RealGM

10 team roto league. NO turnovers category.

team a gives: durant, josh smith, jason kidd
team b gives: paul, richardson, randolph

my team now:
chris paul
chauncey billups
jason terry
jameer nelson
jason richardson
caron butler
richard jefferson
jodie meeks
grant hill
zach randolph
david lee
marcus camby
elton brand
andrew bynum

What do you think?

Sorry, but I don't like it for your team.

First off, CP3 doesn't hold THAT much high of a value on your league since you guys don't have TO on your category.

Second, J-Smith and Kidd are top 15-30 fantasy players. You gave up guys who can single handedly carry your team's scoring (durant), blocks and FG% (J-smith) and Assists (kidd).

Thanks man - though you got it wrong: i will be getting durant, kidd, and smith, not the other way around. So I should go and get them?

I would do the deal as Durant is still Durant, and Smith has quickly become a 1st round talent. So your getting two top of the line elite studs for pretty much 1 in the deal. While not losing much depth in the first place.

It's a pretty good trade!

melege wrote:Thanks man - though you got it wrong: i will be getting durant, kidd, and smith, not the other way around. So I should go and get them?

OK.. do it.

Do it, you're essentially trading 3 injury prone players for 3 healthier players.