Shoe wrote:So Marcus Smart might sign for 4/46. A winning player getting $20 million less than Ian Mahinmi.
I hate the Mahinmi contract as much as everyone else, but it's not fair to compare playing signings in this cash-strapped offseason to signings made during an offseason when there was more cap room available than in any year in NBA history.
I really like the Celtics keeping Smart. They were gonna have to choose between Smart and Rozier (or Kyrie) sooner or later; and I think Smart, signed in this offseason, is going to be a better contract that what Rozier is gonna get offered next year when everyone has money. I also think that Smart is a more versatile player who can find a way to fit in on that Celtics team regardless of who is on the floor with him. He can play and defend the 1, 2 and 3, either alongside Kyrie or in place of him. Also, he can replace Kyrie and give Boston a crazy defensive lineup where they can effortlessly switch 1 through 5. Basically, you can find 25-30 minutes a game for Smart, even on that stacked team.
Rozier is exclusively a PG (or an undersized SG). He's fine as Kyrie's backup, but he's not nearly as versatile or as effective as Boston's other options when playing alongside Kyrie because Boston loses their trademark defensive switchability when playing two diminutive guards. It would be tough to pay him $12-15M a year only to play the 14 minutes that Kyrie sits.
Also, by keeping Smart, Ainge retains the flexibility of trading Kyrie or letting him walk if his upcoming contract looks too expensive. Boston may discover that Tatum and Hayward give them enough offense that Kyrie is no longer necessary.
If Ainge ultimately intends to keep Kyrie, watch him trade Rozier for an expiring and a pick early this season. Ainge never lets an asset go to waste.