Dat2U wrote:My gut tells while Okongwu was the better college player, Achiuwa may be better in the NBA as a rebounder/defender and even as a face up option on the offensive end. I would lean taking Achiuwa over Okongwu at this point.
Interesting. You think this even after factoring their age difference? (Achiuwa is 1.2 years older.)
I can buy the argument that Achiuwa might end up as the slightly better defender/rebounder in the long run because of his superior athleticism and his demonstrated ability to rebound outside his immediate area. But I can't overlook that Okongwu is nearly as agile and quick on his feet despite carrying 20 extra pounds on his frame. I know Okongwu has the girth to hold his position against full-sized NBA centers, I'm not as sure Achiuwa can. So defensively, I think it might be a wash.
What separates them IMO is offense. Achiuwa can't shoot and is turnover prone. Those are pretty big red flags. It may well be the case that he never develops enough offensive game to be any kind of threat in the NBA. A good coach can hide a guy like that in the regular season and just put him in the dunker's spot; but in the playoffs, he can be exploited. Teams may give him the Montrez Harrell treatment and guard him with a big center whom they could just leave in the paint to clog up the lane.
Okongwu is far more likely to be at least a secondary offensive threat - good enough that teams can't cheat off of him. At the very least, Okongwu is much more NBA ready and is likely to contribute right away. Achiuwa is probably at least two full seasons of development away from being a guy who doesn't actively hurt the offense. That might not matter to a rebuilding team, but to a "reloading" team like us, that's a factor.