ImageImageImageImageImage

Tank World Order (2.0)

Moderators: DG88, niQ, Duffman100, tsherkin, Reeko, lebron stopper, HiJiNX, Morris_Shatford, 7 Footer

At 10-13 where do you stand now?

TWO: True tank... Sell all assets and start hoping to land a Top 5 pick through the Lottery
28
15%
Asset-Building Mode: Trade Powell/Lowry but Keep Long-Term Core
84
46%
Asset-Building Mode: Wait Until Trade Deadline and Let Lowry Make His Own Call
39
22%
Buyer Mode: Trade Multiple Picks/Players to Get Star... Continue Competing with Lowry
6
3%
Organic Growth Mode: Likely Means Waiting Until Offseason Unless No-Brainer Trade Presents Itself
24
13%
 
Total votes: 181

Mehar
Lead Assistant
Posts: 4,975
And1: 3,444
Joined: Apr 23, 2012
Location: Toronto, ON

Re: Tank World Order (2.0) 

Post#1741 » by Mehar » Sun Apr 11, 2021 5:46 pm

sidsid wrote:
OAKLEY_2 wrote:
sidsid wrote:
The answer to this is "I don't care about role players at the beginning stage of a rebuild". We can find a Terence Ross, FVV, Norm, Amir, JV, OG, Ibaka, etc. down the road and anywhere in the draft and out of it.

I do care about losing a shot at our best chance to get a high level, ceiling raising star. And that's what the Norm/Lowry decisions are likely to cost us. Trent isn't worth that tradeoff. I'd rather have the future pick that isn't likely to be as good as him AND the lottery pick that has the potential to be much, much, much more impactful than he ever will.

And this isn't a full tank, it's the stealth tank moves for this season that 90% of this board has finally accepted were the obvious course after we slid down the standings. Masai just blew the opportunity.


This really isn't a rebuild it is a retool on the fly. Masai and Bobby want players for next year and the years after not five years plus from now like Sam Hinke. All these freshmen? Super high risk.Ideally we land Cade, Suggs, Mobley and Green but... we are in Poetl territory. So what they do with KL's 30 mil plus and Baynes 7 is the biggest concern and biggest opportunity going forward.


Even in a retool, you're still looking for the highest level assets because you have a "core" that can provide a floor. And specifically in our situation, getting lucky with the lottery balls could net us a player that is more impactful both immediately and in the future than Trent is now. That was the immediate calculus that should have made the trade course clear.

Even looking at it from other aspects like the cap. The #1 pick would likely cost us significantly less than what we're paying Trent this offseason. We'd have his RFA rights in 4 years which we won't for Trent, etc.

It's a different story if we were getting Giannis this offseason, but we're not.


The way Trent is playing now, I would not be surprised if a desperate team offered him over 20 million a year. The argument made was that Trent would be cheaper than Powell. No longer the case. I was looking at the cap aspects also. So, the argument from my perspective was to trade Powell for draft picks and some expiring contracts that you could waive. My hope was that this team would have dumped Powell and Lowry in January for nothing but picks and expiring contracts. Then "load managed" Siakam, FVV, and OG for the rest of the year, to guarantee a bottom 3 finish. This was a lost year playing in Tampa, especially the way the team started out, so I would have thrown in the towel in January. I was hoping to be where Detroit and Minnesota is record wise right now.

