RealGM

I am not posting my team or his because it is irrelavant. I offered him Gortat and JR and this goof sent me a counter saying it is a terrible trade and countered with Gortat+JR for Manu and some scrub... I want to know what people feel about this offer.

Pre season ranking for Gortat was 39 current rank is 41, preseason rank for JR Smith was 88, current ranking is 45, Brook Lopez preseason rank was 81 current rank is 31, JJ preseaon rank was like 45 current rank is 99.

If you just go my preseason ranking it is a 39+88 for a 45+81
If you just go my current ranking it is a 41+45 for a 31+99

I dont care if you dont like the players I want to know if this is a fair offer or a completely one sided Durant for Derozan esque trade

Oh and it is a standard 9 cat yahoo league

Incomplete

How are you going to go in so much detail yet u can't list the 2nd player in the trade?

I think it was Manu and Avery Bradley... for JR smith and Gortat... but how about the trade I posted

Fair-looking proposal, but I'm certainly taking the Lopez side.

Exactly. I have no beef that he did not want the trade I have beef that he's bitching saying I spammed a bad deal at him. I sent it twice and the second time I said was only so he could look at the numbers. If I wasn't commish I would have bitched this guy out hard

Welcome to the Internet.

I'm taking that Lopez side all day but I he shouldn't blame you for want to sell high on JR and buy low on JJ. Some people just only look and the rankings and base value solely on that.