RealGM

Augustin
Pts 12.7
Reb 3.4
Ast 6.3
Fg % 42.4
To 1.7
Stl 0.6

Jennings
Pts 18.5
Reb 4.0
Ast 5.3
Fg % 39.5
To 2.4
Stl 1.2

Who would you pick in a FG%,FT%,3PTM,3PT%,PTS,OREB,DREB,REB,AST,ST,BLK,TO Fantasy League?

Jennings. But not by a large margin. That +6 in PPG and +.6 spg advantage by Jennings can't compensates Augustins' +1 in apg and 3% FG%.

Also take into account that Augustin shoots 90% from the FT line whereas jennings is 75%

Definitely Augustin. His efficiency far exceeds Jennings' larger point totals.