Dat2U wrote:hands11 wrote:Nivek wrote:The Wizards misplayed their hand when they struck quick to "lock up" Maynor. It would have been a bad move all by itself, even if these other PGs had signed MLE deals. That they're signing for the BAE (and less) just highlights how poorly conceived their off-season strategy was.
Just for kicks, here's the PPA for Maynor and for the other backups who have signed recently (average = 100, higher is better; replacement level = 45):
Maynor -- 32
Maynor (last healthy season) -- 57
Collison -- 116
Robinson -- 105
Price -- 84
Temple -- 60
Maybe Ernie had a vacation scheduled and wanted to get "sign backup PG" off the "honey do" list Ted gave him when the season ended.
Price really wasn't that great at running the offense. He did his best work once Wall returned and he was playing more like a SG at PG.
Wizards wanted a back up that could run the team so as to make other players better.
Thats a harder stat to extract. Would have to run numbers using 5 man line up with and with out those players are PG. Something like that. AST% would be a decent number as well.
Plus Maynor has experience being on the floor and doing well with other star PGs like Wall.
Not sure if your PPA number captures everything that is needed to do a comparison. And we don't know that Nate or Collison wanted to sign here.
You know what's harder to extract? Talent where it doesn't exist. Making guys like Vesely, Seraphin, Singleton & Booker look like competent NBA players is not going to be done by some scrub PG. To acquire a PG for that specific purposes borders on insanity. You want to make the bench better? Get better players and stop looking for "super smart" ways to save devalued assets that simply need to be dumped at this stage.
Ah, the insanity position. An oldie but a goodie.
Yeah, I think they know they want to have better players. I think that is what they tried to do by getting Maynor over Price. Maynor is better at running a team then Price was. He also has experience playing with stud PGs who can score.
From that list above, Temple is still with us, and who says Nate or Collison wanted to play for the Wizards this year. Nate went to Denver and Collison to LAC. Both established playoff teams. Wizards don't have that track record in recent memory. Plus LA is a place a lot of players like to go.
Maynor is a 30% AST% and 7 Ast per 36 player. 6-3 26 years old. decent 3 pt shooter.
Am I doing back flips over getting Maynor. No. Not freaking out either.