ATLTimekeeper wrote:tecumseh18 wrote:WaltFrazier wrote:Barnes really better than OG?
I feel like guys like Simmons and other Americans see the Raptors as a source of talent to make other teams better. They don't look into or care how it affects the Raps.
I still like PER as a quick and dirty assessment of what a player brings to a team. Interesting that the Kings' top two players (Sabonis and Fox) have a higher PER than the Raptors' top two players. Of course, it doesn't help that the Raps don't even have a #2 player worthy of the designation. Malik Monk has a higher PER than any of our other four starters after Pascal.
Anyway, for what it's worth, O.G.'s PER of 15.5 is higher than H. Barnes' PER of 14.9. And then when you add in the defensive capability, there's no comparison. But if Masai believes in Murray - and a lot of people seem to - this is the sort of trade that should be made.
I don't even think Hollinger would use PER anymore.
Well, ESPN does. Basketball-reference.com also still include PER as one of their stats.
It ultimately comes down to an eye/smell test, and from comparing the PER leaders to the Win Share leaders, I'd have to say PER is in better accordance with my humble opinion. Unless you agree with WS that Sabonis is the third best player in the league, Giannis is #18, and Pascal is not in the top 20 (while DeMar is #12). Giannis climbs back to #10 under VORP, still behind Sabonis, Haliburton and Donovan Mitchell and slightly ahead of Julius Randle (!?!)
Oddly, they don't have net Offensive rating - defensive rating. NBA.com does feature a net rating stat, with the top two spots going to:
Jokic is #3, and a bunch of nobodies (and Aaron Gordon) round out Top Ten.
For PIE, the top 10 looks legit. Way down the list, Harrison Barnes is #97, and OG is at #100. Interestingly, Obi Toppin is #87, and Keldon Johnson (who Spurs drafted with the pick we sent in the Kawhi trade and who I've always considered to be the dictionary definition of a replacement-level player) is #89. Drew Eubanks, is #91. Personally, I’d rather have OG than Eubanks, who admittedly sports a slightly higher PER than OG. Speaking of Masai/Bobby mistakes, Yuta and OPJ are tied.
An interesting diversion on a Saturday afternoon, but it does raise the question of the extent to which we overrate our own players, even such a sought-after piece like OG. Pascal barely scrapes the top 20 in these lists, if he shows up at all. Raps have had such a miserable season, which kills a lot of the advanced stats based on plus/minus. But you need talent to win. Do we have nearly enough?