Post#1858 » by Baphomet » Mon Feb 15, 2016 1:32 pm 
            
            
            La Liga is the best league in terms of quality, but as an entertainment proposition it's lacking. In that sense, I can see where mercgold is coming from.
Spanish teams play a highly technical brand of football that succeeds in European competitions. On that metric, it's the best league hands down, no other nation since England in the late 70s/early 80s has dominated in Europe quite so profoundly as what we're seeing from Spanish clubs now (particularly Sevilla in the EL). Given that inter-league competition is the only method we really have to quantify the quality of a league, La Liga is the 'best'.
I just think there's more to league analysis than saying x team from La Liga would beat x team from the Premier League. Yeah, it's probably true that Barca would obliterate Leicester, or Atletico would beat Spurs, but to look at it like that is reductive and ignores the entire process of football itself. This season in the Premier League represents a triumph for traditionally middling powers over established giants. After a slow start, the games are extremely exciting now and we have the most open title race in decades. Compare that to the usual Barca/Atleti/Real dominance.
At which point, it boils down to semantics. Yes, La Liga is the most successful league in Europe nowadays, so it's reasonable to say that it's the best league in terms of its European representatives. But it's also completely and utterly boring. If it's a choice between watching Barca having 70% possession in every match and 30 shots to 0 or watching a determined underdog like Leicester counter teams to death, I'll take the latter every time. It's not interesting seeing a superstar laden team like Barcelona or Real roll over teams of only basque players or financially threatened clubs. It's passé. It's meaningless. I'm not saying they should let them win, it's just a boring spectacle. They're a joy to watch in the CL against teams that can actually threaten them, but the league itself? Dull as dishwater. The PL was like this too until a few seasons ago.
I would like to add that obviously entertainment is subjective and all that's just my opinion. To many, seeing amazing players like Messi, Suarez, Ronaldo, Neymar etc. operating at or near their peaks is hugely entertaining in itself (and I don't disagree). But more often than not the result of these matches is a foregone conclusion. So I guess it's like, football as an artform with x factors vs. football with an overall narrative, an unpredictability, something delicately poised. I can see the appeal of both, and I know they're not mutually exclusive either, because the two often come together in El Clasico, Madrid derby, the CL, etc.