I'm fine playing any of the four, but I voted for exclusion
Re: Which draft should we do next?
Posted: Fri Nov 29, 2024 9:18 pm
by Fadeaway_J
I'm concerned we won't get enough participants to make it challenging, but I voted for the 90s players draft.
Re: Which draft should we do next?
Posted: Fri Nov 29, 2024 9:39 pm
by Snakebites
I voted for my idea (Thanksgiving Leftovers)- I think it fits a smaller group of drafters and eliminates so many conventional team building options both in terms of top end talent and elite role players.
But I'll play any of them.
Re: Which draft should we do next?
Posted: Fri Nov 29, 2024 9:53 pm
by wackbone
Any would be fine to me, although TBH not sure if I'll have time or not.
Re: Which draft should we do next?
Posted: Sat Nov 30, 2024 12:12 am
by Laimbeer
Exclusion but I really won't be available until Monday
I opened the 90s players draft given poll results, but I'd vote for the Thanksgiving Leftovers Draft after that
Re: Which draft should we do next?
Posted: Thu Dec 5, 2024 6:37 pm
by durantbird
Seems like 2 wanted the exclusion idea (Laimbeer, Dr P) and 2 wanted the Thanksgiving (me and Snakebites).
I'll throw in here this recent idea that was and oned by Larry:
Goats franchise pairs
Pairs according to the top two franchises for GOAT candidates (from top 10 of the top 100 project in the PC board):
1. Miami Cavs 2. Bucks Lakers 3. Bulls Washington 4. Houston Toronto 5. Philly Warriors 6. Lakers Orlando 7. Minny Boston
But maybe if we want to play with the Thanksgiving Leftovers we should do it next, before the leftovers are getting too cold.
Re: Which draft should we do next?
Posted: Thu Dec 5, 2024 6:39 pm
by Snakebites
durantbird wrote:Seems like 2 wanted the exclusion idea (Laimbeer, Dr P) and 2 wanted the Thanksgiving (me and Snakebites).
I'll throw in here this recent idea that was and oned by Larry:
Goats franchise pairs
Pairs according to the top two franchises for GOAT candidates (from top 10 of the top 100 project in the PC board):
1. Miami Cavs 2. Bucks Lakers 3. Bulls Washington 4. Houston Toronto 5. Philly Warriors 6. Lakers Orlando 7. Minny Boston
But maybe if we want to play with the Thanksgiving Leftovers we should do it next, before the leftovers are getting too cold.
I’m Good either way.
Re: Which draft should we do next?
Posted: Thu Dec 5, 2024 6:53 pm
by MadNESS
Just pick one and roll with it
Re: Which draft should we do next?
Posted: Thu Dec 12, 2024 3:11 am
by MadNESS
How about:
Randomly assigned a team from the East and a team from the West, per drafter.
You “draft” 4 pairs, so 4 players from each team.
No draft per say, but we make our own teams and post the rosters
Only categories allowed: 1 MVP 1 All NBA 1 All Star 1 All D 1 Champ 3 other
We could have 20 teams used, so we could eliminate like the Wizards, Nets, Hawks, etc.
Re: Which draft should we do next?
Posted: Thu Dec 12, 2024 12:49 pm
by Larry_Russell
MadNESS wrote:How about:
Randomly assigned a team from the East and a team from the West, per drafter.
You “draft” 4 pairs, so 4 players from each team.
No draft per say, but we make our own teams and post the rosters
Only categories allowed: 1 MVP 1 All NBA 1 All Star 1 All D 1 Champ 3 other
We could have 20 teams used, so we could eliminate like the Wizards, Nets, Hawks, etc.
Can teams have the same player? I would have to assume so right? I think thats cool
Re: Which draft should we do next?
Posted: Thu Dec 12, 2024 1:32 pm
by Larry_Russell
We could do a GOAT draft.
You can only draft a top 5 player from the history of each team as per Ranker.
No FGA limit
Re: Which draft should we do next?
Posted: Thu Dec 12, 2024 1:51 pm
by durantbird
Larry_Russell wrote:We could do a GOAT draft.
You can only draft a top 5 player from the history of each team as per Ranker.
No FGA limit
Another variation here might be that only players who are top 5 for some club in their All-Time list of a certain category (PTS, REB, BLK, STL, AST, 3pt, etc.) are eligible. That would make it more neutral than Ranker.com, also will be probably a bit more friendly on the role players.