Official Scottie Barnes Thread
Moderators: HiJiNX, niQ, Morris_Shatford, DG88, Reeko, lebron stopper, 7 Footer, Duffman100
Re: Official Scottie Barnes Thread
-
- General Manager
- Posts: 8,689
- And1: 4,608
- Joined: Jul 24, 2006
Re: Official Scottie Barnes Thread
- blastttOFF
- General Manager
- Posts: 7,787
- And1: 8,803
- Joined: Mar 13, 2007
Re: Official Scottie Barnes Thread
It wasn’t too long ago when Realgm was crying for more shots and touches for a rookie Bargnani, with TJ Ford and Bosh taking most of the shots.
The Raptors ended up winning the division that year with a record of 47-35.
The Raptors ended up winning the division that year with a record of 47-35.
Re: Official Scottie Barnes Thread
-
- Head Coach
- Posts: 6,849
- And1: 5,349
- Joined: Aug 22, 2017
Re: Official Scottie Barnes Thread
Realgm will never change lolblastttOFF wrote:It wasn’t too long ago when Realgm was crying for more shots and touches for a rookie Bargnani, with TJ Ford and Bosh taking most of the shots.
The Raptors ended up winning the division that year with a record of 47-35.
Sent from my SM-G960W using RealGM mobile app
Re: Official Scottie Barnes Thread
- nowayguy
- Senior
- Posts: 645
- And1: 662
- Joined: Apr 10, 2011
Re: Official Scottie Barnes Thread
blastttOFF wrote:It wasn’t too long ago when Realgm was crying for more shots and touches for a rookie Bargnani, with TJ Ford and Bosh taking most of the shots.
The Raptors ended up winning the division that year with a record of 47-35.
Fun fact: Bargnani would have ended up with a HOF career if he had taken 2 more shots during his rookie season.
Re: Official Scottie Barnes Thread
- Potential
- RealGM
- Posts: 19,427
- And1: 44,040
- Joined: Feb 28, 2015
Re: Official Scottie Barnes Thread
Yes he willDreamTeam09 wrote:Raps in 4 wrote:Potential wrote:When we drafted Scottie Barnes, a lot of Toronto Raptor fans had a lot of negative things to say about the pick. We've seen it time and time again Masai Ujiri is a genius especially when it comes to scouting and drafting players. After a lot of work, I have finally found my reaction from draft night.
Thu Jul 29, 2021 11:34 pm
Scottie Barnes is the next Scottie Pippen you heard it here first
**** Pippen. Scottie is going to be better offensively.
I definitely thought he had high bust potential and was extremely down on the pick. Shows how little we know. Dude looked like he was shooting a basketball for the first time in college. Now he's arguably our best shot creator and finisher.
I won't be doing any amateur scouting again as long as Masai and Co. are running the team. It leads one down a dark path.
He absolutely will not be a better player than Scottie pippen and even that in itself is quite okay
Re: Official Scottie Barnes Thread
-
- RealGM
- Posts: 17,338
- And1: 21,180
- Joined: Nov 23, 2017
Re: Official Scottie Barnes Thread
nowayguy wrote:blastttOFF wrote:It wasn’t too long ago when Realgm was crying for more shots and touches for a rookie Bargnani, with TJ Ford and Bosh taking most of the shots.
The Raptors ended up winning the division that year with a record of 47-35.
Fun fact: Bargnani would have ended up with a HOF career if he had taken 2 more shots during his rookie season.
And barnes just had his 13 games. Only it happened at the very beginning of his career.
Re: Official Scottie Barnes Thread
-
- RealGM
- Posts: 18,876
- And1: 9,936
- Joined: Feb 02, 2007
Re: Official Scottie Barnes Thread
I know many people are disturbed / tad upset about Scottie's recent usage.
But I don't think its a terrible thing to slowly ease him into things and let Scottie gain confidence in what he does well. I don't think its great to put him into high usage situations for a long 80 game season.
Obviously as the season progresses (and if we go into tank mode) we should look to expand his time with the ball. But easing him in and not overwhelming, or having him make too many mistakes is not a bad strategy for the first half of the season.
