Page 33 of 35

Re: MEM shopping Rudy Gay (Raps interested, PHX in lead? P.

Posted: Wed Jan 9, 2013 12:29 am
by Double Helix
Harry Palmer wrote:DH:

Hypothetical.

The Raptors play exactly the same way they are playing now.

Only the league changes the rules so that instead of almost 60% of teams making the playoffs, almost 90% do.

Is your experience watching the exact same games played by the exact same players different? Is the bad basketball better?

If it is, isn't the solution to be found within our own perspectives? Just decide that today we want 100 points/pizza. Tomorrow we want a lot of 3s. W/e. it's not about having a chance to win it all, so let's set our own goals. As you say, the league sets their lines based on marketing...why do we buy in if the reality isn't different? We're seeing the top w/e % of basketball players in the world playing the game...if we abandon the need to build a real winner, why not find contentment wherever we look?


Harry, I want to reply to this but can't. I'm heading out for the night but will later. If you see it, awesome. If not, I wasn't ignoring.

Re: MEM shopping Rudy Gay (Raps interested, PHX in lead? P.

Posted: Wed Jan 9, 2013 12:43 am
by cdel00
For me it's about watching the game played the right way. The thrill of long stretches of great team work on both ends of the court. The oohs and aahs of a well set pick. The joy of beautiful defensive rotations. The crispness of a buttery smooth stroke on a wide open shot created by a well executed play. Etc.

I often hear that only thing that counts is the W but I disagree. I think the only thing that counts is the performance during the 200 or so possessions. The result is not as meaningful to me as the play that lead to the result.

I want to see proper execution for 200 plays.

Win or lose I don't care for me it's all about the content that lead to the result.

Re: MEM shopping Rudy Gay (Raps interested, PHX in lead? P.

Posted: Wed Jan 9, 2013 12:44 am
by Big Shot
Wall(2010), Irving(2011),and Davis(2012) were all consensus #1 pick and considered as franchise players.

I would be interested in waiting patiently and knowing how long it would take for their teams to turn into contenders. :D

Re: MEM shopping Rudy Gay (Raps interested, PHX in lead? P.

Posted: Wed Jan 9, 2013 12:51 am
by Harry Palmer
cdel00 wrote:For me it's about watching the game played the right way. The thrill of long stretches of great team work on both ends of the court. The oohs and aahs of a well set pick. The joy of beautiful defensive rotations. The crispness of a buttery smooth stroke on a wide open shot created by a well executed play. Etc.

I often hear that only thing that counts is the W but I disagree. I think the only thing that counts is the performance during the 200 or so possessions. The result is not as meaningful to me as the play that lead to the result.

I want to see proper execution for 200 plays.

Win or lose I don't care for me it's all about the content that lead to the result.



Why watch the NBA? You sound like a natural NCAA fan.

Re: MEM shopping Rudy Gay (Raps interested, PHX in lead? P.

Posted: Wed Jan 9, 2013 12:53 am
by Harry Palmer
Double Helix wrote:
Harry, I want to reply to this but can't. I'm heading out for the night but will later. If you see it, awesome. If not, I wasn't ignoring.


Cheers. Have a good one.

Re: MEM shopping Rudy Gay (Raps interested, PHX in lead? P.

Posted: Wed Jan 9, 2013 12:55 am
by cdel00
Harry Palmer wrote:
cdel00 wrote:For me it's about watching the game played the right way. The thrill of long stretches of great team work on both ends of the court. The oohs and aahs of a well set pick. The joy of beautiful defensive rotations. The crispness of a buttery smooth stroke on a wide open shot created by a well executed play. Etc.

I often hear that only thing that counts is the W but I disagree. I think the only thing that counts is the performance during the 200 or so possessions. The result is not as meaningful to me as the play that lead to the result.

I want to see proper execution for 200 plays.

Win or lose I don't care for me it's all about the content that lead to the result.



