nate33 wrote:NatP4 wrote:Did we discuss the fact that an Oklahoma State team, without Cunningham, beat a top 10 ranked West Virginia team? Maybe his teamates aren’t actually that bad?
It’s been very strange to me that we don’t give Evan Mobley the same “plays on a bad team” pass. USC is horrible. No guard play, awful coaching. Mobley still puts up terrific numbers.
To me, it's not about their numbers. It's about the eye test. I can see Cade Cunningham can fill the SF position (or the SG position) in the NBA right away. He has the necessary physical profile and shooting ability that his success is guaranteed. For him, the only question is whether or not he's merely an above-average starter like an Otto Porter, or a star like a Jason Tatum or Paul George. But there is virtually zero bust risk.
I love Evan Mobley, and I agree that his stats are just as impressive as Cunningham's, but that frame and his rebounding ability are red flags (or yellow flags, at least) that can't be ignored. If he was built stronger and grabbing 11-12 boards per 36, he'd be a no-brainer top pick in the Tim Duncan/Anthony Davis mold. But the possibility exists that his lack of strength and toughness will significantly detract from his NBA potential. Instead of Davis, maybe he's merely Myles Turner or Nerlens Noel.
We must be using different eye tests. I guess I could see Mobley turning into Nerlens freaking Noel if he lost his offensive ability and basketball IQ entirely.
And Cunningham turning into Paul George if he suddenly became an above the rim athlete with a 40 inch vertical.
I actually love the Tatum comparison for Cunningham. Doesn’t actually help his team win all that much. Not super efficient, doesn’t make teamates better. Tatum contributes to Ws because he is a solid defender. Not sure if Cunningham will actually be that at the next level. Bust risk? Nope, but the discussion is about how much these 3 players contribute to Ws.
Again, Suggs&Mobley have the floor of being elite on the defensive end.
What makes Cunningham a better prospect than a guy like Moody? Or Jalen Green even? Green is a much better athlete with slashing and defensive potential. Moody has more ability to play off the ball in a low usage role.