badinage wrote:What I love is, we all know defense is half the game, yet the advanced stats that people trot out don’t include defense, of any kind.
So, by the reckoning of some formula, Deni is performing at the level of an 8th or 9th best player on a good team (what does that even mean, good team? The Celtics of 2022? Or the Celtics of 1986?).
Factor in his defense, which in a defensive graph I recently saw for wing defenders pegged him as Top 5 (more precisely, no. 4), and what does that get you?
And now factor in his age.
And now factor in where he is in his development.
1. PPA does include defense. That said, I'm not arguing that advanced stats like PPA are that great when
it comes to defense ratings. Neither does Kevin. Everyone knows defensive impact is hard
to measure accurately in a comprehensive way.
https://kevinbroom.com/ppa/2. What does a good team mean? Well I suppose it could mean a lot of things but lets start by saying
a + .500 team perhaps, or maybe a playoff team. No, I'm pretty sure it doesn't mean the 86 Celtics.
Suffice to say, I would disagree with anyone who suggests that how I (or Kevin) used the term
'good team' is deceptive, inaccurate or unfair.
Kevin is a pretty smart guy and came up with PPA to try to create as accurate a single number descriptive (metric)
that is as useful as possible. If you are unfamiliar with it, perhaps you should become more acquainted before
being as dismissive as your comments sound. Check out the link above. If you still think PPA is trash,
I'd be interested in your explanation as to why. And what single number metric you prefer.
3. Yes Deni is still pretty young and I would agree with anyone who expects he will get better given his
current age.
4. Where he is in his development? Here is where reasonable folks can differ.
It's said he needs to improve shooting and his left hand (which we hardly ever see him use).
I've heard discussion as to where expectations ought to be for an NBA player now
finishing his 3rd year on things like shooting and ball handling which are pretty
important for wing players.
On the whole, I think this (link below) is a fair analysis of where Deni is right now.
He's a promising young player who still needs to improve a fair amount
in order to become a really good player by which I'll define as performing
at the level of a top 6 player on a playoff team. Or with a PPA over 100
which is league average.
https://www.bulletsforever.com/2022/4/16/23027949/avdijas-second-season-was-a-step-in-the-right-direction-can-he-take-the-next-step