Why watch the NBA? You sound like a natural NCAA fan.


I like both :)

Re: MEM shopping Rudy Gay (Raps interested, PHX in lead? P.

Posted: Wed Jan 9, 2013 1:18 am
by kmatrixg
Dr Positivity wrote:I love that PHX trade for Memphis. Dudley is exactly the type of player MEM needs to replace Gay with at SF. He'd be a permanent version of 2011 Battier for them spacing the floor, hitting open shots and moving the ball with a high IQ. Or basically the Tayshaun Prince to their 2000s Pistons. Don't think the Raps can compete with that offer even if they put Ross in the trade, because MEM is still trying to win a title the next 2 years and nothing we can offer helps that as much as PHX giving them that Dudley glue guy piece on the wings


This is basically spot on to what is going on. People downplaying Dudley haven't analyzed much of what the guy does. With Conley, Randolph and Gasol, they don't need much playmaking ability - especially at the behest of 19 million a season. Dudley will do the job well, and for a fifth of the cost. We can't compete with the offer, and I haven't seen Hollinger talk well about one of our players for YEARS. Dudley is a Hollinger star - cheap and efficient.

Re: MEM shopping Rudy Gay (Raps interested, PHX in lead? P.

Posted: Wed Jan 9, 2013 1:24 am
by suntzuballin
i can see this trade go down but beasly probly going other way grizz have no one to man the 3 spot i see grizz being even stronger team with dudly and beasly plus the get the lakers pick i bet rather then give up there own too the suns missed out on Gordon so Rudy Gay be there centerpiece

Re: MEM shopping Rudy Gay (Raps interested, PHX in lead? P.

Posted: Wed Jan 9, 2013 1:32 am
by fredericklove
Can someone help me think of ways to obtain both Gay and Milsap, trade offer scenario whatever without hitting over the caps.

Lowry
DD
Gay
Milsap
Val

Fapworthy.

Re: MEM shopping Rudy Gay (Raps interested, PHX in lead? P.

Posted: Wed Jan 9, 2013 1:33 am
by Marvin Martian
kmatrixg wrote:
Dr Positivity wrote:I love that PHX trade for Memphis. Dudley is exactly the type of player MEM needs to replace Gay with at SF. He'd be a permanent version of 2011 Battier for them spacing the floor, hitting open shots and moving the ball with a high IQ. Or basically the Tayshaun Prince to their 2000s Pistons. Don't think the Raps can compete with that offer even if they put Ross in the trade, because MEM is still trying to win a title the next 2 years and nothing we can offer helps that as much as PHX giving them that Dudley glue guy piece on the wings


This is basically spot on to what is going on. People downplaying Dudley haven't analyzed much of what the guy does. With Conley, Randolph and Gasol, they don't need much playmaking ability - especially at the behest of 19 million a season. Dudley will do the job well, and for a fifth of the cost. We can't compete with the offer, and I haven't seen Hollinger talk well about one of our players for YEARS. Dudley is a Hollinger star - cheap and efficient.


Didn't MEM have similar player in Shane Battier 2 years ago? How did that work for them in their championship quest? TOR can offer a much better package for Gay than PHX.

Re: MEM shopping Rudy Gay (Raps interested, PHX in lead? P.

Posted: Wed Jan 9, 2013 1:55 am
by Snakeyes
Hope he ends up on the Suns. Once Gay is traded, there won't be any knee-jerk BC treadmill moves left, right?

Re: MEM shopping Rudy Gay (Raps interested, PHX in lead? P.

Posted: Wed Jan 9, 2013 2:02 am
by SwaggWagg
Snakeyes wrote:Hope he ends up on the Suns. Once Gay is traded, there won't be any knee-jerk BC treadmill moves left, right?



So Rudy Gay would be a treadmill move? :lol:


This fanbase never stops amazing. :P

Re: MEM shopping Rudy Gay (Raps interested, PHX in lead? P.