When you are drafting in the top 3, you are getting Cade or Suggs at 7-8 million a year depending on their draft slot, for the next 3 years, and 10 M in the 4th year. You have their bird rights also. This team also had 25-30 million in cap space, with no Powell and Lowry. I would rather have Cade/Suggs for 7-8 million, with their high ceiling star potential, and 25-30 million in cap space than Gary Trent Jr, who will now eat up a large chunk of the cap. People ignore the cap aspects. I was of the mindset to get the highest level assets, and the only way to do so was to finish in the bottom 3. The worst thing that could happen for this franchise, is to somehow sneak into the playoffs, and have Gary Trent Jr. command a hefty contract in the off-season, where the Raptors might have to potentially pay him more than we should have.
planetmars
Starter
Posts: 2,061
And1: 1,560
Joined: Jun 15, 2018

Re: Tank World Order (2.0) 

Post#1742 » by planetmars » Sun Apr 11, 2021 5:54 pm

JShuttlesworth wrote:I think from my perspective, the main problem is going to be depth next year. Especially big depth, similar to this year. I like our starting 5, aside from the centre spot, but the bench (as of today) will be composed of unproven players.

If we lose Anunoby to an injury, or Siakam even, there is no one to go to off the bench who can replicate what they do. Same goes for Trent.


Yeah injuries can derail any season, but that would be true for any team. The key is to have some depth at every spot, and we did
not have that this year. Our depth was garbage for the most part.

Assume Lowry walks (which is what I'm hoping for). We'll have $18M in cap space + $5M for the room mid-level. We'll have our FRP and two SRP's in the 40's (not low 50's).

We have team options for Boucher, Bembry and Watson. Add Flynn, our draft picks this year, and our room mid level.
That's not a bad bench.

Let's say we can get Richaun Holmes. He's a good rim protector / rebounder. We use the room-midlevel on Olynyk or Birch. We'll have something like this:

Holmes/Birch
Siakam/Boucher
OG/Watson
GTJ/Bembry
FVV/Flynn
+ 3 draft picks, including a FRP (likely lottery)

Just moving Boucher from C to backup PF is a huge boost to the bench. Boucher has been playing out of position all year. Flynn will be a year older. I like Watson as he has size and can shoot 3's. Bembry's getting better. The FRP should hopefully be useful in their first year.

If they can't make the playoffs next year either, then you might have to think about firing Bobby or even Nurse IMO. One season of this garbage is fine in a weird season.. but two in a row should require some big changes from top down.
User avatar
720
RealGM
Posts: 33,090
And1: 67,689
Joined: Nov 01, 2012
Location: Malton
     

Re: Tank World Order (2.0) 

Post#1743 » by 720 » Sun Apr 11, 2021 5:56 pm

OG not playing today. I think we lose.
Image
Image
User avatar
T-d0t
General Manager
Posts: 8,977
And1: 13,141
Joined: Nov 08, 2012
Location: T-dot
       

Re: Tank World Order (2.0) 

Post#1744 » by T-d0t » Sun Apr 11, 2021 6:00 pm

I have Sexland on one of my teams in fantasy and both are GTD for today's game LOL
Los_29
RealGM
Posts: 15,235
And1: 13,848
Joined: Apr 10, 2021

Re: Tank World Order (2.0) 

Post#1745 » by Los_29 » Sun Apr 11, 2021 6:05 pm

Last night we started Flynn, Bembry, GTJ, OG and Boucher and blew out a team that has been in the lottery the past 3 years and is desperately trying to get in the playoffs. The Raptors couldn't have made it any easier for the Cavs and the Cavs couldn't capitalize. People just don't understand how bad the teams at the bottom are.
People forget this team won 60 games last year. This year we've had no production from our C position, no bench production and tons of guys who have missed time due to injury. OG has missed 18 games, Pascal has missed 10 games, Lowry has missed 14 games, FVV has missed 9 games. Having a lottery pick this year is a blessing and finishing 7th or 8th doesn't mean we can't get in the top 4. Just look at the past two years. And if we do pick in the 6-10 range, who cares. There are great players drafted outside of the top 5 every year.
User avatar
Psubs
RealGM
Posts: 20,806
And1: 11,890
Joined: Nov 20, 2004
Location: Toronto

Re: Tank World Order (2.0) 

Post#1746 » by Psubs » Sun Apr 11, 2021 6:12 pm

planetmars wrote:Lowry played like ass this season, and we had Baynes and Stanley Johnson play heavy minutes. Our bench depth was non existent (how many times did our bench only produce like 5 points total). And yet we are still only 3 games back of a play-in. This team wouldn't be a lottery team with Olynyk over Baynes. And Olynyk would only be had for the room mid level let alone with $18M in cap space.

