Phystic wrote:Ghost of Kleine wrote:
It's perfectly fine that we disagree on Aytons' impact. I'm cool with that. Now your argument for Aytons' impact is based upon the concept of Baynes moving to a bench role and thusly Frank's minutes being reduced will eliminate the lack of athleticism in the post, I can agree with that to a degree. And that as a result it would theoretically improve our defense in the post. So more or less addition by subtraction by removing Kaminskys' lack of athleticism right? However, That assertion is highly dependent upon Ayton returning as a dominant and vocal defensive leader whom would hold his entire team accountable on the defensive end. ( something Monty thus far has apparently been unable to do) Although it still wouldn't address Sarics' equally poor athleticism in the post, But to his credit he does give good effort. As evidenced by Baynes( who's already plays a lot more dominantly and physically in the post than what Ayton has shown thus far). And Baynes' inability to cover defensively for either Sarics' or Kaminskys' sub par defense. And Ayton is to this date still more of a finesse player, despite his quite impressive athletic advantages.
Please don't get me wrong, I would absolutely love for that to be the case, Wherein he utilized this time to become a dominant and vocal leader for this team. But I unfortunately have yet to see any evidence of that imminently coming to fruition. Although I will keep my fingers crossed. So, in my opinion, Even with Ayton returning, And Baynes moving to the bench and Kaminskys' role getting reduced, I still don't see how that will stop the constant dribble penetration and easy scoring at the rim, Unless Monty somehow gets everyone operating on their rotations properly. I mean obviously Ayton is mobile, But he can't always be everywhere at once to cover for any/all defensive lapses. So whilst I do fully agree with you on the improvement in our team's rebounding, I can't yet fully agree upon our post defense improvement until I see Aytons' newfound toughness and tenacity upon his return? Will he have it finally, Or will he revert back to his happy go lucky easygoing, " just want to make it to my 2nd contract" finesse persona? I guess we'll see in that regard....lol.
Also, I can of course agree with you that his rebounding will help create better looks on the perimeter for our shooters as a result of the gravity that he creates, and also that his rebounding MAY help us get in better defensive sets. However, getting into defensive sets is only half of the issue, as again it seems our basic defensive fundamentals are lacking and as a result, our rotations and help defense are terrible.
I just don't feel that Ayton alone, Or even with Baynes additionally staggered, Can just by their sheer presence, instill or repair the apparent lack of fundamentals defensively or the necessary tenacity, toughness and consistent effort that has been consistently lacking, Unless again, He has miraculously figured out how to become a dominant defender and a vocal leader for our team. And lead by example defensively. And IF he isn't that upon his return, And our team doesn't buy in like we did at the start of the season, Then he'll of course still make a good impact in terms of points and scoring on the glass. And Baynes will of course add toughness to our bench too. ( ***yet still not addressing our frontcourt defensive weaknesses at the 4). But overall, it still won't be enough to likely carry us into the playoffs. Again, I'm just not seeing how he alone can improve or fully fix or porous perimeter defense and lazy perimeter defensive rotations, That clearly stems from our team's constant apathetic and underwhelming effort. That's the responsibility of the coach, and ultimately the players to hold each other accountable and operate as a team. And we quite obviously should have at least made a few of those corrections by now, Even with Ayton out.
Now I understand that with a young team, certain aspects take time. But were almost 25 games in now, how much more time should it realistically take professional basketball players to learn and exhibit basic defensive fundamentals? Even worse, Why do they need this much time to be able to fully understand the importance of playing consistently with effort ? ( isn't that common sense in competition). Also, Aren't the majority of these issues such as boxing out, basic defensive rotations on the pick and roll, and perimeter defense schemes already things that they should have a full understanding of, as they're obviously implemented even at the high school and college levels of basketball.
So yes, I can agree that he'll absolutely improve certain areas of need. "But one man, or even two does not a team make" as they say. He may be able to carry us for periods on occasion. But without a concerted team effort, We'll still ultimately lose. And these are things that we should be overcoming even without him as a professional basketball team honestly.
That's the thing, I don't think Ayton needs to be come back as a defensive monster for his impact to have a ripple effect. With him back our front court rotations get some much needed flexibility. So we can do more matchup based rotations than we currently can. I didn't mean to imply Ayton's return will absolutely fix our defense and move us up the ranks. But I do think it'll improve, if for nothing else than DEFENSIVE REBOUNDING. Though As I said, Ayton's PnR defense is superior to Saric, Kaminsky and Baynes so that too should help as teams won't be able to attack him as aggressively in that regard. And I agree Saric's lack of athleticism is still an issue. But unfortunately the only remedy to that is to bench or trade him. I think we should look into moving him as with how Monty utilizes him he's redundant with Kaminsky. Saric offers more skills, than he currently allowed to show unfortunately.
