Boxing Thread 4.0

Moderator: lilfishi22

Knickfan1982
Lead Assistant
Posts: 5,797
And1: 2,158
Joined: Mar 19, 2016
       

Re: Boxing Thread 4.0 

Post#2281 » by Knickfan1982 » Mon May 9, 2022 9:07 pm

Butch718 wrote:Not surprised by the outcome. All true boxing heads know that Bivol was a legit 175 pounder, which Canelo is not. The fact that people are calling this a big upset annoys me because it’s disrespectful to Bivol. Canelo is lucky that it wasn’t Betterbiev because he would have gotten knocked out.

This doesn’t take away anything from Canelo. He dared to be great and fell short. It’s time for him to lock up some big fights at 168, where he belongs.

Also, the 115-113 scores were atrocious. They wanted to give Canelo that fight. Bivol won 118-110 or 117-111 at worst.



If Bivol hadn't looked pedestrian in his previous 2 fights he would have never gotten the call. Congratulations to him on coming away with a win despite the judges best efforts to screw him.
Why rely on nuance, facts and logic when you can bludgeon the other side with mindless repetition of "Duuur McDaniel's has potential :tooth and still be treated as if you were reasonable.
User avatar
cowboyronnie
RealGM
Posts: 30,215
And1: 1,465
Joined: Feb 20, 2004

Re: Boxing Thread 4.0 

Post#2282 » by cowboyronnie » Mon May 9, 2022 11:41 pm

Knickfan1982 wrote:
Butch718 wrote:Not surprised by the outcome. All true boxing heads know that Bivol was a legit 175 pounder, which Canelo is not. The fact that people are calling this a big upset annoys me because it’s disrespectful to Bivol. Canelo is lucky that it wasn’t Betterbiev because he would have gotten knocked out.

This doesn’t take away anything from Canelo. He dared to be great and fell short. It’s time for him to lock up some big fights at 168, where he belongs.

Also, the 115-113 scores were atrocious. They wanted to give Canelo that fight. Bivol won 118-110 or 117-111 at worst.



If Bivol hadn't looked pedestrian in his previous 2 fights he would have never gotten the call. Congratulations to him on coming away with a win despite the judges best efforts to screw him.


Bivol is 31-y-o, a baby in the sport. Why would Canelo's team have thought there was a trend in lower quality performance when they had seen him obliterate people like Smith? It's not like he was over the hill.

It's just wild speculation to think Canelo's team only took this because they thought there was weakness. I mean, for one thing, they'd be idiots to think there was weakness and that Bivol wouldn't get up for a fight with Canelo. Do you think they're idiots?
Hi love, bye love, I will miss my love.
Knickfan1982
Lead Assistant
Posts: 5,797
And1: 2,158
Joined: Mar 19, 2016
       

Re: Boxing Thread 4.0 

Post#2283 » by Knickfan1982 » Tue May 10, 2022 3:02 am

cowboyronnie wrote:
Knickfan1982 wrote:
Butch718 wrote:Not surprised by the outcome. All true boxing heads know that Bivol was a legit 175 pounder, which Canelo is not. The fact that people are calling this a big upset annoys me because it’s disrespectful to Bivol. Canelo is lucky that it wasn’t Betterbiev because he would have gotten knocked out.

This doesn’t take away anything from Canelo. He dared to be great and fell short. It’s time for him to lock up some big fights at 168, where he belongs.

Also, the 115-113 scores were atrocious. They wanted to give Canelo that fight. Bivol won 118-110 or 117-111 at worst.



If Bivol hadn't looked pedestrian in his previous 2 fights he would have never gotten the call. Congratulations to him on coming away with a win despite the judges best efforts to screw him.


Bivol is 31-y-o, a baby in the sport. Why would Canelo's team have thought there was a trend in lower quality performance when they had seen him obliterate people like Smith? It's not like he was over the hill.

It's just wild speculation to think Canelo's team only took this because they thought there was weakness. I mean, for one thing, they'd be idiots to think there was weakness and that Bivol wouldn't get up for a fight with Canelo. Do you think they're idiots?



Because that's what Canelo does. His recent run that everyone of his fan boys talk so highly about....its all built on fighting guys when they show signs of slipping.

Could have fought GGG anytime after Canelo won the middleweight belt from Miguel Cotto in late 2015. GGG was his mandatory. When did Canelo fight him....after GGG struggled with Daniel Jacobs and Kell Brook had some success against him.

