ImageImageImage

2024-25 Season Discussion and Speculation

Moderators: bwgood77, lilfishi22, Qwigglez

BobbieL
RealGM
Posts: 15,353
And1: 8,997
Joined: Jun 24, 2009

Re: 2024-25 Season Discussion and Speculation 

Post#1841 » by BobbieL » Wed Jan 8, 2025 7:19 pm

bwgood77 wrote:
BobbieL wrote:
bwgood77 wrote:
Heck, I'd just do Hunter and Capela for KD straight up. But throw in picks and Daniels, I'll take it.


I would do that deal as well. I have no illusions of getting the total best value for Durant and Booker. But getting off the contracts, getting some good players back and with Booker if he goes to Houston, draft picks - would be the best thing moving forward.

Ishbia isn't stupid. I would think he knows what the smart thing to do is but will his ego and fandom take over. Thats what got the Suns to where they are now if reports are true - that he was at dinner with buddies and he made the trade with Joe Tsai himself. My theory,.. He wanted to impress his friends so he took it out to show how big he is.. "...hey I just bought a team and going to get Durant you MFers - drinks on me!!!"


Yeah, and he was probably like "I'll show that Dan Gilbert what a real NBA team looks like over the next few years!"

Anyway, regarding fandom, if a true fan, he would make the right moves and look toward the future. If we could get a few exciting young players, and our picks back, at least us struggling in games wouldn't be so painful and we could look forward to the future.


Strugging but probably getting better - seeing younger players grow together
Would have to fire James Jones though and see if Sam Presti wants a new job
ImNotMcDiSwear
General Manager
Posts: 8,287
And1: 6,411
Joined: Dec 14, 2013
 

Re: 2024-25 Season Discussion and Speculation 

Post#1842 » by ImNotMcDiSwear » Wed Jan 8, 2025 7:20 pm

Slim Charless wrote:
ImNotMcDiSwear wrote:I've been hoping we would blow this team up since our game 7 loss to the Mavs. Now, we can't blow it up unless the Rox are willing to send our picks back for Booker. But if you're the Rockets, do you go for it? Or does holding our picks guarantee they'll contend for the next 10+ years? What makes this nearly impossible is that because of Jalen Green's extension, his contract has a poison pill, so we can't take him back in any deal. They'd have to find a third team for him, which would be very difficult unless the Pistons would send us Ivey for him.

Ideally:
- Booker and O'Neale to HOU; Brooks, Adams, Sheppard, Ivey and picks to PHX; Green to DET
- Tyus Jones somewhere for 3 2nd rd picks
- Allen somewhere for a bad contract and a 1st
- Durant to the highest bidder
- Let Beal rot here in hell

Dream scenario: Loop WAS into the Durant trade so we get our picks back in exchange for whatever Durant would net us.

Problem #1 is that if Houston isn't interested, we are f*cked, pure and simple.
Problem #2 is that Ishbia thinks he's smarter than he is. I bet he'd prefer to trade for other teams picks and continue trying to win - and this simply will not work. If he tries to avoid the tank, he'll turn 10 years of sucking into 20. And at some point, we'll all be dead.


So you think Booker is worth only Brooks, Adams (who's a free agent btw and can't be moved) Reed Sheppard and our picks?

That's the BEST case scenario? Don't think Devin Booker is worth "slightly" more? Just a tad.


I think if we read the situation right, we'll know we're hostages to Houston. We need our picks back, not players. I'll take more picks than just ours if they're on offer. Houston should keep all the guys who can play. I'd rather have cap space (to trade for more picks) than good players.

Because of this, I think we'd need a really crazy package from another team to equal the value that Houston can offer. No other team's picks will be deep in the tank. We need OUR picks.

