ThunderBolt wrote:I’m not interested in trading shai. We have every reason to believe he wants to be here right now and I don’t understand wanting to trade him away. Barnes is nice but he’s a significantly worse fit with Giddey. Also, Toronto should not trade Barnes to accommodate OG. If push comes to shove, moving OG is the right move.
It wouldn't be done to accommodate OG, just he's no longer unhappy if it happens. I do think both starting 5s make more sense after a swap like this. The idea would be Toronto upgrades it's roster now with hometown players who they can plug in for many years to come.
Barnes is a bad fit with Giddey? In the aggregate, the shooting would likely improve as you're trading out SGA/Dort/whoever for Barnes/Trent/maybe Mann or #12. Barnes also fits with the general philosophy of ball movement and positional flexibility.
retrobro90 wrote:This is a trade I would make if I were a heartless Daryl Morey/Danny Ainge type who didnt care about preserving culture/reputation amongst players. Realistically OKC can't be this cut throat in the longview. If I were just looking at this on paper I'd say yes for sure. I think Scottie is a future multi-time all star and with that many added years of team control it seems like a no brainer from that perspective. Again, in the real world, I would not do this as it sends the wrong message to everyone in that locker room and Shai has been nothing but good for OKC since he got here.
Only thing I'd say to this as I generally agree with what you said is you'd obviously get the players' thoughts on a potential move before doing anything. So them being receptive is assumed. Who knows, maybe the Canadian boys would be happy to play for a Toronto team ready to compete now. Everyone thought PG13 was happy here until we found out he asked for a trade. If they want to stay, they stay for sure.
But like I said, I'm not actively looking to trade Shai, getting someone like Barnes who is that good (and we think Presti likes) on a rookie deal would be a unique circumstance. Could probably add one more high lottery pick next season.















