Scottie named East Player of the Week
Moderators: 7 Footer, Morris_Shatford, DG88, niQ, Duffman100, tsherkin, Reeko, lebron stopper, HiJiNX
Re: Scottie named East Player of the Week
- TimeForChange
- Lead Assistant
- Posts: 5,576
- And1: 4,850
- Joined: Dec 23, 2023
Re: Scottie named East Player of the Week
there are still people on here who don't know what to watch on defense but Scottie has been outstanding.
Re: Scottie named East Player of the Week
- F22_Raptor
- Starter
- Posts: 2,029
- And1: 3,697
- Joined: Nov 07, 2019
- Location: Burlington, ON
-
Re: Scottie named East Player of the Week
Tank you Tampa
Re: Scottie named East Player of the Week
-
- Lead Assistant
- Posts: 4,509
- And1: 5,922
- Joined: Mar 11, 2023
-
Re: Scottie named East Player of the Week
DKB333 wrote:Any chance he sneaks onto the All-Star team again?
Pretty unlikely and to be fair he doesn't really deserve it given that he's missed a chunk of games and our team has been horrid.
Mitchell, Garland, Giannis, Lillard, Tatum, Brown, Brunson, Towns, Wagner, Ball and Trae are pretty much locks and that only leaves 1 open spot.
Guys like Cade, Siakam, Herro, Mobley, Allen etc. will have a slight nod over Barnes because they are on better teams. Cade, in particular, has had a really nice season on a decent Pistons squad. Siakam has played really well as off late on a Pistons team that is rolling lately.
Maybe if Barnes was healthier and we were in a play-in seed he would have a good shot.
His only hope is that the East needs 2-3 injury replacements and he may get lucky.
Re: Scottie named East Player of the Week
- Scase
- RealGM
- Posts: 14,640
- And1: 10,781
- Joined: Feb 02, 2009
- Location: Ottawa by way of MTL
-
Re: Scottie named East Player of the Week
TimeForChange wrote:
there are still people on here who don't know what to watch on defense but Scottie has been outstanding.
His defence lately has been really good, but in no way should he be making an All defence team lol. Not until the team isn't one of the worst in the league at least.

Props TZ!
Re: Scottie named East Player of the Week
- F22_Raptor
- Starter
- Posts: 2,029
- And1: 3,697
- Joined: Nov 07, 2019
- Location: Burlington, ON
-
Re: Scottie named East Player of the Week
Tank you, Tampa.
Re: Scottie named East Player of the Week
-
- RealGM
- Posts: 11,910
- And1: 11,601
- Joined: Aug 13, 2021
-
Re: Scottie named East Player of the Week
He doesn't deserve to be an All Star. If he was healthy and playing like this all year, sure.
But the injuries were real and his struggles with those injuries are real.
But the injuries were real and his struggles with those injuries are real.
Re: Scottie named East Player of the Week
-
- RealGM
- Posts: 11,286
- And1: 7,222
- Joined: May 16, 2010
- Location: ♫ Whoa Black Betty Shambleland ♫
Re: Scottie named East Player of the Week
Good for him. Glad to see him recognised.

