doordoor123 wrote:RipCity71252 wrote:Wendell Carter worries me defensively. People talk about his IQ/positioning being pretty good but I think its overrated and has a lot of athletic quirks that I think will be exposed in the nba.
I know I said the opposite a couple days ago, but I think between he and Jontay, Jontay has a better chance to play pf minutes vs traditional lineups. Similar to Zach Randolph athletically.
Jontay is more of a power forward and Carter is more of a center. But I admit it’s going to be a struggle for Carter defensively. Unless he’s on a super young team he’s more likely a back up until he learns how to play defense. If he never learns how to play defense he’s a high level back up. Nikola Vucevic is still starting though, so it isn’t out of the question he starts even if he can’t defend. Centers that can’t defend usually defend better with a quick shot blocker like Porzingis does with Kanter as long as they’re good rebounders.
I've seen Carter look bad on defense in several games, but... I'm not down on his defensive potential - same with Bagley. Duke is one of the top 10 teams in the nation (out of 350ish) in defensive efficiency, and that can't happen if both bigs aren't doing anything right. It's not an Okafor or Vucevic situation - Carter does have the quickness and agility to improve his footwork. And he also has the length and strength. He just needs coaching and experience, imo. Not saying he'll be as good as Horford, but Horford's been a similar athlete who gradually got better and better defensively.
On Jontay, this may sound nuts, but if anyone remembers Tim Duncan as a freshman at Wake Forest, he was considerably smaller then when he was in the NBA. Jontay's still growing, and he could end up being almost Duncan sized in a few years. Duncan played a lot of PF in the NBA, but in today's NBA, he'd likely be a center - first and foremost. Jontay may start out playing PF, but ultimately I think he's a center. I think he's the most fascinating player in the draft.
"A common mistake that people make when trying to design something completely foolproof is to underestimate the ingenuity of complete fools." - Douglas Adams