nate33 wrote:You misunderstand.
I don't disagree with you that McGee has to put on bulk and core strength, and has to do so with a minimal loss of athleticism. I just don't think that's all that difficult of a task to accomplish. Most young bigs start out weak and fill out as they mature, provided they have the initial frame (which McGee does). I consider it a given that McGee will eventually fill out. Physically, he'll develop the frame of a legit NBA center.
The question is whether or not he'll learn the mental aspects of the game. I'm a little concerned that his man to man defensive reputation is so bad despite playing against 6'-8" tall 21-year-olds in a moderately weak conference. The guy isn't a toothpick. He's pretty solid for a 21-year-old 7-footer. He's bigger and stronger than, say, Marcus Camby was coming out of college. You would think a guy with McGee's pedigree and his mother's tutelage would be a better defensive player. The fact that he isn't leads me to believe that he is lacking in the basketball IQ department.
Not really his fault, his mother raised him as a perimeter player, since bigs with outside skills attract the most attention and make the most money. He played guard early on in high school. When he was recruited to Nevada (then only ~6'9"-ish barefoot) they envisioned him as a Small Forward. He was 6'10" and _210_ lbs by freshman year, pretty light for the height.
He's added a couple inches since then of course, and just started to fill out with muscle, he hasn't learned to bang because he's never been big enough 'til this year. Fact is, whether or not he's still growing (!...) athletically he's still developing a ton. Between freshman year and this year he added 3 and a half inches to his vertical jump. Anyone who's ever worked on their ups will appreciate that's a real 'leap' in ups. So to speak.
I suspect if he gets a few rounds in Big Man camps and starts packing on that adult weight he'll learn to enjoy throwing his size around. He definitely get gleeful when he smacks the helloutta somebodies shot.
The knock on him in Nevada was that he didn't bring the focus at both ends, jogged back on defense, sprinted on offense. Again, I fully expect Randy Ayers to cure him of that habit. The other deal is that he's emotional, Wolfpack fans cite an incident where he kicked a ball into the stands, literally crying because a call didn't go his way. And that he tended to have crappy body language when refs would whistle him for fouls, etc. Eh, whatever, so he was immature, that happens with kids.
The biggest knock you hear (other than the perimeter play vs. banging thing) is that his mother is too outspoken and involved in his life. Fact is I'd hope she'd adopt a guy like Andray Blatche too, maybe keep him out of trouble. Having grown up around strong athletic women (Cynthis Cooper was his basketball rolemodel as a kid) it's tough to picture him trolling the DC steets looking to purchase the poontang. More likely he'll be dating one of the Washington Mystics in a couple years.
So. Point being, yeah, he's still developing. I worry less that he'll lose athleticism by putting on a shirt of muscle, because the fact is he's never gonna lose that remarkable length either way. But the truth is he's probably doomed one way or the other because he's notably not bowlegged, so there's clearly no hope.