Rebuilding without tanking all but guarantees we won't win a title. I'll take the coinflips, please.
Slim Charless
RealGM
Posts: 11,704
And1: 7,431
Joined: May 10, 2019
   

Re: 2024-25 Season Discussion and Speculation 

Post#1843 » by Slim Charless » Wed Jan 8, 2025 7:27 pm

ImNotMcDiSwear wrote:
Slim Charless wrote:
ImNotMcDiSwear wrote:I've been hoping we would blow this team up since our game 7 loss to the Mavs. Now, we can't blow it up unless the Rox are willing to send our picks back for Booker. But if you're the Rockets, do you go for it? Or does holding our picks guarantee they'll contend for the next 10+ years? What makes this nearly impossible is that because of Jalen Green's extension, his contract has a poison pill, so we can't take him back in any deal. They'd have to find a third team for him, which would be very difficult unless the Pistons would send us Ivey for him.

Ideally:
- Booker and O'Neale to HOU; Brooks, Adams, Sheppard, Ivey and picks to PHX; Green to DET
- Tyus Jones somewhere for 3 2nd rd picks
- Allen somewhere for a bad contract and a 1st
- Durant to the highest bidder
- Let Beal rot here in hell

Dream scenario: Loop WAS into the Durant trade so we get our picks back in exchange for whatever Durant would net us.

Problem #1 is that if Houston isn't interested, we are f*cked, pure and simple.
Problem #2 is that Ishbia thinks he's smarter than he is. I bet he'd prefer to trade for other teams picks and continue trying to win - and this simply will not work. If he tries to avoid the tank, he'll turn 10 years of sucking into 20. And at some point, we'll all be dead.


So you think Booker is worth only Brooks, Adams (who's a free agent btw and can't be moved) Reed Sheppard and our picks?

That's the BEST case scenario? Don't think Devin Booker is worth "slightly" more? Just a tad.


I think if we read the situation right, we'll know we're hostages to Houston. We need our picks back, not players. I'll take more picks than just ours if they're on offer. Houston should keep all the guys who can play. I'd rather have cap space (to trade for more picks) than good players.

Because of this, I think we'd need a really crazy package from another team to equal the value that Houston can offer. No other team's picks will be deep in the tank. We need OUR picks.

Rebuilding without tanking all but guarantees we won't win a title. I'll take the coinflips, please.


So you wanna give Booker away for nothing.....so we can tank for years and years and years and in doing so get a player that HOPEFULLY as good as Booker is now?

Did I get that right? Cause you want Brooks and Reed (just sent back to the G League btw) and our picks for Booker. You also said you'd give KD away for the second round picks and swaps we gave up for Beal. Along with filler.

So to recap both Booker and KD traded and the entire grand return is:

Dillon Brooks
Reed Sheppard
Our picks

That's your version of best case scenario?
User avatar
mkot
RealGM
Posts: 11,423
And1: 3,144
Joined: Feb 07, 2006
Location: Eyes On The Bottom Line
 

Re: 2024-25 Season Discussion and Speculation 

Post#1844 » by mkot » Wed Jan 8, 2025 7:34 pm

BobbieL wrote:
Ishbia isn't stupid.


Yeah? I want an update from him on other 28 teams wanting to switch team with the Suns
Image
The 2005-06 Suns will always have a special place in my heart
sunsfan1o1
Rookie
Posts: 1,133
And1: 849
Joined: May 16, 2022

Re: 2024-25 Season Discussion and Speculation 

Post#1845 » by sunsfan1o1 » Wed Jan 8, 2025 7:34 pm

Why doesn’t anybody call out Kevin Durant and Devin Booker for their laziness and sloppy play? But quick to hate on Bradley Beal. Kevin Durant with all the turnovers, the awful passes never boxes out for rebound Devin Booker with all the bricks, turnovers, never boxes out for rebounds, play no defense. Those are the reasons why we’re losing not Bradley. It’s the same thing as when we had Ayton. Booker gets away with doing nothing but scoring and we blame everybody else.

As long as Booker is the number 1 or 2 guy this team will never win anything.

