mtcan wrote:Largely non-lethal? 1 million+ people worldwide have died in 7 months. I know you're just going to downplay the number because there are a few billion people in the world but you are grossly oversimplifying things. There's no need for that. 1 million people is still a lot of people...and it would mean even more to you if it were you or one of your loved ones who died.
1 million people dying from a virus and counting isn't nothing and I'm certainly not saying its nothing, but the thing is why is a covid death so much more significant and special than people dying from various other causes every single day? About 150,000 people die of various causes daily in the world and yet for people like you, its the covid deaths that have your upmost attention while some 49,000 people dying from cardiovascular diseases or 26,000 dying from various cancers or almost 11,000 people dying from respiratory diseases everyday around the world and that never gets the daily coverage that covid infections and deaths do.
The point is lets keep some perspective and understand that while covid is quite contagious its very far from being a world killing virus and there are many other things out there that kill many more humans on a daily basis than covid that we ignore and also don't shutdown the world for.
And your idea of just isolating long term care homes and everyone else going on with their lives? Once again...oversimplifying things.
1) How do you think people in nursing homes and long term care facilities got covid? It got brought in from the outside world. Where in the outside world? Family gatherings, restaurants, weddings in banquet halls. How else did these people get it? Infected staff members who live outside of these institutions.
It really IS that simple to isolate long term care homes if you implement a proper plan. If you test health care workers who work in these homes daily or every other day or something along those lines then you will find out very quickly if they've become infected and you can remove them from the home and tell them to quarantine. If a patient in these homes becomes infected then you isolated them from other patients and give them the care that they need.
If you find out that outside visitors are bringing the virus into the homes then you stop the visits or at least limit the number of people to a few close family members who have to be tested and come back negative before being allowed to enter. Simple procedures like these along with having enough PPE and other resources available to those homes is enough to minimize the spread among long term care facilities again.
Heck if you want to take really strong measures then why not simply have the workers stay longer in the home with their patients rather than going home everyday? Like have the worker stay for a week or two continuously in the home with the people they're caring for after they've tested negative for the virus and then the chances of the virus spreading becomes minimal when they're not going to and forth from home to work and in between. There was a long term care home in France where the workers isolated with their patients for like 1-2 months straight and they suffered zero virus deaths as a result because they were almost completely self-contained.
The bottom line is you don't need to shutdown society and destroy people's lives to limit the spread to vulnerable people and you'd have to be insane to think that's a viable longterm plan to keep doing so until an effective treatment is developed and becomes widely available to everyone in the world.
2) Guess what...seniors and vulnerable people don't just live in nursing homes and long term care facilities. That is just a portion of the vulnerable population overall. I'd say the majority of the vulnerable population live outside those institutions...and most likely live in their own homes where they still have to interact with the outside world. Some of the vulnerable in the outside world live alone...some live in a house with several generations of family including the 20 year old grand kids who do stupid things to put their grandparents' lives at risk.
You're right the majority of seniors don't live in long term care facilities and guess what? They DID NOT die by the thousands as a result of coming into contact with the outside world. Again I'll point out that there are almost 3 million seniors in Ontario and outside of LTC facilities, only about 800-900 seniors died in the entire province OUT OF 3 MILLION. So NO people potentially bringing home the virus to grandma and grandpa DID NOT result in the death of thousands and thousands of seniors outside of LTC facilities probably because many if not most of them were at least decently healthy enough to survive getting infected unlike those that are much weaker and need to live in nursing homes that provide around the clock care.
When you're in poor enough health that you can't even cook your own meals or take a shower without help, then you're in pretty bad condition and you're likely to die by anything compared to seniors who are capable of doing those basic things. So please I wish people like you and all our experts and politicians would stop with the 'well you're going to spread it to grandparents' guilt tripping crap to keep people scared of the virus when its been shown seniors in the general population aren't dying by the tens of thousands after all these months.