lastemp3ror wrote:... I think saying Sheppard is great or bad is a bit early. However, if we had to decide at this moment, I don't see how anyone can say that he is good or great....
Key point: given the mess Tommy was handed, it's way too early to draw any definitive conclusions. But, this seems way overstated:
lastemp3ror wrote:...His draft picks haven't performed as of yet. He has only corrected his mistakes with trades/free-agent signings. I think the Wall for Westbrook trade was a net positive but then the trade for Aaron Holiday was a net negative.......
You are way underestimating the Wall for Westbrook trade -- esp. since it really has to be viewed based on the rest of what happened with Westbrook.
We agree about the Holiday trade -- bad when made, worse given the net now. But, come on, it pales in comparison with his having turned the worst contract in the NBA into a bunch of young players & couple of picks.
& you are overstating how bad his picks are. Tho... in truth you leave out some missed opportunities in the draft! So overall I can't give his draft performance anything more than a C, maybe a C-.
That said, Avdija is a terrific young player, & Kispert looks to have been an excellent pick at his spot. Rui is still an open question, although he looks better than he did last year.
lastemp3ror wrote:I will say, if he doesn't trade Beal, for me, he will be labeled a bad GM. No chance this team is a contender with Beal on a large/max contract. I also don't really care if it is him calling the shots or Ted. That is all hearsay and I can only judge him by what the responsibilities of his position are, and that is to manage the personnel on the team.
There's also no chance that trading Beal will make us a contender. We are a rebuilding team, & Tommy knows it.