After the GGG fights Canelo moved up. Could have fought any of the 168 lb champions right then and there. Chose to fight secondary titlist Rocky Felding. Then he went back down to fight Danny Jacobs. After that fight he jumped all the way to 175 to fight Sergei Kovalev less than 3 months after Kovalev almost got knocked out by Anthony Yarde. His next fight....against Callum Smith...the real holder of the belt that the previously mentioned Rocky Felding held a secondary version of. Why did he choose to fight Callum Smith then. In Callum Smith's previous fight he looked terrible and many believe he got a gift decision against John Ryder. He then chose to fight Billy Joe Saunders and Caleb Plant. Nothing wrong with unifying the titles except...Billy Jo Saunders was a champion at 160 when Canelo was champion at 160 but never got the fight and wasn't too far removed from a flat performance against an unheralded opponent on the Logan Paul/KSI card.

With Bivol and Beterbiev both looking underwhelming in the more recent fights one of them getting selected as Canelo's next opponent wasn't too much of a shock. It was also not too shocking that he also decided to finally give GGG the trilogy fight the world had been asking for. It just so happened to be scheduled 4 years to the day of their previous fight and only after GGG struggled in 2 of his past three fights including what some would consider winning a gift decision against Sergei Derevychenko.

Meanwhile undefeated young guns Jermall Charlo and Demetrious Andrade have both held belts at the same time and in the same division as Canelo in two different weight classes are poised to make jumps to 168 themselves. Canelo could have fought them at any point but chose not to try and unify until he got to 168lb division. Must have been a coincidence. Another coincidence, when he decided against fighting GGG after the Cotto fight Canelo moved back down to 154 for a title fight. The shot was for a vacant title that was recently stripped from Andrade.

Its a pattern dude. Canelo has accomplished a lot but he very carefully chooses whom he fights when. Let's face it, he's not a natural red head. He's a blonde but all his cherry picking has made him look like a red head.
Why rely on nuance, facts and logic when you can bludgeon the other side with mindless repetition of "Duuur McDaniel's has potential :tooth and still be treated as if you were reasonable.
User avatar
cowboyronnie
RealGM
Posts: 30,215
And1: 1,465
Joined: Feb 20, 2004

Re: Boxing Thread 4.0 

Post#2284 » by cowboyronnie » Tue May 10, 2022 10:36 am

LOL @ Charlo being undefeated. Damn, did he really just put together a streak (largely, UDs) against Montiel, Hogan, Adams, Korobov, Centeno Jr., and Heiland. This guy's taking on all the big names, leaving no stone unturned!!!

If Charlo is so **** good why doesn't *he* take on Andrade, Benavidez, Lemieux, GGG, BJS, or any of the other awesome 160-168ers??? The man is fighting C fighters (short of Derevchenko).
Hi love, bye love, I will miss my love.
Knickfan1982
Lead Assistant
Posts: 5,797
And1: 2,158
Joined: Mar 19, 2016
       

Re: Boxing Thread 4.0 

Post#2285 » by Knickfan1982 » Wed May 11, 2022 3:17 am

cowboyronnie wrote:LOL @ Charlo being undefeated. Damn, did he really just put together a streak (largely, UDs) against Montiel, Hogan, Adams, Korobov, Centeno Jr., and Heiland. This guy's taking on all the big names, leaving no stone unturned!!!

If Charlo is so **** good why doesn't *he* take on Andrade, Benavidez, Lemieux, GGG, BJS, or any of the other awesome 160-168ers??? The man is fighting C fighters (short of Derevchenko).



Canelo is the A-side. He picks and chooses who he fights. Charlo and Canelo were both champions at the same time at 154 and 160. Why did Canelo wait until the 168 weight class before he decided to become the first Mexican fighter to unify all the belts in one weight division.
Why rely on nuance, facts and logic when you can bludgeon the other side with mindless repetition of "Duuur McDaniel's has potential :tooth and still be treated as if you were reasonable.
User avatar
cowboyronnie
RealGM
Posts: 30,215
And1: 1,465
Joined: Feb 20, 2004

Re: Boxing Thread 4.0 

Post#2286 » by cowboyronnie » Wed May 11, 2022 3:36 pm

I repeat: Why has Charlo not fought anyone ever at any weight? The dude has been a headliner in Brooklyn and Houston for 5 years, and is Derevychenko is the toughtest opp he's fought. He's clearly just sitting around hoping to land the Canelo lottery and trying to make sure he's undefeated when that happens.

Then, look back at Canelo's last 5 years.

Tell me which has earned the right to demand or pick their fights? Go see what professional boxers say about Canelo. They are head over heels, old timers and up-and-comers both. Everyone respects him and the course he's chosen.

