OakleyDokely wrote:HumbleRen wrote:OakleyDokely wrote:
I know he's younger, but I'd much rather have Lillard given their current window. Butler's already 34 and their window of contention is only as long as Butler's continued greatness which might be only a season or two more.
Sure but Donavan gives them the bridge in a post Jimmy Butler world. Mitchell and Bam can be a foundation for a playoff team for the next several years. They're both practically the same age too.
Jimmy and Dame are entering the wrong side of 30 now. Would they love to have Dame ? Of course but is it the end all be all for the Heat ? I don't believe so.
Bam/Mitchell is a solid core, but those guys are #2/#3 guys on a championship level team and you'd still lack a #1 which will be very difficult to acquire without cap space or big trade chips.
I think you need to maximize Butler's window and Lillard does this the best. MIA is probably the favorite in the East with Lillard. I'd try to win now while it's wide open and if doesn't work out, move out Butler's, Lillard's big deals, create cap space and go after the best FAs.
I get that as a franchise, no in general MIA doesn't have to panic that they won't get stars in the future.
BUT opportunity is a HUGE thing in sports as we know firsthand with Kawhi, Miami's window is RIGHT NOW.
Plus why would MIA just assume they'll get Mitchell?! The dually ironic thing about that is A) Donovan tried to push his to NY, ended up in CLE B) Dame tried to push his way there, ends up in TOR. They can't just bank on winning the next trade with bad assets or free agency when players may have their own plans. You're talking about Mitchell but he's was long rumoured to go HOME to NY, not MIA so even in FA but especially if MIA misses on Dame, what would make MIA so appealing by the time DM is a FA?! MIA will trend downwards as Jimmy ages & NYK is actually by small increments improving. There's absolutely no guarantee he goes there especially when who's to say he doesn't speak with Embiid to go team up when they're FAs somewhere or whatever other star player he may get along with. There's way too many variables to just ASSUME you'll get another star.
But the other thing is let's be real, THE biggest reason for MIA's recent success JIMMY BUTLER (period), not Bam - Himmy. Without Jimmy going God Mode, the Heat are just a bunch of roleplayers. You could trade Bam for another defensive C & Miami would be a fairly similar result, his impact is very role specific. You couldn't trade Butler for just any wing & expect a similar outcome. Miami is scary BECAUSE of the Dame + Jimmy duo surrounded by great roleplayers that buy in, not Dame + Bam plus roleplayers.
So really at the CORE of why Miami could win is a Dame + Jimmy duo, Jimmy is THE biggest reason MIA has had the success it has & it's wanting to capitalize on that & add to THAT, that MIA needs to build on to get over the hump. If the goal is just being a franchise that can attract another star, no MIA doesn't have anything to worry about -- if MIA wants to capitalize on the opportunity they have as a result of having Jimmy Butler, yes they NEED to get Dame right now. Jimmy has already broken down physically several times, there's only probably a year or two to strike. They can't wait on Mitchell & Bam is not the difference maker.