Posted: Wed Jan 9, 2013 2:07 am
by Wo1verine
SwaggWagg wrote:
Snakeyes wrote:Hope he ends up on the Suns. Once Gay is traded, there won't be any knee-jerk BC treadmill moves left, right?



So Rudy Gay would be a treadmill move? :lol:


This fanbase never stops amazing. :P

Adding Rudy Gay is defiantly a treadmill move..

adding him doesn't take us to the next level.

Re: MEM shopping Rudy Gay (Raps interested, PHX in lead? P.

Posted: Wed Jan 9, 2013 2:10 am
by SwaggWagg
Ross, Davis, Bargnani, Calderon, Pick

For

Randolph, Gay


Lowry
Derozan
Gay
Randolph
Valanciunas

Re: MEM shopping Rudy Gay (Raps interested, PHX in lead? P.

Posted: Wed Jan 9, 2013 2:12 am
by SwaggWagg
Wo1verine wrote:
SwaggWagg wrote:
Snakeyes wrote:Hope he ends up on the Suns. Once Gay is traded, there won't be any knee-jerk BC treadmill moves left, right?



So Rudy Gay would be a treadmill move? :lol:


This fanbase never stops amazing. :P

Adding Rudy Gay is defiantly a treadmill move..

adding him doesn't take us to the next level.



We'll not get a player anywhere near that talented anytime soon. Fans of this team being this absurdly picky is ridicuous considering our history.

Re: MEM shopping Rudy Gay (Raps interested, PHX in lead? P.

Posted: Wed Jan 9, 2013 2:15 am
by TheWire
SwaggWagg wrote:Ross, Davis, Bargnani, Calderon, Pick

For

Randolph, Gay


Lowry
Derozan
Gay
Randolph
Valanciunas


Championship time

Re: MEM shopping Rudy Gay (Raps interested, PHX in lead? P.

Posted: Wed Jan 9, 2013 2:17 am
by TheWire
What BC should be looking at is dealing Demar+ed for Cousins
followed by ross+Bargnani+Calderon for Gay

a starting 5 of
lowry

gay
cousins
Val

Re: MEM shopping Rudy Gay (Raps interested, PHX in lead? P.

Posted: Wed Jan 9, 2013 2:17 am
by Wo1verine
SwaggWagg wrote:We'll not get a player anywhere near that talented anytime soon. Fans of this team being this absurdly picky is ridicuous considering our history.

That's true, but unless we're contender's , i don't care because our roster isn't talented enough with gay and that's not a knock on him! we're just not in a position to be adding high priced players to a mediocre roster at this point.

Re: MEM shopping Rudy Gay (Raps interested, PHX in lead? P.

Posted: Wed Jan 9, 2013 2:22 am
by JunkYardSubs
Wo1verine wrote:
SwaggWagg wrote:We'll not get a player anywhere near that talented anytime soon. Fans of this team being this absurdly picky is ridicuous considering our history.

That's true, but unless we're contender's , i don't care because our roster isn't talented enough with gay and that's not a knock on him! we're just not in a position to be adding high priced players to a mediocre roster at this point.

Yeah if we get Rudy we have to add more

If the goal is "be a decent playoff team":

Lowry
Demar
Gay
Milsap
Val

Thats a decent team, I don't like the idea though

Re: MEM shopping Rudy Gay (Raps interested, PHX in lead? P.

Posted: Wed Jan 9, 2013 2:22 am
by Snakeyes
SwaggWagg wrote:
Wo1verine wrote:
SwaggWagg wrote:So Rudy Gay would be a treadmill move? :lol:


This fanbase never stops amazing. :P

Adding Rudy Gay is defiantly a treadmill move..

adding him doesn't take us to the next level.



We'll not get a player anywhere near that talented anytime soon. Fans of this team being this absurdly picky is ridicuous considering our history.


The chance to draft a perfect prospect for this city like Wiggins may not reappear anytime soon either.