Booker is best served as a role player like on team USA.
BobbieL
RealGM
Posts: 15,353
And1: 8,997
Joined: Jun 24, 2009

Re: 2024-25 Season Discussion and Speculation 

Post#1846 » by BobbieL » Wed Jan 8, 2025 7:43 pm

ImNotMcDiSwear wrote:
Slim Charless wrote:
ImNotMcDiSwear wrote:I've been hoping we would blow this team up since our game 7 loss to the Mavs. Now, we can't blow it up unless the Rox are willing to send our picks back for Booker. But if you're the Rockets, do you go for it? Or does holding our picks guarantee they'll contend for the next 10+ years? What makes this nearly impossible is that because of Jalen Green's extension, his contract has a poison pill, so we can't take him back in any deal. They'd have to find a third team for him, which would be very difficult unless the Pistons would send us Ivey for him.

Ideally:
- Booker and O'Neale to HOU; Brooks, Adams, Sheppard, Ivey and picks to PHX; Green to DET
- Tyus Jones somewhere for 3 2nd rd picks
- Allen somewhere for a bad contract and a 1st
- Durant to the highest bidder
- Let Beal rot here in hell

Dream scenario: Loop WAS into the Durant trade so we get our picks back in exchange for whatever Durant would net us.

Problem #1 is that if Houston isn't interested, we are f*cked, pure and simple.
Problem #2 is that Ishbia thinks he's smarter than he is. I bet he'd prefer to trade for other teams picks and continue trying to win - and this simply will not work. If he tries to avoid the tank, he'll turn 10 years of sucking into 20. And at some point, we'll all be dead.


So you think Booker is worth only Brooks, Adams (who's a free agent btw and can't be moved) Reed Sheppard and our picks?

That's the BEST case scenario? Don't think Devin Booker is worth "slightly" more? Just a tad.


I think if we read the situation right, we'll know we're hostages to Houston. We need our picks back, not players. I'll take more picks than just ours if they're on offer. Houston should keep all the guys who can play. I'd rather have cap space (to trade for more picks) than good players.

Because of this, I think we'd need a really crazy package from another team to equal the value that Houston can offer. No other team's picks will be deep in the tank. We need OUR picks.

Rebuilding without tanking all but guarantees we won't win a title. I'll take the coinflips, please.


I am with you. . Need the draft picks back and hope the best for coin flips.

The Rockets will need to trade players -- Brooks, steven Adams, jeff Green - just to make the math work. But if Booker could get you Amen and draft picks - thats fine.

The future now is nothing. The Suns do not have one. At least moving Booker, Durant, Tyus Jones - they can start getting a future
User avatar
bwgood77
Global Mod
Global Mod
Posts: 98,249
And1: 61,046
Joined: Feb 06, 2009
Location: Austin
Contact:
   

Re: 2024-25 Season Discussion and Speculation 

Post#1847 » by bwgood77 » Wed Jan 8, 2025 7:47 pm

sunsbg wrote:How did we get to a fire sell ? "Big 3" but still talented players, Nurkic + Allen actually looked pretty good this time last season, two great A/TO PGs, two promising rookies, championship coach...the team shouldn't be that bad. It's mind boggling. Cursed ?


It is. I think it's a combination of things. Book and KD just won at the very highest level in the olympics and played all summer. I don't think that has increased their motivation because they feel like they just won everything (even though they were on the most stacked team you can be on), they make money, are doing what they love, and they just don't have that fire. They still put up nice stats, but I mean the win at all costs fire....try hard on defense all the time even when your shot isn't falling, etc.

And then I think as much as I like Tyus Jones, and Beal for that matter, promising Jones to start was probably a mistake. Now of course they probably don't get him if they don't start him, but they did have Morris.

Because last year they were like 15-15 before Beal came back completely from the back spasms, and they finished 49-33.

So with Beal, they were 34-18. They were really good when all of them played.

They did turn it over a lot, but it worked. It also helped that Allen was on fire from 3.

This year I think with Tyus they maybe got too small, as has been mentioned. Allen is only 6-4, but a few inches, so I'm not sure it's only that, but I think also even though that him handling the ball helps with turnovers, I think when you have 3 guys like our big 3 that are good with the ball in their hands, and creating for himself, having that pure PG who creates for others, isn't nearly as impactful.

