Post#18 » by jmon » Tue Aug 26, 2008 9:55 pm
Not to come in defending geiger or anything, but ROY normally goes to a guy who scores. Jason Kidd is the only rookie since Kidd's rookie year to not be in the top 3 in scoring and be a unanimous all-rookie team selection or something like that. That isn't ROY, but you get the idea I think. Anthony Randolph, in college, had a tough time scoring some points. His shooting efficiency was in the toilet and, if my memory serves, he feasted on the weak and played terribly against any real compeition.
I wouldn't have Randolph in my top 10. Then again, I didn't have him in my top 20 come draft night and really thought Maresse Speights wouldn't be there at our pick, so what do I know.
I would say Beasley is the obvious frontrunner personally. Followed by Mayo, and whoever else is in a great situation to get starters minutes.
Randolph is a project who is behind several people at PF. Turiaf and Harrington come to mind immediately.