Well, the first quote was from 2006, but the second one was from April 2010. During the playoffs. 2 months later, he did the exact opposite.
In April, before the 2010 playoffs, he said, "I got a goal, and it's a huge goal, and that's to bring an NBA championship here to Cleveland, and I won't stop until I get it."
Now, I said that we should treat these type of statements, whether from a player, coach, or owner, the same way we would campaign promises from a politician. There's a reason why the dreaded "vote of confidence" is such a joke - because it almost always means the guy is toast. But you can't say that LeBron never indicated he would stay.
And his interview with Larry King, on national TV - in June, just one month before leaving:
KING: So it has to be a good team?
JAMES: Absolutely.
KING: All right. Do you lean at all toward the place you know the best? I mean do they have an edge going in...
JAMES: Oh, absolutely.
KING: -- your home team?
JAMES: Absolutely. Because, you know, this city, these fans, I mean, have given me a lot in these seven years. And, you know, for me, it's comfortable. So I've got a lot of memories here. And -- and so it does have an edge. But it's a -- it's a very -- it's going to be a very interesting summer and I'm looking forward to it.
...
KING: OK. So I'm not going to put words in your mouth. All things being equal, is Cleveland sort of sentimentally the favorite?
JAMES: Oh, absolutely. And it's a -- it's a Cleveland-Akron team, because I grew up in Akron. I mean Akron is less than 30 miles south of Cleveland. So, absolutely. My whole family is here. You know, when I played high school basketball, where I grew up, in the projects, a lot of -- a lot of things mean home for me here. And -- and it's not just about the basketball court.
So yeah, he can say that Cleveland
was the favorite, but then he changed his mind. Or you can say that he told a white lie on Larry King, saying it was his favorite but he didn't really mean it. But he certainly made plenty of public statements indicating that Cleveland was where we would/wanted to be. In any event, it just doesn't cast him a good light no matter how you cut it.
"A society that puts equality - in the sense of equality of outcome - ahead of freedom will end up with neither equality nor freedom. The use of force to achieve equality will destroy freedom" Milton Friedman, Free to Choose