Everyone mentions Beal with the bench, which works as well, but I honestly think Tyus' talents would better be utilized if he played most of his minutes with guys like Royce, Allen, Dunn, etc....with maybe only one or two of the big 3, and not all 3 of them. He initiates offense and offense wasn't our problem.

I think we maybe would have been best served to start Beal/Book/Royce/KD/Plumlee...and now maybe Dunn that he has proven himself, and then let Tyus come in when Beal rested and let Tyus play as stars sub out and Allen, Dunn (or Royce), Oso, etc, come in.

Of course that puts Morris further down the pecking order, and it was great to get both but I'm not sure that was our biggest need.

I don't think initiating more offense was what we needed necessarily.

I think after watching it though, and knowing what I know now, that if Tyus starts, it is best for Beal to come off the bench, as I don't think you need 4 offensive initiators at once. Nurkic is even kind of a 5th...so Plumlee should work better.

But I think mainly KD and Book are just not totally into it even though they are our best two players and put up great numbers. I don't think they have enough fire to overcome our weaknesses at C, athleticism, defense and size.
User avatar
mkot
RealGM
Posts: 11,423
And1: 3,144
Joined: Feb 07, 2006
Location: Eyes On The Bottom Line
 

Re: 2024-25 Season Discussion and Speculation 

Post#1848 » by mkot » Wed Jan 8, 2025 7:50 pm

sunsfan1o1 wrote:Why doesn’t anybody call out Kevin Durant and Devin Booker for their laziness and sloppy play? But quick to hate on Bradley Beal. Kevin Durant with all the turnovers, the awful passes never boxes out for rebound Devin Booker with all the bricks, turnovers, never boxes out for rebounds, play no defense. Those are the reasons why we’re losing not Bradley. It’s the same thing as when we had Ayton. Booker gets away with doing nothing but scoring and we blame everybody else.

As long as Booker is the number 1 or 2 guy this team will never win anything.

Booker is best served as a role player like on team USA.


Your first guy being the number one guy is so critical for team success.

If you look at the champions of the past season.

Boston - Jayson Tatum
Denver - Nikola Jokic
Warriors - Curry

And if you determine early on that your first guy can't be your alpha, you be like the Lakers and Raptors, take a gamble and trade him for an established winner.

I'm not saying we should be trading Book instead of Mikal/Cam, but it's pretty obvious that Book is not THAT guy, and KD ain't it either. And our team went all-in with the two and now we are looking at decade of disaster.
Image
The 2005-06 Suns will always have a special place in my heart
BobbieL
RealGM
Posts: 15,353
And1: 8,997
Joined: Jun 24, 2009

Re: 2024-25 Season Discussion and Speculation 

Post#1849 » by BobbieL » Wed Jan 8, 2025 7:53 pm

mkot wrote:
sunsfan1o1 wrote:Why doesn’t anybody call out Kevin Durant and Devin Booker for their laziness and sloppy play? But quick to hate on Bradley Beal. Kevin Durant with all the turnovers, the awful passes never boxes out for rebound Devin Booker with all the bricks, turnovers, never boxes out for rebounds, play no defense. Those are the reasons why we’re losing not Bradley. It’s the same thing as when we had Ayton. Booker gets away with doing nothing but scoring and we blame everybody else.

As long as Booker is the number 1 or 2 guy this team will never win anything.

Booker is best served as a role player like on team USA.


Your first guy being the number one guy is so critical for team success.

If you look at the champions of the past season.

Boston - Jayson Tatum
Denver - Nikola Jokic
Warriors - Curry

And if you determine early on that your first guy can't be your alpha, you be like the Lakers and Raptors, take a gamble and trade him for an established winner.

I'm not saying we should be trading Book instead of Mikal/Cam, but it's pretty obvious that Book is not THAT guy, and KD ain't it either. And our team went all-in with the two and now we are looking at decade of disaster.



Booker was at his best with Paul being the Alpha force on the team with guys like Ayton, Bridges and CamJo, Crowder, Payne around him

Even though he is the high scored - he is not the alpha personality that is needed.