It's easy to make the playoffs in the East. And we couldn't do it this year because of Covid+Tampa+Baynes. All three of those variables will be gone next year. And we'll have more depth arguably. I mean look at last night: Boucher, Flynn, Watanabe, Bembry would all be coming off the bench, not starting. Add a FRP and two SRP's to that as well. We may even get a full G-league season to develop everyone properly.

This team is easily making the playoffs in '22. The bigger question is how do they become contenders again. That might take a few years.. but being a lottery team again would only happen if there were serious injuries again.. or if we end up with Baynes 2.0 as our next tank commander.


Next year, they'll at least on par with the Boston, NY, Charlotte, Chicago, etc. Likely in the tier with Milwaukee as they are tied financially and going to treadmill. :lol: I would think they trade with Philly and be just slightly below them with BK being on top if they can re-sign Blake and Aldridge.
Image
User avatar
Psubs
RealGM
Posts: 20,806
And1: 11,890
Joined: Nov 20, 2004
Location: Toronto

Re: Tank World Order (2.0) 

Post#1747 » by Psubs » Sun Apr 11, 2021 6:14 pm

720 wrote:OG not playing today. I think we lose.


Siakam in. Lose to the Knicks. :lol:
Image
User avatar
720
RealGM
Posts: 33,090
And1: 67,689
Joined: Nov 01, 2012
Location: Malton
     

Re: Tank World Order (2.0) 

Post#1748 » by 720 » Sun Apr 11, 2021 6:22 pm

Cavs play the pelicans today. Pels probably winning but off chance the cavs win and we lose we revert the damage done yesterday.
Image
Image
User avatar
Psubs
RealGM
Posts: 20,806
And1: 11,890
Joined: Nov 20, 2004
Location: Toronto

Re: Tank World Order (2.0) 

Post#1749 » by Psubs » Sun Apr 11, 2021 6:30 pm

720 wrote:Cavs play the pelicans today. Pels probably winning but off chance the cavs win and we lose we revert the damage done yesterday.


Can always hope!
Image
User avatar
720
RealGM
Posts: 33,090
And1: 67,689
Joined: Nov 01, 2012
Location: Malton
     

Re: Tank World Order (2.0) 

Post#1750 » by 720 » Sun Apr 11, 2021 6:46 pm

I was rewatching game 4 and game 7 of the sixers series last night. Just reminded me of how **** ing special Kawhi was. He willed us to both those victories. We had no business winning either game with how poorly some of our guys were playing. It almost felt like Kawhi could sense the anxiety of the other guys on our team and decided "**** it I'll do it by myself". Ibaka was clutch too but Kawhi had such a big work load.

We have NO ONE on our team that can even come close to replicating that. We need a blue chip prospect. Someone with top 10 potential so badly. Or else the prime of these guys on our team will get wasted.
Image
Image
Yeezus_
RealGM
Posts: 11,026
And1: 14,088
Joined: Feb 18, 2009
Location: Toronto
     

Re: Tank World Order (2.0) 

Post#1751 » by Yeezus_ » Sun Apr 11, 2021 6:48 pm

Marmoset wrote:
Yeezus_ wrote:For anyone in here that is criticizing the Raptors direction, it means you guys don’t think Masai/Bobby (arguably the best front office in the league), aren't good enough at their jobs to build a championship team. Carry on though.


This is the age-old argument that you can't criticize someone because they have had success. A silly argument. The best managers make some bad decisions. The worst managers make some good decisions.

One of the main criticisms right now is that there is no apparent direction for the franchise. Recent decisions seem contradictory. This doesn't mean there is no plan - I have a hard time believing such a successful front office does not have one - but their moves make it hard to see. Time will tell.

