LloydFree wrote:DickGrayson wrote:LloydFree wrote:Towns isn't on Chandler's level as an athlete, and will not be anywhere near the defender that Chandler has been during his career.
WTF?
Towns is already better defender than Chandler right now.
Chandler has been average on defense lately and he had one great season in NYK.
In fact, Chandler has only had 4 good defensive seasons as a center, the rest were average.
Chandler is a below average shot blocker and gets extremely overrated on defense.
Towns will be a much better, consistent and overall defender than Chandler. Towns will be better than Chandler defensively in 2015-16 and you can quote this.
I respect your opinion, but I disagree. You're comparing Towns as a college defender to Tyson Chandler guarding pros. I saw Chandler as an amateur. Towns is not the natural athlete that Chandler was. Towns will be a decent defender in the pros, but I doubt he is a stopper, because he doesn't have that kind of lateral movement. I'm a big fan of Towns, and think he should be the #1 pick, but I'm projecting his tools, not current production.
Being more athletic doesn't make you the better defender all the time. Athleticism helps defense, especially in the NBA no question. Towns is athletic enough to be an elite defender. He's not DeAndre Jordan, Dwight Howard or Blake Griffin athletic, but neither was Tim Duncan, Rasheed Wallace and Marcus Camby.
"Towns is just a college defender" The downplay is real right now.
Karl Anthony Towns is making NCAA history as one of the best defensive freshman of all time.
Tyson Chandler is guarding pros but at average level most of his career. If you look at Chandler's teams, more often they rank 15th in defense. Chandler only had 4 seasons where he anchored a good defense.
"Decent" doesn't describe Towns at all. He's a STOPPER whether its contested or block shots or forcing his opponent to pass the ball. Teams constantly play away from Towns and refuse to challenge him at this point. He's known for stops, so how are you going to say he isn't a stopper? Towns lateral movement for a 7 footer is actually very good. he's currently the best defensive freshman prospect, better than Nerlens Noel and Anthony Davis. What his does in the NCAA will translate to the NBA and he'll may even be better in the NBA than the NCAA.
Do also you understand Chandler's athleticism was the death of him?
When he was healthy, he won DPOY as a Knick.
After his injury, he fell to 15-20th amongst centers in the NBA in interior defense. Knicks became one of the worst defensive teams. Chandler couldn't play to his full strength.
If you're going to breakdown Towns weakness, atleast be more accurate with it.
Towns has poor lower body strength. (dominating in the paint)
Towns isn't a good offensive finisher. (finishing strong at the basket)
Towns tends to hack when he had mistimed a defensive play. (foul prone)
Stops, lateral movement on defense, being "decent" on defense don't assess Towns at all. It's false