payitforward wrote:As to "can't shoot," look... Ben Simmons scores more points than an average PG. He scores those points at a significantly higher level of efficiency than an average point guard -- measured by his TS%, which was 58.7% last season. That's all that matters.
No. That is not all that matters. You keep saying this as if, by repeating it, it becomes true. Shooting a high percentage from the perimeter is more helpful than shooting a high percentage near the basket because the threat of a perimeter shot creates space for teammates.
Ben Simmons is an very good player. But because of his shooting limitations, a team must compensate by finding a good shooter from a position that one doesn't normally expect to find good shooting - which means the center must be a passable 3pt shooter instead of a non-shooter, or the PF must be an elite 3pt shooter instead of an adequate one. Generally, it's harder to find bigs who are both good shooters and good defenders. Having Simmons on the floor means you are sacrificing either shooting or defense at other positions.
Zach Lowe sums it up nicely here:
https://www.espn.com/nba/story/_/page/zachlowe26715213/can-sixers-win-big-ben-simmonsIn the playoffs, the Sixers were forced to put Simmons in the "dunkers spot" because there was no where else to put him. He couldn't run pick-and-roll because teams went under screens, and he couldn't stand in the corner because teams wouldn't guard him. All he could do was lurk on the weakside baseline, which is usually a place reserved for a center - who is the one guy you're willing to "hide" on offense because he is so valuable defensively.