You’re missing the point though. If they decided they rather compete and go for a playoff spot, who are we to say that’s wrong. They’ve proven they know how to build a championship team so this whole team tank vs team mediocre stuff is just pure nonsense. They’ll figure it all out as a front office.
Yeezy SZN approaching
Marmoset
Veteran
Posts: 2,538
And1: 563
Joined: Nov 17, 2003
 

Re: Tank World Order (2.0) 

Post#1752 » by Marmoset » Sun Apr 11, 2021 6:56 pm

Yeezus_ wrote:
Marmoset wrote:
Yeezus_ wrote:For anyone in here that is criticizing the Raptors direction, it means you guys don’t think Masai/Bobby (arguably the best front office in the league), aren't good enough at their jobs to build a championship team. Carry on though.


This is the age-old argument that you can't criticize someone because they have had success. A silly argument. The best managers make some bad decisions. The worst managers make some good decisions.

One of the main criticisms right now is that there is no apparent direction for the franchise. Recent decisions seem contradictory. This doesn't mean there is no plan - I have a hard time believing such a successful front office does not have one - but their moves make it hard to see. Time will tell.

You’re missing the point though. If they decided they rather compete and go for a playoff spot, who are we to say that’s wrong. They’ve proven they know how to build a championship team so this whole team tank vs team mediocre stuff is just pure nonsense. They’ll figure it all out as a front office.


What is the point of a discussion board then? What is wrong with disagreeing with the front office? Just because they've had past success doesn't mean we automatically have to agree with the current and the future. It's not like anyone is calling for them to be fired. A lot of us simply have questions about the direction of the team and I think that's valid.

Past success does not mean you can't question current decisions. It also doesn't mean I don't trust them, just that I have questions about some of their choices. There's no nonsense in that.
DelAbbot
RealGM
Posts: 15,272
And1: 21,723
Joined: May 22, 2019
   

Re: Tank World Order (2.0) 

Post#1753 » by DelAbbot » Sun Apr 11, 2021 7:39 pm

I think a lot of posters dont bother doing basic research or understand how the NBA works before discussing their ideas for how to GM
720 wrote:This season revealed all the low IQ posters on this forum. These TM clowns are funny.
User avatar
Inevitable
RealGM
Posts: 44,482
And1: 134,644
Joined: Apr 22, 2006
Contact:
   

Re: Tank World Order (2.0) 

Post#1754 » by Inevitable » Sun Apr 11, 2021 8:10 pm

The silliest argument is they built a title team they can do it again. It completely ignores the fact the actual team construct pre Kawhi compared to now is totally different. We aren’t a deep team of former lottery picks/first round picks anymore we have like 3 guys from the G league in the rotation. If a superstar which is what we need to win a title becomes available (and not a super depressed asset like Kawhi), the NBA landscape has changed so much that means multiple first rounders and then OG and other core pieces going the other way. Then you’re basically a super shallow team hoping to fill out the roster with free agents or buyout players that don’t willingly come here. This is why a very good lottery pick this season is so attractive, gives you so much flexibility short and long term and builds up your asset base. We are basically like those MLB teams that go all in and sell the farm, then are back in the basement. Depressing it to win a play in game for nothing more than ego purposes (we beat the Bucks and Sixers in the dog days of the season, we can give em a scare!) is Bryan Colangelo thinking.
Los_29
RealGM
Posts: 15,235
And1: 13,848
Joined: Apr 10, 2021

Re: Tank World Order (2.0) 

Post#1755 » by Los_29 » Sun Apr 11, 2021 8:14 pm

720 wrote:I was rewatching game 4 and game 7 of the sixers series last night. Just reminded me of how **** ing special Kawhi was. He willed us to both those victories. We had no business winning either game with how poorly some of our guys were playing. It almost felt like Kawhi could sense the anxiety of the other guys on our team and decided "**** it I'll do it by myself". Ibaka was clutch too but Kawhi had such a big work load.

