Madvillainy2004 wrote:PushDaRock wrote:sidsid wrote:
Maybe, maybe not. He's not standing somewhere mid-baseline for half a quarter doing nothing and the ball is moving and ending up in his hands more often. His offense isn't starting entirely at a standstill every 3 minutes against a set defense.
With him and Siakam playing C/PF he'd be getting more hub touches for playmaking than he is now with Jak. And he isn't defending pgs, he'd be in his roamer role that he's in now.
What has made Barnes special this year isn't the open 3s he's hitting in front of defenses that still aren't respecting it, which would change his scoring from a 20 to an 18 average. It's that he's having Lowry like impact. He's a connector, a PNR initiator and finisher, a PG driver, a high/low man, etc.
He's breaking out because he is more involved in an offense in multiple roles instead of being told to be KD every 3 minutes while asked to be Davion Mitchell on defense the whole game.
Coaching matters.
So, you blame Nurse for Barnes not having a good 2nd year but do you give credit to Nurse for a break out rookie season that exceeded expectations?
Nurse had the ball in Barnes' hands a lot to start last year. FVV was even saying how he was sacrificing his game for the betterment of the team by having the ball less in his hands. They tried to get him into the primary playmaking role for this team and he wasn't ready for the responsibility last season and he is this year. The difference is really the first 2 seasons he showed flashes of what he's doing now but this year he's a lot more consistent with his play.
I do find that kinda weird like Scottie was drafted as a project look at some of the preseason expectations. Before the preseason most people probably had like 10 6 3 or something along those lines. Scottie was coming off a pretty meh College season as well. And Nurse found out pretty quickly how talented he is and gave him all the mins and touches he could handle as a rookie.
I give Nurse credit for giving him minutes, although not much there as he was a top 5 pick on a team that's been shedding talent. It's kind of expected.
Barnes showed raw talent right off the bat, especially his playmaking. He had a great campaign with very little of the team scheme designed around his strengths. I was advocating for this to be changed mid-season, but understandable that it may take an offseason.
We go to the offseason...and absolutely nothing changes. We play the exact same way, prioritizing gimmicks and iso over tailoring more of the O/D around his strengths. This is confirmed by the FO/players, including Scottie, the season is a trainwreck absent development, and added regression for him.
All that changes this year, we see most of the changes that I wanted, he thrives under those changes, etc.
It's a pretty clear progression that fits the information we have on hand. Now you can say that all the players and FO were lying, that Nurse is responsible for everything that was good, but has no involvement in anything that went wrong. I just think my interpretation of events stands on firmer ground.