This place is insufferable.
Re: Scottie named East Player of the Week
-
- Analyst
- Posts: 3,125
- And1: 2,072
- Joined: Mar 25, 2021
-
Re: Scottie named East Player of the Week
Great player. I have no doubt in my mind that he is the most complete player from his draft class. Masai hit a homerun with him.
Re: Scottie named East Player of the Week
-
- Forum Mod - Raptors
- Posts: 92,222
- And1: 31,805
- Joined: Oct 14, 2003
-
Re: Scottie named East Player of the Week
Great couple of games from Scottie leading into this.
Re: Scottie named East Player of the Week
-
- Pro Prospect
- Posts: 794
- And1: 453
- Joined: Jul 25, 2024
-
Re: Scottie named East Player of the Week
TheGeneral99 wrote:DKB333 wrote:Any chance he sneaks onto the All-Star team again?
Pretty unlikely and to be fair he doesn't really deserve it given that he's missed a chunk of games and our team has been horrid.
Mitchell, Garland, Giannis, Lillard, Tatum, Brown, Brunson, Towns, Wagner, Ball and Trae are pretty much locks and that only leaves 1 open spot.
Guys like Cade, Siakam, Herro, Mobley, Allen etc. will have a slight nod over Barnes because they are on better teams. Cade, in particular, has had a really nice season on a decent Pistons squad. Siakam has played really well as off late on a Pistons team that is rolling lately.
Maybe if Barnes was healthier and we were in a play-in seed he would have a good shot.
His only hope is that the East needs 2-3 injury replacements and he may get lucky.[/quot
Wagner ahead of Barnes. No way.
Re: Scottie named East Player of the Week
- WuTang_CMB
- RealGM
- Posts: 40,981
- And1: 51,448
- Joined: Sep 26, 2017
-
Re: Scottie named East Player of the Week
DKB333 wrote:TheGeneral99 wrote:DKB333 wrote:Any chance he sneaks onto the All-Star team again?
Pretty unlikely and to be fair he doesn't really deserve it given that he's missed a chunk of games and our team has been horrid.
Mitchell, Garland, Giannis, Lillard, Tatum, Brown, Brunson, Towns, Wagner, Ball and Trae are pretty much locks and that only leaves 1 open spot.
Guys like Cade, Siakam, Herro, Mobley, Allen etc. will have a slight nod over Barnes because they are on better teams. Cade, in particular, has had a really nice season on a decent Pistons squad. Siakam has played really well as off late on a Pistons team that is rolling lately.
Maybe if Barnes was healthier and we were in a play-in seed he would have a good shot.
His only hope is that the East needs 2-3 injury replacements and he may get lucky.[/quot
Wagner ahead of Barnes. No way.
Cade for sure is going to get in
Re: Scottie named East Player of the Week
- ontnut
- RealGM
- Posts: 12,184
- And1: 9,167
- Joined: Jan 31, 2009
- Location: Toronto
-
Re: Scottie named East Player of the Week
WuTang_OG wrote:DKB333 wrote:TheGeneral99 wrote:
Pretty unlikely and to be fair he doesn't really deserve it given that he's missed a chunk of games and our team has been horrid.
Mitchell, Garland, Giannis, Lillard, Tatum, Brown, Brunson, Towns, Wagner, Ball and Trae are pretty much locks and that only leaves 1 open spot.
Guys like Cade, Siakam, Herro, Mobley, Allen etc. will have a slight nod over Barnes because they are on better teams. Cade, in particular, has had a really nice season on a decent Pistons squad. Siakam has played really well as off late on a Pistons team that is rolling lately.
Maybe if Barnes was healthier and we were in a play-in seed he would have a good shot.
His only hope is that the East needs 2-3 injury replacements and he may get lucky.[/quot
Wagner ahead of Barnes. No way.
Cade for sure is going to get in
Cade def deserves to get in over Barnes this year. Wagner puts up more offensive stats than Scottie, and Mobley puts up more D stats, so Scottie kinda stuck in the middle, where he's not going to get any votes over either guy. ORL needs a guy in the ASG so Wagner gets the obvious nod.

Re: Scottie named East Player of the Week
-
- Lead Assistant
- Posts: 4,509
- And1: 5,922
- Joined: Mar 11, 2023
-
Re: Scottie named East Player of the Week
ontnut wrote:WuTang_OG wrote:DKB333 wrote:
Pretty unlikely and to be fair he doesn't really deserve it given that he's missed a chunk of games and our team has been horrid.
Mitchell, Garland, Giannis, Lillard, Tatum, Brown, Brunson, Towns, Wagner, Ball and Trae are pretty much locks and that only leaves 1 open spot.
Guys like Cade, Siakam, Herro, Mobley, Allen etc. will have a slight nod over Barnes because they are on better teams. Cade, in particular, has had a really nice season on a decent Pistons squad. Siakam has played really well as off late on a Pistons team that is rolling lately.
Maybe if Barnes was healthier and we were in a play-in seed he would have a good shot.
His only hope is that the East needs 2-3 injury replacements and he may get lucky.[/quot
Wagner ahead of Barnes. No way.
Cade for sure is going to get in
Cade def deserves to get in over Barnes this year. Wagner puts up more offensive stats than Scottie, and Mobley puts up more D stats, so Scottie kinda stuck in the middle, where he's not going to get any votes over either guy. ORL needs a guy in the ASG so Wagner gets the obvious nod.
I think Cade, Wagner or Siakam will get in, and all three of them likely get in if there is an injury replacement.