nate33 wrote:How many burly, post-up shooting guards are still in the league? Joe Johnson, Kobe Bryant, Vince Carter, Tyreke Evans, Brandon Roy and Brandon Rush are the only ones that come to mind. There are a few other tall SG's, but they're mostly finesse players who stay out on the wings. I don't think size differential will be a factor when Arenas tries to guard guys like Rudy Fernandez, Kevin Martin, Ray Allen and Manu Ginobili. Arenas also won't have trouble with the defensive specialist SG's like Thabo, Parker, Afflalo and Courtney Lee. That just leaves the short SG's who are roughly Arenas' size: J.Terry, Ben Gordon, Jamal Crawford, J.J. Redick, etc.
So really, I guess my biggest concern with Arenas defending SG's is my same concern with Arenas defending PG's. Arenas hasn't shown that he is capable of being a consistently good defender at any position.
1) Dwayne Wade is pretty big and strong although most guards aren't quick enough to keep up with him either.
2) For every old guy that appears to be on their way out, rookies like Evan Turner enter the league who could be a bigger shooting guard
3) Caron Butler is one of the bigger shooting guards although it would be laughable to see him try to guard Arenas or John Wall
4) What about simply taller shooting guards like Kevin Martin or Richard Hamilton that can constantly shoot over Arenas with their height advantage? Those players also worry me because they are catch and shoot players.
5) Stephen Jackson, although he's naturally a small forward, plays shooting guard since they already have Gerald Wallace.
But yeah, Arenas will have problems defending some SGs not because he's defficient in height but because he's a ball watcher and gives up open shots, but also doesn't do a good job in general slowing down penetration against quicker guards.