Trade him and Durant. I think Durant is the same way
Slim Charless
RealGM
Posts: 11,704
And1: 7,431
Joined: May 10, 2019
   

Re: 2024-25 Season Discussion and Speculation 

Post#1850 » by Slim Charless » Wed Jan 8, 2025 7:54 pm

BobbieL wrote:
ImNotMcDiSwear wrote:
Slim Charless wrote:
So you think Booker is worth only Brooks, Adams (who's a free agent btw and can't be moved) Reed Sheppard and our picks?

That's the BEST case scenario? Don't think Devin Booker is worth "slightly" more? Just a tad.


I think if we read the situation right, we'll know we're hostages to Houston. We need our picks back, not players. I'll take more picks than just ours if they're on offer. Houston should keep all the guys who can play. I'd rather have cap space (to trade for more picks) than good players.

Because of this, I think we'd need a really crazy package from another team to equal the value that Houston can offer. No other team's picks will be deep in the tank. We need OUR picks.

Rebuilding without tanking all but guarantees we won't win a title. I'll take the coinflips, please.


I am with you. . Need the draft picks back and hope the best for coin flips.

The Rockets will need to trade players -- Brooks, steven Adams, jeff Green - just to make the math work. But if Booker could get you Amen and draft picks - thats fine.

The future now is nothing. The Suns do not have one. At least moving Booker, Durant, Tyus Jones - they can start getting a future


This a terrible trade and McD-much like the real McD has no idea how any of this works lol.

For starters, both of you need to stop putting Adams in the trade, he's a FA this summer and can go wherever he wants. Exact same situation with Jeff Green. This trade wont happen till the summer when both of those guys are gone.

-Second, Jalen Green has a poison pill contract and while that sucks now, it ends in the summer where his salary goes to roughly 33 million. He's an obvious move for the Rockets as they cant afford both him and Booker.

-Third and most important-if you really think that Booker is worth this little then you have the same level of value as Ishbia. This is actually worse value than Ishbia gave CamJo and Mikal cause at least Booker has made multiple all NBA teams.

Good lord guys. I'm not trying to be mean but come on here.

:roll:
User avatar
bwgood77
Global Mod
Global Mod
Posts: 98,249
And1: 61,046
Joined: Feb 06, 2009
Location: Austin
Contact:
   

Re: 2024-25 Season Discussion and Speculation 

Post#1851 » by bwgood77 » Wed Jan 8, 2025 7:54 pm

Slim Charless wrote:
ImNotMcDiSwear wrote:
Slim Charless wrote:
So you think Booker is worth only Brooks, Adams (who's a free agent btw and can't be moved) Reed Sheppard and our picks?

That's the BEST case scenario? Don't think Devin Booker is worth "slightly" more? Just a tad.


I think if we read the situation right, we'll know we're hostages to Houston. We need our picks back, not players. I'll take more picks than just ours if they're on offer. Houston should keep all the guys who can play. I'd rather have cap space (to trade for more picks) than good players.

Because of this, I think we'd need a really crazy package from another team to equal the value that Houston can offer. No other team's picks will be deep in the tank. We need OUR picks.

Rebuilding without tanking all but guarantees we won't win a title. I'll take the coinflips, please.


So you wanna give Booker away for nothing.....so we can tank for years and years and years and in doing so get a player that HOPEFULLY as good as Booker is now?

Did I get that right? Cause you want Brooks and Reed (just sent back to the G League btw) and our picks for Booker. You also said you'd give KD away for the second round picks and swaps we gave up for Beal. Along with filler.

So to recap both Booker and KD traded and the entire grand return is:

Dillon Brooks
Reed Sheppard
Our picks

That's your version of best case scenario?


HIs point is the most important pieces by far are getting OUR picks because they are tied to how bad our team is (will be) and we will certainly be last in the west and bottom 3 or 4 team. I would love to get Sengun, would really like Smith Jr, or Thompson.

