everything Hinkie has built" and when posters are going to say that I'm going to bring it full circle. It's just ridiculous and false, and an unfair biased take on BC who has done a good job.
Who is saying he "ruined everything Hinkie has built"? It's a quote that is incorrect, but I can't attribute it to anyone.
And you're free to have your opinion, but he has been mediocre at best. All of his transparency (lies) aside, his big signings in a year that was meant to be the turning point have underperformed (Amir and Redick). Wasted assets on Anzejs Pasecniks (I'll eat crow if he comes over here and does anything for us). Signed Gerald Henderson, Sergio Rodriguez and Bayless the offseason before who were/are both not contributors on winning teams.
And those are objective points of views. I'm not even going to get into the Fultz trade since it was my opinion that he wasn't a top three prospect of mine, much less a player to trade a future top 10 pick for. But I could be wrong.
I just know that we had one of the best cap situations this past offseason and we have struggling vets and a non-existent bench. I don't know who else to blame for that.