Chocolate City Jordanaire wrote:I've never coached anything more than an intramural sports team. I shouldn't be so quick to criticize Flip Saunders. That said, it seems to me to be common sense that a coach shouldn't try to change the identity of players to fit the coach's mentality or system.
I've been saying for a while now that Flip doesn't seem like a great coach for Arenas, Butler, Young, or McGee; and it's because IMO he's asking all of them to be something they are not.
I'm not sure it's possible to have "the right kind of coach" for Arenas, Butler and Young, and also have a team that plays consistent defense. It's difficult to run a loosy-goosy offensive system that allows those guys to improvise, while also having a structured defense. Flip pointed out in the beginning of the season that it's hard to defend well when you take quick shots on offense.
You need to pick your poison. We tried it the other way with a freewheeling offense and we were an exciting but woefully inconsistent team. Now we'll try it Flip's way and hopefully be more consistent, though maybe with lower high points. If you don't like it, then the solution might be to trade one of Arenas/Butler (presumably Butler) rather than look for a type of coach that doesn't exist.
By the way, I don't think McGee belongs in that group of guys you mentioned. If anything, McGee will fare better under Flip than EJ. McGee has the skills to one day be a very effective as a pick-and-roll big man, whereas I don't think he could ever be a Princeton center. McGee isn't getting minutes right now under Flip because his defensive fundamentals are so bad. That condition won't persist forever.