However, each of our picks is more valuable than Green, Eason, Sheppard, or any of those guys, and maybe more valuable than ANY of their players...because they could all quite easily be #1 or at least top 4 picks.

If you trade Booker elsewhere and maybe get a better player but get a few picks that are that teams, and Book makes that team good or top tier, the picks are not that valuable at all. Like not even lotto...almost maybe like 2nd rounders.

That's a HUGE difference.
User avatar
Ghost of Kleine
Master of Tweets
Posts: 16,372
And1: 9,061
Joined: Apr 13, 2012

Re: 2024-25 Season Discussion and Speculation 

Post#1852 » by Ghost of Kleine » Wed Jan 8, 2025 7:59 pm

Read on Twitter
Image
dremill24
Assistant Coach
Posts: 3,924
And1: 3,211
Joined: Jan 11, 2016
Contact:

Re: 2024-25 Season Discussion and Speculation 

Post#1853 » by dremill24 » Wed Jan 8, 2025 8:00 pm

Saberestar wrote:
dremill24 wrote:
Saberestar wrote:Yeah, I agree with you, obviously I would prefer to get Jalen Green + Whitmore (or Eason) + all our picks back.

My first impression is that Jalen Green has a HIGH value around the league with the way he is playing at 22 years old (23 next month) and on a fair long- term deal.

The difference between Jalen Green and Booker aren't three FRP + young prospect IMO.


I think you're overrating Green. He certainly has amazing physical tools and is still quite young, but there are reasons he wasnt a no-brainer max extension and there are still those who think hes a bad contract. He could have a Booker-like ceiling but still has a long way to go. I think Houston would jump at the chance to do Green, Whitmore, and the picks since it sends away their least favorite prospects.

IDK... he has fire in his game and he has improved on defense.

One of my favorite non-Suns players so probably I am overrating him and I am not self aware of it.


He's got potential for sure. He offers upside for rim pressure like we haven't had since like...Amar'e. His shooting is still just theoretical, he doesn't really make anything right now. But he could. I'm not nearly as sold on his defense as you.

If we go this route I wouldn't be opposed to taking him back but if he's counted at extremely high value, that would dilute the rest of the package we're getting. I'll take him but I dunno that I'd want him as the main chip coming back. For example, if I could only get one of Jabari or Jalen, I'm not sure I pick Jalen. Jalen makes so much more sense from Houston's side but I'm just not sure I'm sold. Could we get both if we let them keep one of the picks? I might do that lol

I had Amen, Jabari, and the picks as my Booker package before the season started. Unfortunately it looks like the Rockets and especially Amen have improved way too much (and Booker's stock might be going down too) for that to be realistic anymore.

It will be an interesting offseason. I'm gonna have fun theory crafting the Booker/KD packages that can help start the climb out of the gutter. I think even if you don't get your picks back, there are paths (just less traditional/straightforward). But of course we'll just be trying to run it back with Butler citing that we didn't develop the necessary chemistry instead.
Trying out this Substack thing. Suns and NBA thoughts. Check it out: https://hoopsnexus.substack.com/
User avatar
Ghost of Kleine
Master of Tweets
Posts: 16,372
And1: 9,061
Joined: Apr 13, 2012

Re: 2024-25 Season Discussion and Speculation 

Post#1854 » by Ghost of Kleine » Wed Jan 8, 2025 8:03 pm

Read on Twitter
Image
Fo-Real
General Manager
Posts: 9,799
And1: 5,503
Joined: Mar 21, 2009
     

Re: 2024-25 Season Discussion and Speculation 

Post#1855 » by Fo-Real » Wed Jan 8, 2025 8:11 pm

Ghost of Kleine wrote:
Read on Twitter


They would beat us with him.
User avatar
Ghost of Kleine
Master of Tweets
Posts: 16,372
And1: 9,061
Joined: Apr 13, 2012

Re: 2024-25 Season Discussion and Speculation 

Post#1856 » by Ghost of Kleine » Wed Jan 8, 2025 8:15 pm

Read on Twitter
Image
User avatar
mkot
RealGM
Posts: 11,423
And1: 3,144
Joined: Feb 07, 2006
Location: Eyes On The Bottom Line
 

