bwgood77 wrote:Revived wrote:bwgood77 wrote:
I don't know if Young or Doncic could start as a rookie on a playoff team but they are both a heck of a lot better prospects than Jamal freakin Murray was. He doesn't even really pass. What did he average in college, like 2 assists per game?
Murray has the talent to be a really good PG. His passing isn’t much of an issue considering that many of the better PGs today are mostly score first PGs anyway. His assist numbers were low in college because he played next to Fox who was their main distributor while Murray played the 2. And his college assist numbers are irrelevant anyway considering the reigning MVP, who now averages like 10+ in every season, only averaged like 3 assists a game in college and 2 assists per game for his college career.
Jamal Murray is a SG who has mostly struggled shooting. He averages 2.6 apg and 2 to pg in his second year. He is just not a good passer. Westbrook averaged 8 apg and 3.3 to pg in his second year.
Murray was the 7th pick in a pretty bad draft after the top 1 or 2 picks. Murray wasn't even in the same ball park as a prospect as Doncic or Young. Young took an unranked team to one of the best teams in the country, is one of the best shooters in college history, and leads the nation in assists with double digit assists (or rather 9.8 at the moment), which is VERY rare in college. Doncic is the best european prospect ever.Spoiler:
Sorry, man, but you are having one of your hyperbolic moments again. He's not even close to being the best shooter...even this season.
http://cbbref.com/tiny/QL8Cg
And that's with a couple of qualifiers added like at least 11 PPG and 4 APG Guards.
He's great and deserves the attention he's getting, but I'd term it more as one of the highest rising prospects ever, and one of the most prolific scoring college PGs ever, but best shooters in college history?? Not really.
And regarding Doncic? Well, that's highly subjective. It seems every year there's a new 'best prospect ever' in some regard. I know the media types are throwing around the 'best Euro prospect ever' as well, and they will again...
“Personally, I would take Darko ahead of LeBron James because he has more skills and can play more positions. There are very few can’t-miss players, but I have no doubt that Darko is a can’t-miss player.”
Not to mention, Pau Gasol, Tony Parker and Dirk Nowitzki. Problem is, back then, the 'Euro-Prospect Hype-Train' had yet to leave the station. It hasn't been but 8-10 years since European players have been REALLY scouted and hyped. Sure, they have for a long time, but not nearly, not close to the extent they are now.
So while Doncic might be the most 'hyped' European prospect ever, put him back 25 years, or put Gasol, Dirk, Parker, Vlade, etc with Doncic today?? Well, I'm not certain he'd be placed above them. And even if you'd want to argue that he would be, he's gonna have a hard time matching:
Gasol: 18.3 points, 9.2 rebounds, 3.3 assists, 1.6 blocks, 51.5 percent shooting, 21.5 PER, 113.9 win shares
Parker: 17.1 points, 3.0 rebounds, 6.0 assists, 49.5 percent shooting, 19.1 PER, 96.6 win shares
Dirk: 22.5 points, 8.1 rebounds, 2.6 assists, 47.7 percent shooting, 38.4 percent three-point shooting, 23.5 PER, 185.9 win shares + an MVP



















