bwgood77 wrote:MrMiyagi wrote:Dual wrote:In my case it was for all the hype mostly. And yes, the treatment of the timelines was so poor that first time I didnt know we were in the past after some minutes in hehe.
I guess is ok, also didnt like much the acting, starting with the main character.
And last but not least:
I'm not really sure exactly what your spoiler tagged comment means or why it is tagged as a spoiler. I guess I can see how someone can walk away from watching this and think "wow, not much happened" but I personally would disagree.
I don't really care about two timelines, as I have no problem following that stuff. But is it compelling, interesting. It's weird reading about the Mandalorian. I am a big Star Wars fan and I haven't watched it but I hear people saying it's not that great except the little Yoda is cute. That sounds very strange to me. Doesn't sound like that would be enough to keep watching it. Do either of them really leave you wondering at the end of the episode "I really want to see what's going to happen next" or "This is really interesting...lets see how this develops."?
I enjoy both, but differently. Mando is easy watching. There's not a lot to keep track of, you just get to tune in and see some cool Star Wars stuff for 40ish minutes. It's kind of like a mobile game on your phone. It's simple, enjoyable, passes the time, usually easy to navigate (tap tap tap). Witcher is a little more work (it's not hard to follow per se, but there are more characters and dynamics great and small), which I would say is more akin to a PC/Console game. You might need to remember which button does what thing because it's been a while and you need a refresher before you progress in the actual game, but once you're in it there's a bit more satisfaction than the tap tap tap of a mobile game.
I'd say that Witcher, for me, would probably be more likely to enduce those questions/reactions than Mando. This is just one man's biased opinion, of course. I've already been hooked by the other mediums of Witcher tales and I think the series captures much of the allure of it's source materials, whereas Mando is brand new and the first episode hit much differently than each successive one has, just because it could have gone in so many different directions after episode 1. It has since narrowed, and I'm not quite as compelled.