CAT: Rosters and Contact Information-Jud is 3rd Judge

[CellarDoor]

viewtopic.php?f=340&t=891348

Have to find them in their individual posts, but it's the best I could do if they don't have it listed w/ their roster here. Not sure why they were edited out.

[why22]

whoever wants jrich i would like a young big man of similar value in return

[CellarDoor]

Wrong thread why22. Anything labeled 'CAT" is for the create-a-team gam, anything labeled GM-a-Team is where you want to post about your competition.

[Jud's Buechlers]

Cellar,

I hope you're not waiting on me to vote on the match ups. I didn't get an email or anything saying that you needed an additional judge. All I have seen is ShaqSux and yourself judging. If I am supposed to be the 3rd one, just let me know and I'll get on it. If not... good luck to all the teams!

[Sports Arsenal]

Jud, yes you are the third judge, go ahead and proceed with voting...Sorry I didn't remember who cellar said he had lined up for the third judge.

[Jud's Buechlers]

Sorry guys! I'll get right on it... I have my opinions of the match-ups... so I just need to put them in writing. I'll try to get them all out by the end of the day today.

[Jud's Buechlers]

Looks like I spoke too soon... seems like all of the 1st round match ups were clean sweeps (unless I'm missing one). So I'll just jump in on the second round judging.

[CellarDoor]

Yeah, they ended up working that way. Haha.

SS, what are we doing in rd III with three teams?

[Sports Arsenal]

Well I have 2 ideas, but I am definitely open for suggestions

1. The 3 judges place a 1st, a 2nd, and a 3rd place vote. Who ever ends up with the most first place votes is the winner.

2. Each team does a write up as if they were facing the other 2 teams, and then you end up with something like Team B is greater than Team C but not greater than Team A, and you get your winner like that...

Anybody have any suggestions?

[CellarDoor]

I would think in any instance we'd need two write-ups unless you're giving someone a bye. I can't judge how two teams would do without a game plan. Well, I can, but it wouldn't be fun.

[Jud's Buechlers]

We could do a small round robin:

Team 1 vs Team 2
Team 1 vs Team 3
Team 2 vs Team 3

Each team has two games. If one team wins 2 games... they would be the winner. The only drawback would be if each team won one game each. Then there would be a tie. But there could also be a tie with 1st place votes as well. Let me know your thoughts.

[Sports Arsenal]

I like the round robin idea, How do the participants and Cellar feel about this?

[Gremz]

I'm ok doing writeups for each (if i get through that ridiculous match with Vintage).

[CellarDoor]

Whatever is good for me. Although the tie would be disastrous.

[Sports Arsenal]

Its happened before, right Cash? lol

[Jud's Buechlers]

Ok... then how about in the case of a tie, we rank them 1, 2, 3. That can be the tie break.