d-train wrote:Brandon Roy A+
LaMarcus Aldridge B+/A-
Travis Outlaw B+
Jarrett Jack B-
Steve Blake B-
James Jones B
Joel Przybilla C+
Martell Webster D+
Channing Frye C+
Sergio Rodriguez C-
Raef LaFrentz D
Josh McRoberts Inc
Von Wafer C (his name alone makes him a keeper)
Key
A
Posted: Wed Feb 27, 2008 8:11 pm
by Goldbum
Telfaire wrote:Wow, you're giving Jack a B- and Webster gets a D+ ? while I dont think Jack deserves an F, my sentiments for him are definitely on the lines of "get him out my team, that would be addition by subtraction"
+1 I think Jack could be a key contributor on the right team. Just not this one.
Posted: Wed Feb 27, 2008 8:42 pm
by ebott
Brandon Roy A+
LaMarcus Aldridge B
Travis Outlaw B+ (I'm tempted to give him an A after how well he did at small forward last night. Travis being able to play small forward makes him a much more useful part of our future than him only being able to do well when matched up against slower big men)
Jarrett Jack F-
Steve Blake C
James Jones A
Joel Przybilla B
Martell Webster B-
Channing Frye C
Sergio Rodriguez D
Raef LaFrentz F
Josh McRoberts F
Greg Oden F (He must be suckin' it up in Practice. Nate hasn't let him sniff the court all year. What's up with that? With our rebounding being so bad you figure Nate would give the kid a shot.)
Nate - C-
Re: Grade our players
Posted: Wed Feb 27, 2008 8:55 pm
by Red Robot
Posted: Wed Feb 27, 2008 8:56 pm
by zzaj
Lol, Jack...F-
That's awesome Ebott
Posted: Wed Feb 27, 2008 9:17 pm
by Andre 2999
Brandon Roy - A
LaMarcus Aldridge - B+
Travis Outlaw - B+
James Jones - B/B+
Joel Przybilla - B
Steve Blake - B
Martell Webster - C+/B-
Channing Frye - C+
Jarret Jack - C/C+
Sergio Rodriguez - C
Darius Miles - D-
I don't think it's really fair to even rate the rest of the guys (except for maybe LaFrance - B (because of his contract))
Posted: Wed Feb 27, 2008 9:28 pm
by Tim Lehrbach
Roy A
Aldridge B+
Outlaw B+
Przybilla B
Jones B
Blake B-
Frye B-
Webster C-
Jack C-
Rodriguez C-
LaFrentz D
McRoberts and Wafer do not compute
Posted: Wed Feb 27, 2008 9:32 pm
by Voodoo
Tim Lehrbach wrote:Roy A
Aldridge B+
Outlaw B+
Przybilla B
Jones B
Blake B-
Frye B-
Webster C-
Jack C-
Rodriguez C-
LaFrentz D
McRoberts and Wafer do not compute
Almost perfect, only differences I see is Roy as A+ other then that +1 to this post.
Posted: Wed Feb 27, 2008 10:15 pm
by Tim Lehrbach
Roy will get an A+ from me the season he plays 75+ games. I doubt this is going to be that season.
My 'A' for Roy represents a perfect score in all respects except durability--and it's hard to mark a guy down much for getting beat up while carrying a team.
Posted: Wed Feb 27, 2008 10:23 pm
by Voodoo
Point well taken, I am more tempted to agree with you now that I think about it, but I still would probably give Roy an A+.
Posted: Thu Feb 28, 2008 12:03 am
by b_roy7
Brandon Roy - A+
LaMarcus Aldridge - A-
Travis Outlaw - B+
Steve Blake - B
James Jones - B
Martell Webster - B
Joel Przybilla - B-
Channing Frye - C
Jarrett Jack - C
Sergio Rodriguez - C
Raef LaFrentz - D-
Posted: Thu Feb 28, 2008 12:13 am
by Mr Odd
Nate C+
Posted: Thu Feb 28, 2008 12:38 am
by TowelBoy12
The opinions of Webster on this board are too negative, imo. His shooting, particularly on open threes, has been absolutely disgusting.... however, I have loved every other aspect of his game lately and think his development is ahead of schedule.
He is starting to put the ball on the floor and finish with authority, which is great to see. He is also showing a decent midrange game. It's interesting to look at his box scores when he has terrible shooting nights (which is most of the time) and take his 3PT out of the equation. For example, against the Lakers he was 4-10 from inside the arc; not terrible.
Also, he shows great commitment on the defensive end and on the glass, and is usually good for a block or a steal or two. I think he's going to be a real contributor in our core, and at age 21 is better than advertised in every area but shooting.
Opinions vary I guess on what's wrong with his shot. Is it mental? Is it confidence? Is something wrong with his form? I have no idea. Is it just a "slump"? A temporary statistical anomaly? He was shooting over 40% from deep earlier in the year... Anyway, if his open threes were falling, Webster would be the third best player on the team. He gets a B from me.
Posted: Thu Feb 28, 2008 1:21 am
by UGotThrilled
ebott wrote:Greg Oden F (He must be suckin' it up in Practice. Nate hasn't let him sniff the court all year. What's up with that? With our rebounding being so bad you figure Nate would give the kid a shot.)
Is this a joke?
I would give Aldridge a B. He cant seem to score and rebound in the same game.
Posted: Thu Feb 28, 2008 1:26 am
by NBAMAN2006
Brandon Roy A
LaMarcus Aldridge A-
Travis Outlaw B+
James Jones B
Joel Pryzbilla B-
Steve Blake B-
Channing Frye B-
Martell Webster C+
Jarrett Jack D
Sergio Rodriguez D
Raef LaFrentz D
It really hurts me to put Sergio at a D. I loved the kid last year, but I have seen few players regress like him from their Rookie to Sophmore season.