You think 25 games is enough time for such a young team to completely come together in every regard? I wouldn't be even remotely shocked if we don't see massive improvement until the end of the year or beginning of next year. Our training camp had to introduce so many new things and players. And then we lost Ayton so everything that they did learn is now irrelevant as they are having to adjust. I think people need to be patient. We can all see the team has the tools, it's just a matter of giving them time to full gel. And that includes Monty. Coaches have to learn just like Players do. I'm shocked that once again so many people are hating on Monty. It's crazy how fickle fans can be.
Fair points really, and I will agree on your points that Ayton will be superior defensively in comparison to either Saric or Kaminsky if based upon athleticism alone. So there is hope there certainly. But I'll still have my strong concerns over the overall general lack of team defensive fundamentals. Such as lack of proper defensive rotations, helping out by hedging on pick n' roll dribble penetration to close down straight paths to the hoop as we don't have a competent rim protector. So obviously such basic defensive fundamentals become critically important in the absence of Ayton/ and or Baynes. The other issue I have with regards to the lack of basic defensive fundamentals is in the unwillingness or inability to box out! Yes Ayton will of course help somewhat in that regard, But is he going to be expected to be at the hoop 100% of the time to alleviate any rebounding issues? What if the opposing teams pull him out from the post? Who gets the rebound then.
My point is that these are team issues that should be taught and/or addressed in practice and through drills, not based under the assumption that one player alone or even two players regardless of athletic ability should have to consistently shoulder the burden alone. Rebound by committee as they say. And whilst I absolutely do agree that it does take time for a team and coach to get familiarized with each other and gel, Isn't that the purpose of the preseason and also training camp? Furthermore, the issues that I'm focusing on are what I consider to be basic fundamentals of basketball, That are taught even as early as high school and in college too.
These are professional basketball players. It's not like they just picked up a basketball for the first time this season. Are we supposed to just assume that they forgot how to box out for rebounds, play perimeter defense, guard on pick and rolls. Even kids playing pickup basketball or recreational ball players have a basic understanding of rebounding and defense.
So whilst it does of course take time for a team to gel together. Our critical issues are basic defensive fundamentals that any competent basketball player should be familiar with, especially veterans in the league. Now if it's a matter of changing defensive schemes, Then yes, there'll obviously be a period of adjustments. But there has yet to be any discernible evidence of a defensive scheme whatsoever. Moreover the general lack of effort or interest in even playing consistent defense and getting stops is an even bigger issue. So yes, it's completely honestly understandable that new defensive schemes will take some time to adjust to. But the complete lack of being engaged defensively is a matter of choice and commitment to puttting forth the effort. And if a team is not showing any real consistency defensively, Then it's again a coaching issue that should be being addressed accordingly in practice through defensive drills.
So I'm sorry if I seem impatient, But again, This team has had training camp, and preseason IN ADDITION TO the already 25 games into the season to address potential defensive issues and become familiar with one another. I mean it couldn't have been that big of an enigma that both Kaminsky and Saric are sub par defenders right? Or that boxing out for rebounds is actually important!
And they should have the ability to comprehend that in any competitive sport, It takes effort if you realistically expect to win right?I understand that building true chemistry takes time. And I'm not advocating for any immediate roster changes. I'm merely expecting to see some reasonable defensive adjustments made by team as a whole, just as every other nba team makes adjustments throughout the season to address their issues. Isn't that what coaches are paid to do? Help a team make adjustments in order to play at their optimal abilities.
Again, I'm not asking for perfection. Just modest improvements such as actually boxing out, getting engaged defensively, and playing with energy and consistent effort. I just don't see why it should take 25 games or longer to figure out how to play a competitive sport with energy or actually box out. Things that are again basic fundamentals of basketball. And things that are simply common sense. And as far as being professional basketball players that essentially are paid millions just to play, shouldn't that be incentive enough to play with actual consistent effort and energy? Ultimately, I hope that you're right man, And that the majority of our deficiencies will be remedied by Aytons' return. Also that Monty will straighten the team out and get them back into a positive rythym. Else the highlight of our season will be the first few games of the season, and pushing any aspirations back yet another year with hopes of returning to some modicum of relevance and respect.