We have NO ONE on our team that can even come close to replicating that. We need a blue chip prospect. Someone with top 10 potential so badly. Or else the prime of these guys on our team will get wasted.


Easier to trade for a superstar then because by the time these guys are at a superstar level (if they even get there) then guys like Fred and Pascal will be out of their primes.
User avatar
720
RealGM
Posts: 33,090
And1: 67,689
Joined: Nov 01, 2012
Location: Malton
     

Re: Tank World Order (2.0) 

Post#1756 » by 720 » Sun Apr 11, 2021 8:16 pm

Los_29 wrote:
720 wrote:I was rewatching game 4 and game 7 of the sixers series last night. Just reminded me of how **** ing special Kawhi was. He willed us to both those victories. We had no business winning either game with how poorly some of our guys were playing. It almost felt like Kawhi could sense the anxiety of the other guys on our team and decided "**** it I'll do it by myself". Ibaka was clutch too but Kawhi had such a big work load.

We have NO ONE on our team that can even come close to replicating that. We need a blue chip prospect. Someone with top 10 potential so badly. Or else the prime of these guys on our team will get wasted.


Easier to trade for a superstar then because by the time these guys are at a superstar level (if they even get there) then guys like Fred and Pascal will be out of their primes.

We're not trading for a superstar. No assets that can compete with other teams and not in a unique situation like the Kawhi trade (him basically not playing for the most of the year for the spurs, Spurs not wanting to trade him to the Lakers even though they had the best assets, etc).
Image
Image
Los_29
RealGM
Posts: 15,235
And1: 13,848
Joined: Apr 10, 2021

Re: Tank World Order (2.0) 

Post#1757 » by Los_29 » Sun Apr 11, 2021 8:34 pm

Inevitable wrote:The silliest argument is they built a title team they can do it again. It completely ignores the fact the actual team construct pre Kawhi compared to now is totally different. We aren’t a deep team of former lottery picks/first round picks anymore we have like 3 guys from the G league in the rotation. If a superstar which is what we need to win a title becomes available (and not a super depressed asset like Kawhi), the NBA landscape has changed so much that means multiple first rounders and then OG and other core pieces going the other way. Then you’re basically a super shallow team hoping to fill out the roster with free agents or buyout players that don’t willingly come here. This is why a very good lottery pick this season is so attractive, gives you so much flexibility short and long term and builds up your asset base. We are basically like those MLB teams that go all in and sell the farm, then are back in the basement. Depressing it to win a play in game for nothing more than ego purposes (we beat the Bucks and Sixers in the dog days of the season, we can give em a scare!) is Bryan Colangelo thinking.


You're overestimating how hard it is to acquire a superstar. Look at how awful Houston's return was for Harden. They got no young prospects and a bunch of picks that will most likely all be in the later part of the 1st round. People talk about how bad the Spurs return was for Kawhi but Houston will be lucky to even get a player like Demar with all those late 1st round picks. It was a horrendous deal for Houston.

And where is the idea that we are going for the play in game coming from? We have been sitting Kyle, FVV, Pascal and today we are sitting OG. Last night we started Flynn, GTJ, Bembry, Boucher and OG. And the Cavs still couldn't beat them.
Los_29
RealGM
Posts: 15,235
And1: 13,848
Joined: Apr 10, 2021

Re: Tank World Order (2.0) 

Post#1758 » by Los_29 » Sun Apr 11, 2021 8:37 pm

720 wrote:
Los_29 wrote:
720 wrote:I was rewatching game 4 and game 7 of the sixers series last night. Just reminded me of how **** ing special Kawhi was. He willed us to both those victories. We had no business winning either game with how poorly some of our guys were playing. It almost felt like Kawhi could sense the anxiety of the other guys on our team and decided "**** it I'll do it by myself". Ibaka was clutch too but Kawhi had such a big work load.