It's just contrarian edgelords on the internet and people who got it wrong 5 years ago (calling him a cherrypicker Floyd) who are contiuing to nag him. He's wildely respected by his peers. Who gives a **** about you?
Hi love, bye love, I will miss my love.
Knickfan1982
Lead Assistant
Posts: 5,797
And1: 2,158
Joined: Mar 19, 2016
       

Re: Boxing Thread 4.0 

Post#2287 » by Knickfan1982 » Thu May 12, 2022 3:14 am

cowboyronnie wrote:I repeat: Why has Charlo not fought anyone ever at any weight? The dude has been a headliner in Brooklyn and Houston for 5 years, and is Derevychenko is the toughtest opp he's fought. He's clearly just sitting around hoping to land the Canelo lottery and trying to make sure he's undefeated when that happens.

Then, look back at Canelo's last 5 years.

Tell me which has earned the right to demand or pick their fights? Go see what professional boxers say about Canelo. They are head over heels, old timers and up-and-comers both. Everyone respects him and the course he's chosen.

It's just contrarian edgelords on the internet and people who got it wrong 5 years ago (calling him a cherrypicker Floyd) who are contiuing to nag him. He's wildely respected by his peers. Who gives a **** about you?


Why do you care about Canelo having some perceived ability to pick his fights? Are you his brother or something. I don't care. I want to see the best fight the best. And if you are using that excuse then all you're doing is saying sure I don't care if he's a cherry picker I just don't like it when people call Canelo out for it. You're being a fan boy of a fighter rather than a fan of boxing. Because there is no reason anyone in the world would rather see Canelo fight Amir Khan, Liam Smith, Rocky Felding, Avni Yidrim or a Mexican legends embarrassment of a son than fight Charlo.
Why rely on nuance, facts and logic when you can bludgeon the other side with mindless repetition of "Duuur McDaniel's has potential :tooth and still be treated as if you were reasonable.
User avatar
cowboyronnie
RealGM
Posts: 30,215
And1: 1,465
Joined: Feb 20, 2004

Re: Boxing Thread 4.0 

Post#2288 » by cowboyronnie » Thu May 12, 2022 12:20 pm

Let me get this straight: You're complaining about the pound-for-pound king taking on a fight that he could lose, and *did* lose? This is bad for boxing?

BUrT ROcKY FElDInG IN 2016, hee CHeery pICkIng in 2016!!!!!!! Wurt about 2016??? WHY WOn'T somEONE PLs ThINk aburt 2016!??!!
Hi love, bye love, I will miss my love.
User avatar
cowboyronnie
RealGM
Posts: 30,215
And1: 1,465
Joined: Feb 20, 2004

Re: Boxing Thread 4.0 

Post#2289 » by cowboyronnie » Thu May 12, 2022 12:24 pm

Speaking of cherry-picking. Here are you examples (it's *2022* right now, for reference):

Amir Khan - 2016
Liam Smith - 2016
Rocky Felding - 2018 (less than 3 months after GGG, at a new weight class)
Avni Yidrim - 1 of 5 fights he fought in an 18 month period

LOL

**** enjoy boxing, enjoy the Canelo show (it's awesome), stop whining, dork.
Hi love, bye love, I will miss my love.
Knickfan1982
Lead Assistant
Posts: 5,797
And1: 2,158
Joined: Mar 19, 2016
       

Re: Boxing Thread 4.0 

Post#2290 » by Knickfan1982 » Thu May 12, 2022 10:09 pm

cowboyronnie wrote:Speaking of cherry-picking. Here are you examples (it's *2022* right now, for reference):

Amir Khan - 2016
Liam Smith - 2016
Rocky Felding - 2018 (less than 3 months after GGG, at a new weight class)
Avni Yidrim - 1 of 5 fights he fought in an 18 month period

LOL

**** enjoy boxing, enjoy the Canelo show (it's awesome), stop whining, dork.

All I hear are excuses. Demand the best fight the best or call yourself a Canelo fanboy instead of a boxing fan.
Why rely on nuance, facts and logic when you can bludgeon the other side with mindless repetition of "Duuur McDaniel's has potential :tooth and still be treated as if you were reasonable.
User avatar
cowboyronnie
RealGM
Posts: 30,215
And1: 1,465
Joined: Feb 20, 2004

Re: Boxing Thread 4.0 

Post#2291 » by cowboyronnie » Thu May 12, 2022 11:36 pm

The pound-for-pound king just moved up a division and the fight was competitive enough that he *lost*. Yet, you're here complaining about him not fighting worthwhile opponents...becurx LIAm sMitH iN 2o16 wurt boUt thAt?

What more can be said about what a senseless complainer you are?
Hi love, bye love, I will miss my love.

Return to Boxing & Mixed Martial Arts