would you do it?

[Alyosha12]

Hey guys i'm new to NBA fantasy and am still learning so i need some help:
I've been proposed a trade:

Josh Smith for:

Hedo Turkoglu and Grant Hill

Would you do it? I am in a H2H league btw with FG%, FT%, 3PTM, PTS, REB, AST, ST, BLK, TO

[Alex_De_Large]

Your player is Josh? i wouldn't do it. If the league is of 26 teams or more, then maybe yes, because you need minutes and 2 good players are better than 1, but if the league is of 16, 18, 20, 22 or even 24, then Josh is much more valuable.

I think Hill have serious problems with injuries still and will not start for Phx this year, and also Hedo had a perfect year last season and i doubt he can repeat that, it should be Lewis year in the Magic.

[jorgo]

Keep/take Josh Smith.

One thing that new people don't understand in 10-12 ppl leagues, is that 2 for 1 deals are not as good as they seem (if you're getting 2 players).

Whoever gets the Best Player in the deal pretty much always wins out, as the 2nd player can be replaced by someone of decent quality on the waiver wire.

[Alyosha12]

Tnx for the help guys:) you have been very helpful:)

[Curtis Lemansky]

Keep Josh,in a keeper league he is a top 15 player easily.