REDDzone wrote:He may be when you look at pure resume. For me personally though IDK. He has 4-5 huge wins on his resume including Chandler/Pettis/Melendez/RDA. I thought he lost two of those for sure (Pettis and Chandler) and Melendez was razor thin. Obviously RDA was a great win for him.
Speaking of, I wonder if Alvarez winning the title gives Cerrone motivation to come back to LW? Wasn't so long ago when Donald gave Eddie a kickboxing lesson.

There are a lot of those when you start looking at the actual fights and not just the records.
If Edgar is 1-1 against BJ instead of 2-0, that's a big hit to his resume. Actually, if Edgar loses the first fight to Penn, he doesn't get the second one, so what is his career like?
Bendo's wins over Edgar and Gil (at least) were very close, and arguably went the wrong way in a few cases. Those three wins really push him towards the top of this group when without them he'd be at the bottom or out of it completely.
I'll give Pettis a lot of credit for having finishes in many of his key wins.