Re: 2024-25 Season Discussion and Speculation 

Post#1857 » by mkot » Wed Jan 8, 2025 8:29 pm

Ghost of Kleine wrote:
Read on Twitter


Just admit defeat FFS :nonono:
Image
The 2005-06 Suns will always have a special place in my heart
Slim Charless
RealGM
Posts: 11,704
And1: 7,431
Joined: May 10, 2019
   

Re: 2024-25 Season Discussion and Speculation 

Post#1858 » by Slim Charless » Wed Jan 8, 2025 8:29 pm

Ghost of Kleine wrote:
Read on Twitter


Sweet Jesus. Please. Hold strong Bradley
User avatar
sunskerr
General Manager
Posts: 9,811
And1: 5,986
Joined: Feb 20, 2010
 

Re: 2024-25 Season Discussion and Speculation 

Post#1859 » by sunskerr » Wed Jan 8, 2025 8:40 pm

bwgood77 wrote:Oh, they'd for sure give you Eason before Smith. Are you sure you're not thinking of this from a fantasy perspective and you need steals?


Steals are massively underrated in value defensively in the modern day just gonna throw that in there. There is a reason OKC plays for them. If you can steal the ball and play disciplined defense you are a huge asset. Tari can do that.

Also a lot of players that gamble poorly get sussed out quickly due to better coaching and analytics so they end up being played less than in years past (i.e. there's a higher chance a player with good steals is a good defender now than in the past). He also rates higher than Jabari in the three advanced stats I like to most (EPM, DARKO, LEBRON). Also a great rebounder who can sort of stretch the floor.

If you like Bari simply because he is taller and you think he has a chance at being a star then that's fine and a perfectly valid way to build a team(going after bigger upside prospects). I wouldn't be bummed or anything with Jabari coming back. It's just that if you held a gun to my head to ask me who is better in five years, based on the model in my head how I evaluate guys, I'd say Eason. But it wouldn't be like a sure thing (none of this kind of stuff is, especially when it comes to lower usage young guys).

bwgood77 wrote:Why are you so much higher on Amen than Jabari? I figured they'd be higher on Jabari than Amen. He's younger, he's a PF who can hit the 3. He's not a great 3 pt shooter, but you have Amen who is older, is a wing, cannot shoot the 3 (under 25%), is a bad FT shooter (sub 70%). He's a nice athlete but a Jabari skill set is a bit more rare. Thompson can only score right around the rim. Nice defender and finisher but I don't see why his value would be really high and Jabari low. Maybe if he was younger.


I think you are focusing on Amens negatives too harshly. Amen rates ridiculously well in his limited minutes going back to last year in my 3 favorite metrics. This year he took a big leap.

On court he is an elite rebounder. Elite at the fast break. He can handle the ball. His vision is pretty good as well. That overall offensive skill means he has a chance at playing point guard, which separates him from his brother who doesn't have those things.

He also is not just a nice defender, but is, again, ELITE. So we have these holes in his game, namely shooting, but all his strengths are advanced/good or near elite to elite level. That's why I compare him to Giannis - the skill profile is the same. The stat lines come out similar as well, though he may never be as invincible in the paint like Giannis.

Also when it comes to expert opinions on developing players in real life and dynasty there is a reason I actually do listen to guys like Josh Lloyd (and other people should too) for input on young prospects...if a guy rates highly in dynasty it typically means they have a development path that tracks with real life basketball skill and thus long-term sticking power in the league. I.e. in general a guy rated highly in dynasty is going to be rated that highly in part because he has real life potential, not just fancy stats.
sunsbg
Head Coach
Posts: 6,375
And1: 5,452
Joined: Feb 29, 2016

Re: 2024-25 Season Discussion and Speculation 

Post#1860 » by sunsbg » Wed Jan 8, 2025 9:17 pm

What a soap opera this team has become.

Return to Phoenix Suns