clubbing_caveman wrote:14 pages, and some still want EG out. I would have thought that 14 pages would have been enough to otherwise convince those folks.
The marriage between EG and EJ was a shotgun wedding, with Abe looking on as the godfather trying to keep the peace. EJ wanted to play a certain style...something that looked like the Princeton O and a defensive scheme that has no name with which to identify it (Crybaby was once at a loss for words when trying to describe the defensive scheme used by the Wiz). Its right to point out that defense was our major problem, but I dont think its EG's fault. The right defensive scheme could have made this bunch an average to above average defensive team. What more can EG do? Perhaps he should do the coaches job and dictate the defensive schemes...? You see, it normally works like this...the GM hires a coach. Its usually someone that the GM thinks he can work with, someone who is a good fit for the organization, someone who has some idea of what O and D he would like to run. Thats right, the coach dictates the type of O and D he wants to run. The GM gets the players that best suits that style of play. If the coach has no idea what type of D he want to run, how can the GM help you? He probably cant, other than hire a defensive coach. He tried to bring in the right defensive coach (Thiebs) to get things in the right direction, but we all have some idea what happened there. Just getting some really good defensive players may help...the players natural talent will come through and plays will be made. However, we will not capitalize on all of that players natural defensive talents (and the rest of the teams defensive talents) without a good defensive scheme.
I dont see many arguments stating that EG picked rotten offensive players. Some dont like the way AJ or CB, or GA put points on the board, but they did put point on the board, and they were ideal for the type of O that EJ was running.
I wonder if we'd still be considering if EG should go if this team was an average to above average defensive team, while still putting up the offensive numbers they were putting up.
EG has been good for us. He's got some good players, and made some good deals. He gets to stay.
+1
This just bring back flash backs. All the posts about the "big three" and how I hated the idea of ours, about how we needed to feed Haywood the ball more so he could develop and so we would have a post game so we could go inside out, about how we needed to line them up for the best combination of offense and defense instead of just offense because it the team that scores more points then the other team that wins, not the team that score a lot of points.
Posts about how complicated this offense was the learn. Hell, three years into it and I was still hearing how we weren't really running it completely yet. Posts, about how EFJ had no control over GA and his distracting antics and his shoot first with 20 seconds on the clock style. Posts about a coach who had no control over DS and his big month that he couldn't back up. And the 1000 posts about the stupid line ups, rotations and lack of minutes for Haywood and Blatche.
Plus the things we just reviewed. The dysfunctional organization that Abe put in place....again. Owner...coach... GM is not how it is done. Abe..EFJ..EG just like he did Abe..Wes Unseld...Nash. To add to that Abe has had a coach/GM in Unseld and player/VP in MJ.
The problem is at the top. Of all the GMs we have had over the last 30 years, EG is at the top of the list yet people want to get ride of him and roll the dice with Abe doing better.
Head...meet Sand
Seems people would just seem to like the .. lather.. rinse .. repeat ... insanity instead of sticking to a slower more solid course of action.
Look at all the quick fixing the Skins tried to do. And while people will complain about how we didn't draft well or we traded away our picks for vet that never gelled, people also are impatient with the rebuilding process. Well this Wiz org used to do the same thing the Skins have been doing.
But with the Wiz, we at least had a GM and we actually were rebuilding and winning at the same time. For my liking, I think we could have don't a better job of addressing the most pressing need with was developing our post players and a better overall offense and defensive concept with rotations the match it. But that is on the coach, not the GM. We all talked about how EG had to EJ proof the team. It's like people have forgotten this stuff already. It's just, need head on the table mentality.
Hey, given the kind of coaches we had been getting, EFJ was ok for a few years. We needed to stop the bleeding first and I don't think this team could have handled a top notch NBA coach right away nor would one come here. But after about 3 years, this team was ready for something more that EJ. This team did need first and foremost to have some stability and some taste of success.
But at this point, they could handle more. So the question is, can you get a very good to great coach to come coach this bunch ? I would have to think that there would be a lot of coaches interested in coaching this group of talent. And if that is true, EG has done his job. I also believe that even if we kept Tapps, we would be a lot better next year just given the talent we have so if we keep him, we will only look more attractive to other coaches in the future.
This team does not need blown up at all. We should be able to do what we have been doing, win while transitioning and reloading. But the day will come that one of AJ, CB or GA will get moved. I think it will be AJ. So we can move a star player and chance the dynamics of the team. That isn't blowing it up.
Haywood, CB and GA is a solid core to build around if they are used properly. Specially if they are
Center, SF, SG. Plus we have upside players in McGee and Blatche and now hopefully Crit. Adding a vet PG and a seasoned PF would chance a lot. Imagine adding Nash/Kidd and R Wallace. Players who can give you two good years while teaching the younger players and adding to the vet presence. I think this is what CB was getting at.
Haywood, R Wallace, CB, GA, Nash/Kidd
McGee, Blatche, DMAC, NY, Crit