Let's see what Ernie Grunfeld did well
1. When he first signed Gilbert Arenas to his first contract; there were a fair share of experts who thought the Wizards spend too much. I was ecstatic having read about Gilbertology and having gone to Wizards/Warriors game where he dropped 40+.
2. Giving up Laron Profit and Kwame Brown for Caron Butler. He also signed Caron Butler to an extension, which many called as excessive but Butler is on one of the best contracts in the league.
3. Signing Brendan Haywood to that extension. As Nate has pointed out, Haywood is valuable construction block for the Wizards.
4a and 4b. Getting DeShawn for the minimum (before he signed his extension) and Roger Mason for cheap.
5. Ernie's drafting has been above average. Yes he completely missed out in the 2006 in Pecherov. But he has found gems in the second round like Blatche and McGuire, and McGee and Young have tons of potential; so who knows.
Dat2U wrote:I think it goes to say something more about the type of GM Ernie Grunfeld is. While he is a capable executive, he's not particularly good at managing the cap or making the best financial decisions.
People praised the trade which acquired Jamison years back as it helped make the team respectable but the cost was steep. Not only did it cost a high draft pick but Jamison made in upwards of $14 mil per season. As opposed to having a top five pick on a rookie contract (like Iggy or Deng). Jamison has certainly been productive but his burdensome salary has limited financial flexibility since he's been here.
EG doled out expensive and overpriced contracts to the likes of AD, Darius & DeShawn. They were paid above market value and got more years than anyone else was offering. DeShawn's & Darius' deals were particularly bad b/c EG was bidding against himself. There was no market for either to get those type of pay days.
This board loved to point to EG not re-signing Hughes or Jeffries to overpriced deals as evidence of him being wise and financially prudent, but everyone fails to note, EG actually tried to resign both of them.
I cut EG a break on Etan's deal b/c by all accounts, Pollin was instrumental in the Wizards matching the Bucks offer. I also don't criticize EG for resigning Gil & AJ last season. Gil needed to be resigned b/c he's the only player we have that's a capable 1st option and that's the most important piece to building a franchise. As for Jamison, I didn't think it made sense to lose him for nothing although I'd wish he get dealt now.
However EG did it again with the Foye & Miller trade. Some point the money saved this season by not having to pay the salary of a top five pick. However to me that's penny wise and pound foolish. Miller & Foye are basically one year rentals who will be looking for paydays next season. And you all probably know my stance on overpaying role players. There's value in having a guy on a rookie contract. Both 1st rounders & 2nd rounders. That's were you can save money and improve at the same time. If EG doesn't trust his eye for drafting talent then maybe he shouldn't be the one making those decisions.
I actually don't think that the Jamison trade was all that bad. The only franchise player that was visible turned out to be Dwight Howard. Yes, EG overpaid for Jamison but he did become a two time all star; I don't think anyone other than Dwight Howard has made more than 1 all star appearance up to this point. Without Jamison, Arenas wouldn't have gotten to the playoffs in 2004-05; wouldn't have hit a game winner against the Bulls; and it probably would have taken him longer to develop. BTW, I would have loved to have Andre Iguodala but I guess it was better than someone like Josh Childress. Jamison did fill a need; certainly turned out better than the Wizards draft picks prior to Ernie's arival (ie Kwame, the 0-Face, and Jarvis).
I actually think the Wizards got their fair value for Antonio Daniels. He could have lasted longer as Arenas's backup. However, Daniels wore down playing starter's minutes when he was well past his prime. He would have been very valuable to Wizards if he rested during the regular season and played in the postseason. Yes, the deal was 1 year too long, but that was the only reason that Daniels chose the Wizards over other teams; IIRC, his other suitor was the LA Lakers.
With DeShawn, I really can't get too upset. It was simply a move to appeal one Mr. Arenas from leaving. After all, the Wizards main problem was on the defensive end, and the Wizards had lost their best perimeter defenders in the past two years. I can't defend the Darius signing. To my recollection, Grunfeld was bidding against himself. Although he did suffer a back injury which really limited his effectiveness.
You should also remember that the 4 overpaid players you mentioned help carried the Wizards to the playoffs without a healthy Arenas. They had a pretty good chance to make it to the finals in 2007 had Gilbert and Butler not gone for the year. I'm guessing Gilbert would have left if the Wizards struggled as much as they did in 08-09.
On Etan Thomas, you have to blame EG. Although I'm guessing Etan still would have been serviceable if it wasn't for his heart complications and not as hard to trade in a league which lacks quality big men.
On the Foye/Miller trade, I would wait and see. I want to see if Ernie can lock up Haywood or Foye even before the season starts; that's a more important priority than getting someone like Rasho Nestoveric. If Randy Foye can play like he did in January of 2009, this will turn out to be a great deal. Miller/Foye should improve the backcourt depth.
And let's see how the Ricky Rubio saga unfolds; if he's star or he's all hype like Brandon Jennings claims. Or if the Wizards missed out on someone like Steph Curry. If Pech actually becomes a serviceable player as CCJ claims. Time will tell.