RealGM

My team:
PG: Chris Paul, Grievis Vasquez, Jason Kidd
SG:JJ Reddick, Jose Calderon, Paul George
SF: Danny Green, MWP
PF: Paul Millsap, Joakiam Noah, Kenneth Faried
C: Roy Hibbert, Larry Sanders

8 teams, 9 cat roto

Who do you think is better ?

It's a weighted question because I don't have your league info/settings

Calderon is a very efficient player with questionable minutes

Wall is not efficient but has the keys to the franchise

TheToothFairy wrote:It's a sighted question because I don't have your league info/settings

Calderon is a very efficient player with questionable minutes

Wall is not efficient but has the keys to the franchise

Edited it.

John Wall. He's got more potential and Calderon is sharing minutes with Lowry.

Well if it's roto I like Calderon, but why do u need 4 PG's ?

Ya don't think you should have 4 point guards, especially since you have cp3 and Vasquez who get a ton of assists, combined with Kidd getting anywhere from 4-8 you should be winning assists often.

But for your question, it depends on whether you need improvement in stat production (pts, rebounds, assists) vs. efficiency (fg%, 3pt%, and less TO).

Calderon is a lot more efficient, but Wall might have a very big production edge especially since Lowry will be getting more time than Calderon since he is a better player.

Wall obv. Let him come back and sell him off. Everyone overrates Wall.

In a few weeks this thread is going to look silly. Calderon minutes are going sink down to at/below 20 mins with a healthy Lowry so unless he gets shipped off with Bargs, I don't see him retaining a ton of value long term.

Calderon will always be t100. He's been in seemingly **** situations for the past couple of years, but even coming off the bench 5+apg and 2 or fewer TOs always plays. Always always always.

And he's a strong bet to get traded.

I have no probs with Calderon, who is the perfect place-holder. Wall's just so ez to trade for value, though. Has connotations of name, upside and PPG.