But I don't think its a terrible thing to slowly ease him into things and let Scottie gain confidence in what he does well. I don't think its great to put him into high usage situations for a long 80 game season.
Obviously as the season progresses (and if we go into tank mode) we should look to expand his time with the ball. But easing him in and not overwhelming, or having him make too many mistakes is not a bad strategy for the first half of the season.
Re: Official Scottie Barnes Thread
- HumbleRen
- RealGM
- Posts: 16,758
- And1: 23,109
- Joined: Jul 02, 2021
Re: Official Scottie Barnes Thread
A lot of learning lessons for Scottie tonight.
Positives
- Turned it on in the third quarter and brought us back into the game.
- Made fantastic reads
Negatives
- Cannot guard PG's or SG's like I keep saying.
- Needs to be more athletic when he doesn't have a running start. (can be remedied by having tighter handles so he can get to his spots easier)
- Obvious mistakes at the end of the game
Positives
- Turned it on in the third quarter and brought us back into the game.
- Made fantastic reads
Negatives
- Cannot guard PG's or SG's like I keep saying.
- Needs to be more athletic when he doesn't have a running start. (can be remedied by having tighter handles so he can get to his spots easier)
- Obvious mistakes at the end of the game
Re: Official Scottie Barnes Thread
- seanbig
- RealGM
- Posts: 10,474
- And1: 3,879
- Joined: Feb 12, 2005
- Location: wrong side of canada for raps
Re: Official Scottie Barnes Thread
Scottie has that Kobe rookie moment where he dribbled the ball off his leg in the clutch (ie turnover) and shot an air ball three (ie his stuff by McCollum-embarrassing)
Official 1,000,000 post crew
Raptor95,Seanbig,Spykelee,ClutchCarter,
aRapsFan4eva,Koz RJC, MAS, Slowlydrowningme,bigdub,GQstylin
Raptor95,Seanbig,Spykelee,ClutchCarter,
aRapsFan4eva,Koz RJC, MAS, Slowlydrowningme,bigdub,GQstylin
Re: Official Scottie Barnes Thread
-
- Senior
- Posts: 596
- And1: 59
- Joined: Oct 28, 2008
Re: Official Scottie Barnes Thread
Scottie can absolutely guard sgs. Let's not get ridiculous.
His defensive game last night was terrific when you consider how tough this defensive system is for a rookie.
His defensive game last night was terrific when you consider how tough this defensive system is for a rookie.
Re: Official Scottie Barnes Thread
-
- Analyst
- Posts: 3,605
- And1: 3,215
- Joined: May 02, 2009
Re: Official Scottie Barnes Thread
TheBunk wrote:Scottie can absolutely guard sgs. Let's not get ridiculous.
His defensive game last night was terrific when you consider how tough this defensive system is for a rookie.
Defensive system or do you mean defensive assignment? Because as far as I can tell switching on screens is easier and simpler than constantly rotating.
Re: Official Scottie Barnes Thread
-
- General Manager
- Posts: 9,690
- And1: 12,725
- Joined: May 26, 2007
Re: Official Scottie Barnes Thread
Rough finish for Barnes but I thought he was great the first 3.5 quarters.
Good learning game for him.
Good learning game for him.
Re: Official Scottie Barnes Thread
- Psubs
- RealGM
- Posts: 17,858
- And1: 10,660
- Joined: Nov 20, 2004
- Location: Toronto
Re: Official Scottie Barnes Thread
Danny1616 wrote:Rough finish for Barnes but I thought he was great the first 3.5 quarters.
Good learning game for him.
I think cutting his minutes so he can perform better for the whole rest of the season is best. Keep him fresh.
PG FVV - Banton/Flynn
SG Trent - Svi - Dragic
SF OG - Barnes - Yuta
PF Siakam - Barnes
C Birch - Barnes - Achiuwa
Like last night, Barnes vs Zeller might be a better matchup for Scottie. Birch on Nurkic better too as a starter.
