LightTheBeam wrote:FarBeyondDriven wrote:LightTheBeam wrote:
I am one of Monte's biggest critics. Here's what I'll say about this.
My gripe about the pick initially was partially his position, partially that we didnt use the pick to upgrade. Well, we went and got DeRozan without having to sacrifice the pick. And it's pretty clear with Mitchell/Duarte gone, and Huerter next, Carter has a significant role on this team moving forward.
Looking at the picks that went after, there's an argument that Dalton Knecht could have been an immediate contributor, but reality is that he's a massive defensive liability and projects as a cheaper Huerter if things go well.
Carter can change the point of attack defense with Keon and Keegan.
Carter could be back by Xmas, or maybe mid January. Giving him 2.5 months to gear up for the playoffs. We will see. In the meantime we can build up Huerters value by the deadline, or if he's traded now we can use JMac and Colby in those minutes.
I've truly fallen in love with the idea of Devin Carter as a player. I didn't see a single analyst who watches college that didn't love him and his ability. Between Carter/Keon I feel really good we will find a long term starting two and a backup. I think of those 2 for us as what Denver had with KCP/Bruce Brown.
We already had a long-term starting two (Fox/Monk) and backups (Mitchell/Ellis). It wasn't a need. I would have approached this in a way that would have addressed our needs while also adding a few good young prospects to our stable so our SL team wasn't an embarrassment. After you all see how good this draft really is and all the players we could have had you'll understand why I'm pessimistic. I won't enjoy saying I told you so after the season.
Mitchell was trash. I saw 3 years of that guy, he had 3 decent months. Pass on him good riddance.
So our SL team wasn't an embarrassment? Really? Who cares what our summer league team looks like lmao.
Can you share a few names of who were the prospects you wanted?
SL rosters are indicative of how well your organization is run. If you're trotting out garbage it means your talent evaluation and asset management sucks. And we legit have one of, if not the worst, SL roster.
I just would never have drafted Carter. Not because he isn't a good prospect but because since he's damaged good, the point of taking him, the older prospect, is nullified. If PG was on the table I would have taken the guys higher on my board (Carrington, Collier or McCain). Or if instead, since we already had depth at guard, we could have actually address a need and taken Ware? Or we could have traded back, picking up an extra first or 2nd and taken George and Bona/Dunn? And still had our 2nd rounder to take Christie given us more depth and shooting.
To come away from the draft with likely nothing, or very little, for 2024 is atrocious. And btw, we'd still have assets to trade for an upgrade if necessary at the deadline. I just fundamentally disagree with the direction McNair has chosen.


