We have NO ONE on our team that can even come close to replicating that. We need a blue chip prospect. Someone with top 10 potential so badly. Or else the prime of these guys on our team will get wasted.


Easier to trade for a superstar then because by the time these guys are at a superstar level (if they even get there) then guys like Fred and Pascal will be out of their primes.

We're not trading for a superstar. No assets that can compete with other teams and not in a unique situation like the Kawhi trade (him basically not playing for the most of the year for the spurs, Spurs not wanting to trade him to the Lakers even though they had the best assets, etc).


I'm not saying we should trade for a superstar. Now is not the time. But I don't think we should expect a draft pick this year to reach superstar status while guys like Pascal and Fred are still in their prime. So if you want a superstar that fits the timeline of our core guys then you're gonna need to trade for one (which is obviously not a good idea given the current state of our team).
User avatar
720
RealGM
Posts: 33,090
And1: 67,689
Joined: Nov 01, 2012
Location: Malton
     

Re: Tank World Order (2.0) 

Post#1759 » by 720 » Sun Apr 11, 2021 8:40 pm

Los_29 wrote:
720 wrote:
Los_29 wrote:
Easier to trade for a superstar then because by the time these guys are at a superstar level (if they even get there) then guys like Fred and Pascal will be out of their primes.

We're not trading for a superstar. No assets that can compete with other teams and not in a unique situation like the Kawhi trade (him basically not playing for the most of the year for the spurs, Spurs not wanting to trade him to the Lakers even though they had the best assets, etc).


I'm not saying we should trade for a superstar. Now is not the time. But I don't think we should expect a draft pick this year to reach superstar status while guys like Pascal and Fred are still in their prime. So if you want a superstar that fits the timeline of our core guys then you're gonna need to trade for one (which is obviously not a good idea given the current state of our team).

We can't trade for one even if we want to so there is no point in even thinking about that. The only way we're getting one is by drafting one. Siakam is 27, OG is 23, GTJ is 22. They fit the timeline.
Image
Image
User avatar
Inevitable
RealGM
Posts: 44,482
And1: 134,644
Joined: Apr 22, 2006
Contact:
   

Re: Tank World Order (2.0) 

Post#1760 » by Inevitable » Sun Apr 11, 2021 8:47 pm

Los_29 wrote:
Inevitable wrote:The silliest argument is they built a title team they can do it again. It completely ignores the fact the actual team construct pre Kawhi compared to now is totally different. We aren’t a deep team of former lottery picks/first round picks anymore we have like 3 guys from the G league in the rotation. If a superstar which is what we need to win a title becomes available (and not a super depressed asset like Kawhi), the NBA landscape has changed so much that means multiple first rounders and then OG and other core pieces going the other way. Then you’re basically a super shallow team hoping to fill out the roster with free agents or buyout players that don’t willingly come here. This is why a very good lottery pick this season is so attractive, gives you so much flexibility short and long term and builds up your asset base. We are basically like those MLB teams that go all in and sell the farm, then are back in the basement. Depressing it to win a play in game for nothing more than ego purposes (we beat the Bucks and Sixers in the dog days of the season, we can give em a scare!) is Bryan Colangelo thinking.


You're overestimating how hard it is to acquire a superstar. Look at how awful Houston's return was for Harden. They got no young prospects and a bunch of picks that will most likely all be in the later part of the 1st round. People talk about how bad the Spurs return was for Kawhi but Houston will be lucky to even get a player like Demar with all those late 1st round picks. It was a horrendous deal for Houston.

And where is the idea that we are going for the play in game coming from? We have been sitting Kyle, FVV, Pascal and today we are sitting OG. Last night we started Flynn, GTJ, Bembry, Boucher and OG. And the Cavs still couldn't beat them.


Almost a decade worth of pick control from BK is not an awful deal at all, and then you got the lottery pick from the Cavs in 2022. In what world is that a terrible return for a star player walking in 1.5 years?

Return to Toronto Raptors