Re: Official Scottie Barnes Thread
-
- Senior
- Posts: 596
- And1: 59
- Joined: Oct 28, 2008
Re: Official Scottie Barnes Thread
MoneyBall wrote:TheBunk wrote:Scottie can absolutely guard sgs. Let's not get ridiculous.
His defensive game last night was terrific when you consider how tough this defensive system is for a rookie.
Defensive system or do you mean defensive assignment? Because as far as I can tell switching on screens is easier and simpler than constantly rotating.
I mean more so his variety of defensive assignments. He's guarding Dame and he's also guarding centres down low. It's a miracle the dude isn't fouling out every other game considering that he's being asked to do everything on the nba court as a rookie.
Also think his rotations have improved quite a bit and his boxing out is, as always, terrific.
Re: Official Scottie Barnes Thread
-
- RealGM
- Posts: 39,952
- And1: 21,980
- Joined: Apr 28, 2008
Re: Official Scottie Barnes Thread
Danny1616 wrote:Rough finish for Barnes but I thought he was great the first 3.5 quarters.
Good learning game for him.
What does he have to learn from this one? He dropped the ball 2X, which happens to everyone and is a statistical blip. Getting blocked by CJ? Who cares? It was a great defensive play. I thought this was his best game. He was super-involved in the offense, especially working with/off Siakam. He took on that hostile crowd and Dame's lame frontrunning taunting and led the charge for multiple comebacks. He was screaming up the court off misses. Guys are going to give up blow-bys to Lillard and McCollum. They're excellent ballhandlers that can score from everywhere. We sucked at things like DRebounds, PnR coverage, overhelping. The whole team was guilty.
Re: Official Scottie Barnes Thread
-
- General Manager
- Posts: 9,690
- And1: 12,725
- Joined: May 26, 2007
Re: Official Scottie Barnes Thread
ATLTimekeeper wrote:Danny1616 wrote:Rough finish for Barnes but I thought he was great the first 3.5 quarters.
Good learning game for him.
What does he have to learn from this one? He dropped the ball 2X, which happens to everyone and is a statistical blip. Getting blocked by CJ? Who cares? It was a great defensive play. I thought this was his best game. He was super-involved in the offense, especially working with/off Siakam. He took on that hostile crowd and Dame's lame frontrunning taunting and led the charge for multiple comebacks. He was screaming up the court off misses. Guys are going to give up blow-bys to Lillard and McCollum. They're excellent ballhandlers that can score from everywhere. We sucked at things like DRebounds, PnR coverage, overhelping. The whole team was guilty.
I said he was great for the first 3.5 quarters.
He had a couple sloppy turnovers stepping out of bounds, and could have finished stronger a couple times, but overall he's been fantastic.
I never said the loss was on him either.
Re: Official Scottie Barnes Thread
-
- RealGM
- Posts: 39,952
- And1: 21,980
- Joined: Apr 28, 2008
Re: Official Scottie Barnes Thread
Danny1616 wrote:ATLTimekeeper wrote:Danny1616 wrote:Rough finish for Barnes but I thought he was great the first 3.5 quarters.
Good learning game for him.
What does he have to learn from this one? He dropped the ball 2X, which happens to everyone and is a statistical blip. Getting blocked by CJ? Who cares? It was a great defensive play. I thought this was his best game. He was super-involved in the offense, especially working with/off Siakam. He took on that hostile crowd and Dame's lame frontrunning taunting and led the charge for multiple comebacks. He was screaming up the court off misses. Guys are going to give up blow-bys to Lillard and McCollum. They're excellent ballhandlers that can score from everywhere. We sucked at things like DRebounds, PnR coverage, overhelping. The whole team was guilty.
I said he was great for the first 3.5 quarters.
He had a couple sloppy turnovers stepping out of bounds, and could have finished stronger a couple times, but overall he's been fantastic.
I never said the loss was on him either.
I think they called it a travel when the ball deflected off the defender back to him. The ref was in terrible position to make the call. I don't think these are learning moments. Bad stuff does happen when you're pressing to come back in games. To call it sloppy isn't right. There's no "I'll catch the ball next time." You could easily see Fred or Pascal, or any vet make these same mistakes and it wouldn't bat an eye.
