slothrop8 wrote:Local_NG_Idiot wrote:C_Money wrote:After watching for 5 years, why do people still think JV is a good fit for the starting lineup?
Strictly a function of maintaining the impact of the Lowry+bench unit. That unit plays pace and space with pressure defense style that requires the bigs to be far more mobile. Move JV to the bench and into that unit and you are getting rid of the one clear advantage this team has developed these past few seasons; they'll be forced to slow the pace down, abandon show and go P&R defense while adopting the zone/sag P&R defense that the starters play, and they lose their rim runners for earlier offense. The bigs that work in that 2nd unit have always been in the mold Amir/Biz/PPat/Psycho T and not the JV/Scola/Gray/Stiemsma variety.
I have to disagree. Without getting into all the 5 man lineups as the sample for each configuration are so small and instead rolling it up to just Lowry+Slow Big X ON and DeRozan OFF
I'm not a huge fan at all of individual on/off as it doesn't take into consideration the role of the player, the time of the game they are on or off and the level of competition they are playing against. However, I'll play along for the sake of debate:
Lowry+JV ON and DD OFF was 100.3 DRtg and + 12.4 NTrg in '15-'16
That's 300 possessions for an entire season so you are basing this premise on less than 4% of a game's possessions?
How about also looking at the control of Lowry+Biz ON DeRozan OFF to see if the numbers stay consistent?
970 possessions with that combination, a 95 DRtg and a +16.5 NetRtg. That is more than triple the possessions (over 12% of game possessions) with a big jump in defensive rating and a massive jump in NetRtg
Lowry+JV ON and DD OFF was 97.1 DRtg and +12.6 NTrg in '16-17
Lowry+Scola ON and DD OFF was 103.4 DRtg and +4.2 NtRtg in '16-'17
Scola wasn't on the team in '16-17 season. Did you intend for this to be part of '15-16?
for '16-17 PPat's and Ibaka's #s show far better NetRtgs in that same scenario.
The samples are even smaller for playoffs with Lowry +Slow Big X ON and DD OFF - but the defense is actually even better in the playoff samples than in the reg season. The success of the Lowry+Bench units has far less to do with who the big is and far more to do with the fact that it's Lowry and the team in general getting to play without DeRozan on the floor. When Lowry is playing and DeMar is not, we are a powerhouse with pretty great defensive numbers - regardless of the big - because DeMar is not killing our team D. It's very likely that Lowry and any 4 other Raptors who fill those Lowry + Bench minutes slot in the rotation will do extremely well as long as DeMar isn't one of the 4.
Your argument that attempts to shift this from "slow big" not being an issue to a "DD on the floor" issue doesn't hold up once you check the control of "slow big+Lowry" (in this case JV) vs "mobile big+Lowry". (in the cases I provided, PPat/Biz/Ibaka).
Again, I'm not a big proponent of this type of individual on/off analysis as there are just so many flaws based upon the dynamics of the game.