DCasey91 wrote:2006 was peak Federer
2015 was peak Djokovic
These are the two most credible all time modern seasons.
Now if you want the metric comparison Djokovic has a way more stacked and accomplished and experienced top ten to go up against.
Peak Fed basically lost to a 20yr old world number 2 Nadal on clay (50-2 in 2005 and 26 - 0 2006 lol freak but the year before he was better overall more wins injury). Outside of that he won a crap ton. But the truth is Djokovic really did have the harder comp.
The results and peer comp paint a very very distinct picture on their best years in terms of accolades, titles and achievements. 2015 top ten is stacked.
Curious to see your argument for 2015 over 2011.
I'd venture to say this is similar to Lebron 2013 vs Lebron 2018. It boils down to preference?