nate33 wrote:prime1time wrote:So your grand plan is to hold our rookie draft picks and role players to unrealistic expectations? Then when they fall short of these expectations move on from them. If it's any consolation, it looks like you'll get your way.
Yes. That's what good teams do. They assess their draft pick over the first 3 years and decide whether they can envision that guy as a plus player on the next contract or not. If they think the guy is nothing better than an MLE level player, they cut bait and move on. If they can get a little value for him before letting him go, all the better. Consider the top 25 picks from the 2017 draft:
1 PHI Markelle Fultz - Wasn't working out in Philly - Traded for Tyrese Maxey. Resigned by ORL at $17M/yr
2 LAL Lonzo Ball - Traded for Anthony Davis. Ultimately was not resigned by New Orleans.
3 BOS Jayson Tatum - Obvious star. Retained and signed to max.
4 PHO Josh Jackson - Phoenix unloaded him in his 3rd season for a 2nd. Now a journeyman on his 3rd team.
5 SAC De'Aaron Fox - Looked like a possible star. Resigned to a max and is now overpaid
6 ORL Jonathan Isaac - Looked like a quality starter. Resigned to a $17M/yr deal but is always hurt.
7 MIN Lauri Markkanen - Chicago opted not to retain. Signed with Cleveland for $17M/yr. Decent player.
8 NYK Frank Ntilikina - NY did not retain. Signed with Dallas for vet minimum. Not in rotation.
9 DAL Dennis Smith Jr. - NY did not retain. Waived twice. A bust.
10 SAC Zach Collins - Portland did not retain. Signed by SA for $7M/yr. Played 173 minutes so far.
11 CHO Malik Monk - Charlotte did not retain. Signed by Lakers for vet minimum. Useful bench player.
12 DET Luke Kennard - Traded for Saddiq Bey in his 3rd season. Resigned by LAC at $14M/yr to come off bench.
13 DEN Donovan Mitchell - Obvious star. Retained and signed to max.
14 MIA Bam Adebayo - Obvious star. Retained and signed to max.
15 POR Justin Jackson - Traded twice and waived. Now on 10-day contract
16 CHI Justin Patton - Traded twice and waived. Now on 10-day contract
17 MIL D.J. Wilson - 3 lousy years in Milwaukee, then traded for PJ Tucker. Then waived.
18 IND T.J. Leaf - a bust.
19 ATL John Collins - Borderline star. Retained by Atlanta at $25M a year but is now being shopped
20 POR Harry Giles - A bust. Out of the league
21 OKC Terrance Ferguson - A bust. Out of the league
22 BRK Jarrett Allen - Awesome player for Brooklyn. Traded for James Harden. Resigned by CLE at $20M/yr
23 TOR OG Anunoby - Quality starter for Toronto. Resigned at $17M a year. Good value.
24 UTA Tyler Lydon - A bust. Out of league.
25 ORL Anžejs Pasečņiks - A bust. Out of the league.
Of those 25 players, only 7, Tatum, Fox, Isaac, Mitchell, Adebayo, J.Collins, and Anunoby, were retained by the team that drafted them. All of them were better than Rui is now. Tatum, Mitchell and Adebayo were superstars and no-brainers to resign at max contracts. Anunoby was a value signing. Fox, Isaac and J.Collins are useful players but probably overpaid.
There are 6 other rotation-caliber players from that group: Fultz, Ball, Markkanen, Monk, Kennard, Allen. The rest are busts or journeymen. Of those rotation-caliber players, Allen and Ball are clearly better than Rui and are therefore not really a comparison for Rui. And Monk was resigned for the vet-minimum which isn't really a risk for the signer so he is not a comparison either.
I'd say the players from that draft class that probably resemble Rui's situation are Markkanen, Kennard, and Fultz. All 3 demonstrated that they were legit NBA players, but it was far from certain whether they projected to be quality starters or not. Markkanen and Fultz were signed for $17M. Kennard, $15M. Are any of those teams particularly happy with those signings? I doubt it.
The point is, if the player isn't clearly a starting-caliber player by the end of his rookie deal, it's not wise to resign him to significant money and then hope and pray.
You can do the same analysis from the 2016 draft class. Guys that weren't obvious stars or clear starters (Simmons, Ingram, Brown, Murray, Sabonis, Poeltl) ended up being disappointing on their second contract (Hield, Prince, LeVert, Beasley).
prime1time wrote:We are all frustrated, but when your frustration has a negative impact you should take a stepback and become introspective. It is your mentality that leaves the Wizards mired in mediocrity. It's why we moved on from Troy Brown Jr. way to early. Why Kelly Oubre has been gone for years and is just entering his prime. Why Otto Porter Jr. was overpaid and ultimately traded for nothing.
These examples only prove my point, not yours.
We moved on from Troy Brown and it was the right move. The guy hasn't done anything. Instead, we turned him into a better player. Otto Porter was resigned, but for too much money, which ended up being a mistake. It created a luxtax problem that ultimately resulted in us dumping Oubre and then Porter himself. Fortunately, dumping Porter turned out to be a good move because injuries sapped his ability. I was upset that we dumped Oubre because of the Porter mismanagement, but even that turned out to be not such a problem. Oubre has bounced around as a free agent since. The real problem was that we dumped Oubre under duress. If we could have turned him into a future 1st, it would have been a good move.