bwgood77 wrote:TheLogician wrote:bwgood77 wrote:
I think many or most of those who have Doncic over Ayton would have Ayton #1 if they thought he'd be anything like Embiid. He may be like him offensively. You can't just assume a guy that was a questionable defender in college will be a legit DPOY candidate big.
I get the arguments that he has the tools to become potentially an adequate defender or maybe even a good one, but you saying that would be like someone saying "Anyone who wants Ayton over Doncic, watch Harden and tell me you'd rather have Ayton over Doncic."
Embiid was unproven on offense at Kansas. He mostly just dunked lobs. Yet now he is a two-way player. Same potential for Ayton.
Sure, I'd like to assume whoever we draft will reach one of their comp who is among the best players in the league. Those who don't want Durant, watch Porter and tell me you'd rather have _____________. For those who don't want Trae, watch Curry and tell me you'd rather have __________.
I mean that'd be great if these guys all end up superstars. But projecting one guy to be one to take him over another when people seem to compare all these guys to various league superstars is a stretch.
I mean I have those guys as pretty much a toss up, and it would be certainly hard to pass on Ayton at 1, and I have no say in the matter, so if our choice is one of Ayton/Doncic at 1/2 I'll be happy.
I wasn't even using Embiid as a comp. I said bigs are still relevant and Embiid is proving my point despite his goggle mask. There is good reason to expect Ayton to be an impactful big, so this is not a good hill to die on. Much safer assumption than your Doncic-Harden comp.
