The game was lost on the defensive end, and some of that was Scottie. But, the end of the game was just a desperation run that didn't all line-up.
One thing realgm loves to focus on are these minute moments within a game to harp on weaknesses. Like, people will still bring up DeMar dribbling the ball off his foot at the end of a game, or Pascal blowing some endings. When I see people say Scottie blew this one, or that this is a rookie moment, I don't buy it. He was awesome, and then had some badly timed turnovers.
Re: Official Scottie Barnes Thread
-
- General Manager
- Posts: 9,353
- And1: 5,459
- Joined: Jun 03, 2001
Re: Official Scottie Barnes Thread
ATLTimekeeper wrote:Danny1616 wrote:Rough finish for Barnes but I thought he was great the first 3.5 quarters.
Good learning game for him.
What does he have to learn from this one? He dropped the ball 2X, which happens to everyone and is a statistical blip. Getting blocked by CJ? Who cares? It was a great defensive play. I thought this was his best game. He was super-involved in the offense, especially working with/off Siakam. He took on that hostile crowd and Dame's lame frontrunning taunting and led the charge for multiple comebacks. He was screaming up the court off misses. Guys are going to give up blow-bys to Lillard and McCollum. They're excellent ballhandlers that can score from everywhere. We sucked at things like DRebounds, PnR coverage, overhelping. The whole team was guilty.
In the 4th, after Lillard was talking smack to Barnes, Scottie followed it up with a couple great defensive posssessions......on one possession he forced him into missing a contested step back 3 and next possession, his length forced Lillard to miss a wild layup. Scottie has IT.
That said, the current role he has is absolutely perfect for his long term development. I actually dont want to see him forced into a high usage role this early in his career.
Re: Official Scottie Barnes Thread
-
- RealGM
- Posts: 39,952
- And1: 21,980
- Joined: Apr 28, 2008
Re: Official Scottie Barnes Thread
KrazyP wrote:ATLTimekeeper wrote:Danny1616 wrote:Rough finish for Barnes but I thought he was great the first 3.5 quarters.
Good learning game for him.
What does he have to learn from this one? He dropped the ball 2X, which happens to everyone and is a statistical blip. Getting blocked by CJ? Who cares? It was a great defensive play. I thought this was his best game. He was super-involved in the offense, especially working with/off Siakam. He took on that hostile crowd and Dame's lame frontrunning taunting and led the charge for multiple comebacks. He was screaming up the court off misses. Guys are going to give up blow-bys to Lillard and McCollum. They're excellent ballhandlers that can score from everywhere. We sucked at things like DRebounds, PnR coverage, overhelping. The whole team was guilty.
In the 4th, after Lillard was talking smack to Barnes, Scottie followed it up with a couple great defensive posssessions......on one possession he forced him into missing a contested step back 3 and next possession, his length forced Lillard to miss a wild layup. Scottie has IT.
That said, the current role he has is absolutely perfect for his long term development. I actually dont want to see him forced into a high usage role this early in his career.
He was flat-out incredible. Did he have two and1s? What's this "not going up with force" nonsense? CJ blocked him as he was going up to dunk, and it was a great block.
imo Scottie took exactly one bad shot. He hit a transition pull up jumper and then on the next play had Norm on him and settled for another. Nurse benched him for that. They're developing his attack mode instincts. And yeah, he took a lot of **** from Lillard and kept throwing counters.
Re: Official Scottie Barnes Thread
- Hero_Panda
- Veteran
- Posts: 2,520
- And1: 3,994
- Joined: Oct 15, 2015
- Location: SHINE ON!
Re: Official Scottie Barnes Thread
The notion that Barnes should come off the bench has got to stop.
"My life has been full of terrible misfortunes most of which never happened."-Montaigne
"at the Fed level, I'm a libertarian; state level, Republican; local level, Democrat; family and friends level, a socialist."-G & V Graham
"at the Fed level, I'm a libertarian; state level, Republican; local level, Democrat; family and friends level, a socialist."-G & V Graham