Stoudemire/Allen/Harrington for Wallace/Hibbert

[Spicy P]

- It's a keeper league, head to head, 10 people. I'm the one receiving Stoudemire, Allen and Harrington

Here's my current roster:

PG Derrick Rose (Chi - PG) This player is a keeper. Player notes
SG Kevin Martin (Hou - SG) New player notes
G Evan Turner( Phi - SG,SF) No new player Notes
SF Gerald Wallace (Cha - SF,PF) This player is a keeper. New player notes
PF Lamar Odom (LAL - SF,PF) Player notes
F Joe Johnson (Atl - SG,SF) Player notes
C Roy Hibbert( Ind - C) Player notes
C Brook Lopez (NJ - C) This player is a keeper. New player notes
Util O.J. Mayo (Mem - SG) This player is a keeper. No new player Notes
Util Mike Bibby (Atl - PG) New player notes
BN Arron Afflalo (Den - SG) New player notes
BN J.J. Hickson (Cle - PF,C) Player notes
BN Zach Randolph (Mem - PF,C) This player is a keeper. Player notes
BN Greg Oden (Por - C) INJ No new player Notes

[DonKilluminati]

Considering Roy Hibbert's production may go down as reality catches up to him, I'd def. do it.

Stoudemire + Allen + Harrington > Wallace + Hibbert

imo anyways, even counting current production.

[Starkiller]

If you do this trade you should be a lock on 3's.

[FantasyMVP]

I think Wallace and Hibbert have more value than the Stoudamire package. I do think that Stoudamire is the best player in this deal though, so I still would probably do it.

[Spicy P]

I gain quite a bit of scoring and threes, but I lose some shot-blocking (which I'm really lacking) and rebounding. I'd definitely do this trade in real life, but it's tough from a fantasy perspective. I know a lot of people think Hibbert won't maintain these numbers, but I think he could do it. Stoudemire has really been stinking it up too, especially with his shooting and turnovers.

Tough decision, but with 3 people saying I should do it, I might have to.