Page 1 of 1

Buck Harvey: KG more like David Robinson than Timmy.

Posted: Tue Jun 17, 2008 7:58 am
by lukeridenour
Buck Harvey: Never Duncan, KG closer now to another

LOS ANGELES — Kevin Garnett changed uniform numbers this season, but it wasn’t a statement. It was necessary.
He wore No. 21 in Minnesota, and No. 21 wasn’t available in Boston. Bill Sharman once wore it, and the Celtics later retired it.

But the switch is nonetheless symbolic. Garnett was never like San Antonio’s No. 21, as often as they were compared over a decade. With a thin waist and freakish athletic ability for someone his height, Garnett was always closer to being David Robinson.

Now Garnett wears No. 5, and that’s appropriate, too.

Now he’s one win from becoming No. 50.

Thursday all the numbers were skewed. The same Lakers who overcame a 20-point deficit against the Spurs blew a historic 24-point lead. The same Kobe Bryant who said during the Spurs series that he could “get off” whenever he wanted to couldn’t, and Paul Pierce’s physical defense had a lot to do with that.

Then there was the clinching two. Ray Allen went past Sasha Vujacic, and Pau Gasol didn’t come over to help. Had Gregg Popovich been coaching Gasol, he might have lit Gasol’s beard on fire.

But through it all, playing a role he’s always been more suited for, was Garnett. He defended and helped as Gasol didn’t, and he rebounded, and he made a play that mattered.

Then, with just over two minutes left, Garnett drove hard on Gasol, then stopped and extended for a short jumper. The basketball hit the rim about four times before dropping, and the Celtics had a five-point lead.

“Huge shot,” Doc Rivers said afterward. “Maybe the single-biggest basket of the game.”

But everyone has always wanted more of Garnett. He’s an 11-time All-Star with a $23 million salary, and he comes with street coolness and appropriate histrionics. He has a face and a stature made for commercials, as well as expectations.

So when success hasn’t followed, questions have. When a Boston Globe columnist wrote earlier in the postseason that he wanted to see Garnett take over a game or even just a quarter, the writer said this happened: Flip Saunders pulled him to the side and said, “They wrote that story about him in Minnesota every year.”

These are the kinds of stories Robinson heard, too. But at least Robinson got out of the first round.

Garnett, except for one season, couldn’t in Minnesota.

He was on his way to a sad place in history — as the greatest player never to get to a Finals. Then everything changed this season with the trade. With all expectations back in place, the playoffs arrived.

He’s disappointed, and along the way he reinforced what everyone in San Antonio has known: He is not and never has been Tim Duncan.

Duncan has always been steadier and more poised, and he reacted to game situations by going to the low block. There he repeated the most effective play in basketball, grinding his way to four titles.

As it was with Robinson, Garnett’s body is both his strength and his weakness. He showed that again Thursday, when he drifted outside. Robinson, too, was less of a classic post-up player.

Garnett opened the second half with an 18 footer to cut the Lakers’ lead to 14. He followed with a drive, and this is what Rivers meant the other day when he said, “We’ve got to get Kevin going. Clearly.”

Just as clearly, Garnett isn’t built to carry a championship team. Just as Robinson prospered next to Duncan, Garnett prospers now with Pierce and Allen. Now he has closers, and he can be what he is, which is a marvelously complete player.

An example: Pierce defended Bryant well, but Garnett was also behind him, as Robinson always was for his teammates, defending the rim like the reigning defensive player of the year he is.

Afterward Garnett was measured and calm. “The job isn’t finished,” he said, but he added something else. “I can taste it.”

He sounded like another former MVP who once got this close at about the same age. And now Garnett faces a career-changing moment — just as it was for Robinson once before.



http://www.mysanantonio.com/sports/c....284dfde6.html

Re: Buck Harvey: KG more like David Robinson than Timmy.

Posted: Tue Jun 17, 2008 1:46 pm
by Blame Rasho
I have always thought so as well. KG is more comfortable/better being the 2nd banana. There is nothing wrong with that, it is hard for big men to have a significant impact at the end of game, but it can be done. Yelling and screaming doesn't = impact. He is an athletic freak like Robinson was, but has a soft label due to the fact that they both didn't like to be in the post and were face up players.

Re: Buck Harvey: KG more like David Robinson than Timmy.

Posted: Wed Jun 18, 2008 12:06 pm
by johnnyjohnnyjohnny
What an insult to the Admiral.

Call me when KG posts a quadruple-double, scores 71 points in a game, wins an NBA scoring title, wins an MVP award or wins a DESERVED DPOY award (ie., not handed to him by the media).

There's many differences between KG and Robinson. Both were key players to record turn arounds for their franchises, Boston nearly changed the entire face of their team in order to do so. San Antonio drafted David Robinson and Sean Elliot. David didn't play secod fiddle to a Paul Pierce alongside Ray Allen.

Most importantly, David Robinson was drafted a San Antonio Spur and I'm confident would have gone out as a San Antonio Spur even if it meant no titles. When KG retires, I'm not sure if I should think of him as a Minnesota great or Boston legend. David Robinson was loyal to the Spurs organization and it's fans. It would have killed me as a Spur fan to watch him win a title anywhere else.

Re: Buck Harvey: KG more like David Robinson than Timmy.

Posted: Thu Jun 19, 2008 2:04 pm
by Donald Kaufman
I have no problem with KG being compared to D-Rob. Both had issues leading their respective teams deep in the playoffs as the #1 option. Both were freakishly talented. Both great defensive players.

But I take major issue with the Duncan comparisons. KG simply doesn't influence games the way that Timmy does.

The good thing is, smart b-ball fans understand that KG is not even in the same league as Timmy.