Two trades proposed to me

[tartans97]

I just got two trade proposals from two different teams.
I'm in a H2H league with 8 teams, 9 cats.

A:
Andre Iguodala + Al Horford + Kyrie Irving
for Tony Parker + Zach Randolph + Carmelo Anthony

B:
Ray Allen + David West + Monta Ellis
for Gerald Wallace + Omer Asik + Rajon Rondo

My team:
Steve Nash (LAL - PG)INJ
Tony Parker (SA - PG)
Rajon Rondo (Bos - PG)
Jordan Crawford (Was - PG,SG)
DeMar DeRozan (Tor - SG,SF)
Gerald Wallace (Bkn - SF,PF)
Carmelo Anthony (NY - SF,PF)INJ
Zach Randolph (Mem - PF,C)
LaMarcus Aldridge (Por - PF,C)
Dwight Howard (LAL - C)
Tyson Chandler (NY - C)
Brook Lopez (Bkn - C)INJ
Omer Asik (Hou - C)


Right now I lead the league in PG%, PTS, and REB.
My FT%, 3PT, and STL are very weak.

I'm more into proposal A since I can get some 3PT, AST, STL, BLK while giving up some PTS and a little bit REB.
However, I have concerned about the health history of Al Horford and Kyrie Irving.

What do you guys think about these two trades?

Thanks.

[mhi]

I wouldn't either of them.

AI, Hortford and Irving, All of them fail to dominate a caterigory excpet for Irving who can shoot high FG%. But you already have that with Carmelo. You would be giving up a dominant rebounder in Zach but getting no one dominant back. You have a lot of centers so there is no need to take one back in a trade.

The second one is actually good for all the categories you need but the problem would be giving up Rondo, so I would counter with Nash in Rondo's place.

To fix your team, you should deal a center for a 3PT shooter and they usually shoot high FT% as well. Monta Ellis or Irving you should target.

So Asik, Wallace for Monta or Randolph for Irving (When he comes back)

[Apathy]

First one's kind of close.

What you really need to do is trade Dwight for anything. 70, 80 cents on the dollar. You have too many Cs.

You can also use Melo as bait to shore up the weaker spots on your roster (DeRozan, Crawford, Wallace, a 3rd PG, Dwight).